Review: THE MECCA TALES is a Heartbreaking Work of Healing Genius

Photography Credit: Beowulf Sheehan

Countering the perversion of terrorists who shout, "Allahu Akbar", Rohina Malik's mesmerizing new play THE MECCA TALES charts the journey of five disparate women as they make hajj. For true worshipers of Islam, hajj is a pilgrimage from which one returns purified. It is also a perilous journey rife with fatal consequences, the least of which includes deadly temperatures in a hostile terrain. This excellent co-production by Voyage Theater Company and Crossroads Theatre Company perfectly conveys why one would undertake such a risk.

Gulshan Mia in THE MECCA TALES
Photography Credit: Beowulf Sheehan

At first glance, MECCA's five women - the rich "bish", bossy lady, young gal, woman with a past, and tortured but kind mama - resemble a squad of bickering queens trapped on "Big Brother: Arabian Nights". Happily, Malik's writing moves swiftly in establishing why and what this journey means for each character while eschewing didacticism. Using a sly hand, Malik dispenses information through rapid fire though thoughtful humour and honest dialogue that flows naturally into conversation enriching monologues.

Jade Radford & Kimberly S. Fairbanks
Photography Credit: Beowulf Sheehan

Kareem Fahmy's direction, David Esler's scenic design, and Devorah Kengmana's lighting embrace this seamless quality by treating the show as if it were one beautiful dream sequence: what is seen is blurred with what is felt in perfect modulation, giving the play a cinematic feel while maintaining verisimilitude. Flashbacks unfurl as a character relives the past, and then recede as she is called back to the land of the living. Within this framework, Fahmy does an incredible job of charting the ever-shifting power dynamics between MECCA's characters by adjusting their positions and facings across the stage as if they were brushstrokes comprising a master painting. This vision is ably assisted by Fan Zhang's sensitive sound design and Theara Ward's deft choreography. Zhang and Ward treat their work with sparse religiosity that is effectively understated. One feels the sadness without hearing Zhang's subtle music until after tears have fallen; we recognize the dance behind each prayerful gesture only after its invocation has been completed. This is never more clear than during the stories of Maya and Grace.

Mariam Habib in THE MECCA TALES
Photography Credit: Beowulf Sheehan

In telling Maya's tragic story of a love that was born, consummated, and lost in three hours, Mariam Habib takes over and transforms the entire play into an epic worthy of Martha Graham. There is one particular moment - that must have been constructed by Ward - during which Habib is on the verge of collapsing with tears. Instead, she seizes her grief in a high contraction - imagine a knot of sorrow constricting your heart - and stands stone still as tears stream slowly down her face. Habib does not have to work herself into a frenzy or "make" herself cry; she simply stands and emits a pulse of empathy that reduces the audience to a chorus of naked sobs.

Kimberly S. Fairbanks in THE MECCA TALES
Photography Credit: Beowulf Sheehan

This sorrow gives way to Grace's resolution - Kimberly S. Fairbanks. Hajj is completed after a believer cuts a lock of their hair and buries it in the sand. Though Grace has led numerous pilgrimages, she has never completed this ceremony. Instead she punishes herself like an eager Sisyphus skipping up the hill, relishing in her anguish. Though Fairbanks is blessed with a commanding physical presence, one hears her more than one sees her. Hers is a vocal performance that transforms the simple text into a symphony. In that regard, Fairbanks is perfect in conveying the message embedded within MECCA: the religion of peace is built upon forgiveness and accepting one's self is to accept all.

Gulshan Mia and Cynthia Bastidas in THE MECCA TALES
Photography Credit: Beowulf Sheehan

It is undeniable that MECCA wraps things up too tidily, however that resolution - coming after a roller coaster of emotions - feels earned and gratifying. Like the production team, the entire cast is flawlessly marvelous. In particular, Louis Sallan - a malleable ball of specificity who distinguishes each of the many characters that he plays with a vibrant inner life worthy of a starring role, proving that there are no small parts - and Gulshan Mia - as the zesty diva who takes extreme pleasure in scoffing at others - are to be applauded. At curtain call I did something I have not done this calendar year: I joined the entire audience to give a well deserved standing ovation. I could have stood clapping all night.

THE MECCA TALES plays at The Sheen Center through Saturday November 4th. It is the best performance I have seen all year, on and Off-Broadway, in dance, music, or film. RUN to purchase tickets. For more information, visit:

RELATED STORIES - Off-Off-Broadway

LOVE IN BLOOM to be Presented at Universal temple of the Arts This Month

This year Universal Temple of the Arts is inviting theater lovers of all ages to enjoy the musical production, Love In Bloom, indoors at a brand new location on Sunday, June 25, 2023 at 7:00 pm at the Wagner College Theatre.

Broadway Dreams Launches 2023 Summer Intensive Tour IMMERSE YOURSELF

Broadway Dreams (Annette Tanner, Founder & President), a leading non-profit performing arts training program, is kicking off its 2023 Summer Intensive Tour “Immerse Yourself” this week in Nashville, TN.

Firebird Project Launches Adult Wing With ROSSUM'S UNIVERSAL ROBOTS

Firebird Youth Theater, the nucleus of The Firebird Project, made its debut in the Spring of 2013 as the first independent youth-led theater company in its founders' community.

Broadway-Inspired Draglesque Show THEATER CAMP To Return To Culture Lab LIC in June

Join Tulle Kit and friends for an evening of raunchy, campy, earnest, very queer musical theater inspired drag and burlesque at THEATER CAMP at Culture Lab, LIC. 

From This Author - Juan Michael Porter II

Juan Michael Porter II is the Managing Editor and  Critic-in-Residence of BroadwayWorld Dance. He writes and creates with a focus on engaging, entertaining, and educating the reader without ... (read more about this author)


#repshow# in[i]# The Dinner Detective Mystery Dinner Show
The Dinner Detective NYC (6/03-6/03)Tracker
#repshow# in[i]# LAST ROOM
Secret Studio (5/05-6/03)Tracker PHOTOS CAST
#repshow# in[i]# WORLD PREMIERE: Billy the Bomber
The Producer's Club (6/02-6/04)Tracker PHOTOS CAST
#repshow# in[i]# Charley's Aunt
Trinity Theatre (5/26-6/03)Tracker CAST
#repshow# in[i]# Pianist Jeeyoon Kim: music and poetry at Carnegie
Weill Recital Hall at Carnegie Hall (6/07-6/07)Tracker
#repshow# in[i]# ROWENA
Teatro Latea (5/30-6/03)Tracker
#repshow# in[i]# Rehearsal for Truth Theater Festival: Bowie in Warsaw
Bohemian National Hall (6/02-6/03)PHOTOS CAST
#repshow# in[i]# COWBOY
Actors Temple Theatre (3/04-10/29)
#repshow# in[i]# Live at the Gantries: Bartlett Contemporaries
Gantry State Plaza (7/18-7/18)
#repshow# in[i]# Jamel Gaines Creative Outlet Commemorates Juneteenth
Jamel Gaines Creative Outlet (6/18-6/18)

Recommended For You