Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: Theatre Three's I HATE HAMLET

By:

Review: Theatre Three's I HATE HAMLET Image

We all need a good laugh now-a-days and Theatre Three's production of Paul Rudnick's play I Hate Hamlet certainly delivers. The brilliant cast coupled with Mary Powers' clever direction brings roars of laughter throughout the production. Originally on Broadway in 1991, not without controversy, this incarnation runs through February 3rd at the gorgeous Port Jefferson venue.

The story centers on Andrew, an actor, who has moved to New York due to the cancelation of his television series. He's received an opportunity to star in a theatrical production of Hamlet, but he has no passion for the project (hence the name of the show). Ironically, he's purchased an apartment previously owned by former (and, perhaps, best) Hamlet... the great John Barrymore.

In an ensemble company filled with Theatre Three vets, Dylan Robert Poulos charmingly portrays Andrew who we see get increasingly frustrated which is well exude by Mr. Poulos. This is not only because he's upset about his former television show and everyone pushing him to do a project he doesn't want to do, but also because his doe-eyed actor girlfriend, Deidre, strongly portrayed by Jessica Contino, has committed to "save herself" for marriage and seems very naïve in the overall relationship forward. Oh, and also, during a séance, the ghost of Barrymore, portrayed remarkably by Steve McCoy, appears to help Andrew prepare for his performance in Hamlet.

The rest of the stellar cast is top notch as is Ms. Powers' superb creative team. Randall Parsons' New York City apartment set is gorgeous with the bi-level stage featuring vintage style pieces (wall art, couch, grand staircase, ext). This is beautifully enhanced by the stunning lighting design (Mr. McCoy's entrance is a highlight) by Robert W. Henderson, Jr. and the attractive costumes designed by Su Jung Lee Weaver.

And so, Paul Rudnick's I Hate Hamlet is certainly a hit for Port Jefferson's Theatre Three. If you need an escape to laugh and smile, this is your show. An extraordinary cast and hilarious story make for a truly entertaining night of theatre.


I Hate Hamlet is presented by Theatre Three of Port Jefferson, Long Island, through February 3rd. For more information and to purchase tickets, please call 631-928-9100 or visit www.theatrethree.com.

By Paul Rudnick, Directed by Mary Powers, Scenic Design by Randall Parsons, Costume Design by Su Jung Lee Weaver, Lighting Design by Robert W. Henderson, Jr., Properties by Linda May, Fight Choreography by Steven Uihlein, Stage Management by Alissa Graber

Starring Linda May, Dylan Robert Poulos, Jessica Contino, Marci Bing, Steve McCoy, Steve Ayle

Photo: The cast of I Hate Hamlet (clockwise from top right: Steve Ayle, Linda May, Dylan Robert Poulos, Jessica Contino, Marci Bing, and Steve McCoy)

Reader Reviews

Don't Miss a Long Island News Story
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...


BroadwayWorld TV


THE WEDDING SINGER in Long Island THE WEDDING SINGER
The John W. Engeman Theater (7/09-8/23)
Golden Girls The Laughs Continue in Long Island Golden Girls The Laughs Continue
Patchogue Theatre (10/09-10/09)
What's Cooking? With Pamela Morgan in Long Island What's Cooking? With Pamela Morgan
LTV Studios (8/23-8/23)
The 31st Annual Stony Brook Film Festival in Long Island The 31st Annual Stony Brook Film Festival
Staller Center for the Arts (7/16-7/25)
South Shore Theatre Experience present 15th Annual One Act Festival in Long Island South Shore Theatre Experience present 15th Annual One Act Festival
South Shore Theatre (9/04-9/04)
The Importance of Being Earnest in Long Island The Importance of Being Earnest
Theatre Three - NY (4/04-4/23)
Pinkalicious - The Musical in Long Island Pinkalicious - The Musical
Patchogue Theatre (10/25-10/25)
Cagney - The Musical in Long Island Cagney - The Musical
Bay Street Theater (6/30-7/26)
Jessica Vosk: Sleigh in Long Island Jessica Vosk: Sleigh
Staller Center for the Arts (12/11-12/11)
Disney Pixar’s Coco in Concert – Live to Film in Long Island Disney Pixar’s Coco in Concert – Live to Film
Staller Center for the Arts (10/30-10/30)