Get theatre news and discounts for Off-Off-Broadway
 Speakeasy, Die Softly: Immersive Murder Mystery Dinner Theater at Carmine's show poster

Speakeasy, Die Softly: Immersive Murder Mystery Dinner Theater at Carmine's at Carmine's Italian Restaurant - Times Square

Dates: 11/8/2025 - 1/31/2026

Theatre:

Carmine's Italian Restaurant - Times Square

The Murder Mystery Co.

200 W 44th St
New York City,NY 10036

Phone: 8886592952


  1. View All Off-Off-Broadway Shows
  2.  > 
  3. Speakeasy, Die Softly: Immersive Murder Mystery Dinner Theater at Carmine's


The Dinner Show Everyone’s Dying To Attend… At Carmine’s in Times Square!

 

Speakeasy, Die Softly is the newest and most elaborate comedic immersive murder mystery ever performed by The Murder Mystery Company. During this killer show, guests will enjoy a three-course, family-style Italian feast in the newly renovated Sinatra Room at the legendary Carmine’s in Times Square.

 

The year is 1927, a time of flappers, mobsters, bootlegging, and countless seedy speakeasies.  Come on into Lou Zar’s and shimmy to the live music of the club’s famous songstress, Lucy Morals, and her accompanist, Keys Yacar, or, if you prefer, play some casino games and win big money you can blow on “soda pop.” Unfortunately, the fun can’t last all night– the feds have been sniffing around, so we need your help to flip the speakeasy into a “legitimate Italian restaurant” before the police raid the place. However, even amidst all these games, dames, and dons, someone had murder on their mind! You and your table team must help the detective solve the crime before the culprit escapes! But, beware… the killer could be anyone… even YOU!

 

The Murder Mystery Company created by Scott Cramton is an experiential entertainment company exploding with popularity after being recently featured on ABC’s “Shark Tank.” Come see what all the hype is about at the legendary Carmine’s in Times Square! 

 

Menu

Caesar Salad

Penne a la vodka

Chicken Parmigiana

Shrimp Scampi

Tiramisu and Cannoli 

 

Show Schedule

Friday Doors @ 7 pm

Saturday Afternoon Doors @ 4 pm

Saturday Night Doors @ 8 pm
Sunday Doors @ 5 pm

Monday Doors @ 7 pm

Speakeasy, Die Softly: Immersive Murder Mystery Dinner Theater at Carmine's at Carmine's Italian Restaurant - Times Square Schedule

Friday Doors @ 6 pm Saturday Afternoon Doors @ 3:30 pm Saturday Night Doors @ 7 pm Sunday Doors @ 4:30 pm Monday Doors @ 7 pm



Carmine's Italian Restaurant - Times Square Frequently Asked Questions FAQ

Videos


Broadway Magic Hour in Off-Off-Broadway Broadway Magic Hour
Broadway Comedy Club (9/30 - 12/30) Tracker
Nine Shadows in Bloom: A Devised Piece in Off-Off-Broadway Nine Shadows in Bloom: A Devised Piece
Chain Theatre (12/5 - 12/7) Tracker
PHOTOS DISCOUNT
A Christmas Carol: A Live Radio Play in Off-Off-Broadway A Christmas Carol: A Live Radio Play
Hampton Theatre Company (12/12 - 12/14) Tracker
Sins and Stardust Burlesque: Winter Wonderland in Off-Off-Broadway Sins and Stardust Burlesque: Winter Wonderland
Under St. Marks Theater (12/8 - 12/8) Tracker
Bette Davis Ain't For Sissies in Off-Off-Broadway Bette Davis Ain't For Sissies
Triad Theater (12/13 - 12/13) Tracker
Dance, Edita, Dance! in Off-Off-Broadway Dance, Edita, Dance!
The Factory Series @ The Chain Theatre (12/12 - 12/14)

OFF-OFF-BROADWAY PREMIERE Tracker
PHOTOS DISCOUNT
A Marble Christmas Concert: Everlasting Joy, Narrated by Simon Jones in Off-Off-Broadway A Marble Christmas Concert: Everlasting Joy, Narrated by Simon Jones
Marble Collegiate Church (12/14 - 12/14) Tracker
Blackbird By David Harrower in Off-Off-Broadway Blackbird By David Harrower
Theatre Row (12/2 - 12/7)

BUY NOW & SAVE LIMITED TICKETS REMAIN Tracker
PHOTOS VIDEOS DISCOUNT
Gloria Bangiola: “I Dreamed Last Night…” in Off-Off-Broadway Gloria Bangiola: “I Dreamed Last Night…”
Don’t Tell Mama (11/19 - 12/10)
Alternative Medicine’s Fool-Tide Greetings in Off-Off-Broadway Alternative Medicine’s Fool-Tide Greetings
The Theater Center (12/14 - 12/14)
Music and Theater Innovators in Off-Off-Broadway Music and Theater Innovators
Open Jar Studios (12/8 - 12/8)
The Dinner Detective Murder Mystery Dinner Show in Off-Off-Broadway The Dinner Detective Murder Mystery Dinner Show
The Dinner Detective NYC (12/20 - 12/20)
The Brothers Size in Off-Off-Broadway The Brothers Size
Ujima Theater Company (2/27 - 3/8)
VIEW SHOWS  ADD A SHOW