Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: Southwest Shakespeare Company Presents THE MERCHANT OF VENICE ~ Virtual Classics Live

Review: Southwest Shakespeare Company Presents THE MERCHANT OF VENICE ~ Virtual Classics Live

These are the times that try the souls of theatre people. COVID-19 lockdowns have prompted inspired initiatives to stay visible and viable, to retain audience interest and engagement, and to practice and preserve one's art form muscles. With an eye to keeping theatre top of mind and artists top of form, many companies have gone virtual, offering "live" performances on their Facebook pages and YouTube channels.

In this spirit, Southwest Shakespeare Company has launched the Virtual Classics Live Series, the latest edition of which featured THE MERCHANT OF VENICE. (Showcased for live streaming on May 23rd, the program is available on the Company's Facebook page.)

To his great credit, Irwin Appel (the director of the production who also appears as Shylock the usurer) has assembled an impressive cast of accomplished performers from all across the United States, all seventeen of whom are situated in their Zoom rooms for the two hours and forty minutes reading.

If there's a gold prize for snagging one of Broadway's superstars, Patrick Page, to participate in the reading, pin it on Appel.

Page (Emmy Awardee, Tony Nominee and Grammy Award recipient for his role as Hades in Hadestown) brings an authority and intelligence to his performance as Antonio, the merchant imperiled by his obligation to Shylock, that resonates with every smooth utterance of his low bass voice.

Appel is in his own right an accomplished Shakespearean. The Professor of Theater and Chair of the Department of Theater and Dance at University of California Santa Barbara brings a distinguished background to the enterprise ~ as a versatile actor, founding artistic director of Naked Shakes, and the award-winning producer and director of The Death of Kings.

As celebrated as the gathering of such talents is, the production is, after all, a reading, to be differentiated in its particular attributes from a staged performance. This is not to be regarded as a criticism but it is rather an understanding of the limits of a critical review that might otherwise be applied to a staged performance.

The actors as readers sit in their rooms, a separation necessitated by forces beyond their control. They have been limited to one rehearsal the day before and, for the sake of time, lines have been cut. They are denied the dynamics of direct and physical interaction, the ability to eyeball each other, feel each other's presence, experience the chemistry that would infuse their performances with palpable energy. Each is left to their own interpretation of the lines. Some emote and wax eloquent; others are more subdued. All, however, have charged into the play with full commitment, conviction and vigor. If the nuances of character development and interpretation are denied, that's not the fault of direction but more of the inherent limitations of cyber-separation.

This is the reality of virtual, the technical limitations of Zoom and similar communications portals.

And yet, having offered these caveats, there is a resounding benefit to the reading. It is that we may instead concentrate on and really hear Shakespeare's words, discern his meanings, and wrestle with the play's ambiguities ~ unencumbered by the distractions of stage sets, sound, and lighting. If there's evidence to this effect, the proof is in the thirty-minute discussion among the actors following the reading. It is an intelligent, brilliant and stimulating exchange of ideas and interpretations of the work and the playwright's intentions.

Notwithstanding the above observations, I have now watched this virtual performance of THE MERCHANT OF VENICE twice! And, I have found it inspired, informative, and, as usual, provocative. And I can wholeheartedly recommend it as a worthwhile opportunity to delve into one of Shakespeare's most controversial plays.

To wit, is MERCHANT a play about anti-Semitism or is it an anti-Semitic play? What are we to feel for Shylock ~ sympathy or disdain? Is it a commentary on fidelity and the excesses of a mercantile culture? No doubt, MERCHANT, is in any case, a play with multi-layered themes that speak, among other topics, to privilege, bigotry, power, and justice ~ all themes that suggest relevance to issues of current times.

There are notable moments during the reading when it feels like the actors have crossed the divide between the Zoom rooms and seized the emotional moment.

There is Patrick Page's intense sense of sadness and desperation as he bears the burden of a debt unfulfilled and an affection necessarily suppressed for his kinsman, Bassanio (Zach Appelman).

There are the heady and wistful exchanges between Portia (Tracie Lane) and her lady-in-waiting Nerissa (Alison Campbell) about potential suitors.

