Mysteries have a way of following Fannie Miller. When she makes it to the finals of a baking contest and contestants start disappearing, she calls on part-time PI Foster Bates to help investigate. Are her fellow finalists trying to thin out the competition? Like the couple who need the prize money? Or the sisters who are always whispering? Fannie and Foster will stay on the case until the end—and everyone will learn something about baking contests, solving mysteries and life. A collaboration between best-selling authors Wanda E. Brunstetter and Martha Bolton, this delightful show from Blue Gate Musicals reunites Fannie Miller and Foster Bates, who were introduced in the popular show Stolen. The result is an intriguing musical comedy mystery. A rigged contest. A missing baker. A determined detective. The right recipe for total disaster!
Bird-in-Hand Stage is at 2760 Old Philadelphia Pike, Bird-in-Hand, PA.
The Christmas Candy Caper (10/30/25-12/27/25)
Stolen (8/12/25-10/22/25)
The Christmas Candy Caper (11/1/24-12/28/24)
Half Stitched. . .the Musical (8/13/24-10/24/24)
The Confession (4/4/24-8/3/24)
Our Christmas Dinner (10/26/23-12/30/23)
The Home Game (8/4/23-10/19/23)
Dear Soldier Boy (4/6/23-7/27/23)
Josiah for President (8/18/22-10/21/22)
A Simple Sanctuary (4/8/22-8/10/22)
The Christmas Candy Caper (10/30/25-12/27/25)
Videos
![]() |
Jane Lynch’s A Swingin’ Little Christmas featuring Kate Flannery, Tim Davis, and the Tony Guerrero Quintet
Keswick Theatre (12/2 - 1/2) | |
|
Family Magic Shows -@ 1 PM Saturdays | Best For Ages 6 - 106!
Smoke & Mirrors Theater in House of Magic (9/13 - 12/27) | |
|
Caesar
The Philadelphia Theatre Company (2/6 - 2/22) | |
|
The Anastasia Trials in the Court of Women
Temple Theaters (2/19 - 2/23) | |
|
Gino Mozzarella ♦ The Godfather of Magic
Smoke & Mirrors Theater in House of Magic (12/27 - 12/27) | |
|
Isaiah Collier & Keyon Harrold
Zellerbach Theatre (1/24 - 1/24) | |
|
Dog Sees God: Confessions of a Teenage Blockhead
Old Academy Players (1/9 - 1/25) | |
|
Kayhan Kalhor
Zellerbach Theatre (3/8 - 3/8) | |
| VIEW SHOWS ADD A SHOW | ||