There's the endearing exchange between Portia and Bassanio as he vies to unlock the door to her heart.

Then, too, the playful ruse at play's end when Portia and Nerissa catch Bassanio and Gratiano (Cameron Knight, a consistently balanced and attractive presence throughout the reading) in their failed deception.

There is Appel's painful rendering of Shylock's classic speech (Hath not a Jew hands, organs, dimensions, senses, affections, passions?) and his confusion and torment at the climactic trial.

And, finally, of course, there is the trial in which Tracie Lane's Portia, disguised as Balthazar the attorney, forcefully and mercilessly challenges Shylock's claims and frames the terms of justice.

For all their commitment and devotion to a vital and virtual reading of THE MERCHANT OF VENICE, I offer a hearty round of applause to Southwest Shakespeare Company and the full cast:

Salarino ~ Dathan B. Williams

Solanio ~ Kyle Sorell

Bassanio ~ Zach Appelman

Lorenzo ~ Walter Kmiec

Gratiano ~ Cameron Knight

Portia ~ Tracie Lane

Nerissa ~ Alison Campbell

Shylock ~ Irwin Appel

Prince of Morocco ~ Debra Ann Byrd (Founder/AD and AAD of Harlem Shakespeare Festival)

Launcelot Gobbo ~ John Way

Old Gobbo ~ Greg Whiteley (creator of Cheer and Last Chance U)

Leonardo ~ Cooper Bruhns

Jessica ~ Tadja Enos

Prince of Arragon ~ Jeff Mills

Tubal ~ David Ira Goldstein (also, Assistant Director)

Stephania ~ Sierra Hastings

Duke of Venice ~ Beau Heckman (also, Stage Directions)

Poster credit to Southwest Shakespeare Company

Southwest Shakespeare Company ~ ~ 55 E Main St, Mesa, AZ ~ 480-435-6868

From This Author - Herbert Paine

Herb Paine ~ Herb has served as Senior Contributing Editor and lead reviewer for BWW's Phoenix Metro Region since 2014. He has been acclaimed as BEST THEATRE CRITIC by PHOENIX magazin... (read more about this author)

Review: The Phoenix Theatre Company Presents Rodgers and Hammerstein's CINDERELLAReview: The Phoenix Theatre Company Presents Rodgers and Hammerstein's CINDERELLA
November 20, 2022

Chosen as its holiday season family special, this regional production of CINDERELLA, directed by Michael Barnard, is a prime example of the excellence that The Phoenix Theatre Company has developed over the years. Runs through January 1st.

Feature: THE OTHER SIDE OF THE SEA- Acts Of Conscience And Support On Behalf Of The People Of UkraineFeature: THE OTHER SIDE OF THE SEA- Acts Of Conscience And Support On Behalf Of The People Of Ukraine
November 16, 2022

Hsuan Yu Pan's THE OTHER SIDE OF THE SEA captures the human dimension of the tragedy in Ukraine and the response of New York's community of artists to raise awareness and support. The film will be showcased on December 16th at the Soapbox Gallery in Brooklyn.

Review: Douglas Morrione's FAIRWAYS TO HAPPINESS Goes OnlineReview: Douglas Morrione's FAIRWAYS TO HAPPINESS Goes Online
October 27, 2022

FAIRWAYS TO HAPPINESS is Doug Morrione's intriguing documentary that opens wider the doors of perception about happiness and the pathways to realizing it. The film goes online (iTunes, Amazon, Google Play) on November 17th.

Review: The Black Theatre Troupe Presents Robert O'Hara's BARBECUEReview: The Black Theatre Troupe Presents Robert O'Hara's BARBECUE
October 24, 2022

Directed by Ron May and featuring a pitch-perfect cast, The Black Theatre Troupe's production of Robert O'Hara's BARBECUE is a richly intelligent play and a definite must-see. Runs through November 6th.

Review: OKLAHOMA! at ASU GammageReview: OKLAHOMA! at ASU Gammage
October 21, 2022

A candid review of OKLAHOMA!, re-vamped and re-imagined for National Tour, currently playing at ASU Gammage, Tempe until Sunday, October 23. It is not the Rodgers and Hammerstein of your parents.