Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: TENDERLY at Florida Rep is Stirring and Splendid!

Review: TENDERLY at Florida Rep is Stirring and Splendid!

TENDERLY: THE ROSEMARY CLOONEY MUSICAL at Florida Repertory Theatre tells the beautifully bittersweet story of Rosemary Clooney through a variety of flashbacks, songs, and therapy sessions.

Susan Haefner played Rosemary Clooney, and she was absolutely phenomenal. She showcased the contrast between the façade Rosemary would put on and the traumas and struggles Rosemary faced behind the act flawlessly. Though her singing was, of course, excellent, I was even more impressed with her acting; she truly was Rosemary Clooney, and this allowed the audience to become fully immersed in her story.

Michael Marotta played The Doctor, along with several other roles, including Rosemary's sister, Betty, Bing Crosby, Dante DiPaolo, and more. It was very fun seeing him switch to another character with the changing of his glasses or the addition of a scarf; he also changed his tone of voice and his movements to fit each character, and the subtlety of it was brilliant and quite effective. Review: TENDERLY at Florida Rep is Stirring and Splendid!

I thoroughly enjoyed how TENDERLY progressed. As Rosemary and The Doctor met for therapy sessions, they would switch to acting out a flashback of whatever they were talking about. This worked very well, and the audience got to understand and go more in-depth into her life because of this. TENDERLY also had a wonderful balance of more upbeat and happy songs, such as "Botch-A-Me" and "Mambo Italiano," and more languid, sometimes bittersweet songs, such as "Have I Stayed Too Long at the Fair?" and "Tenderly."

Whether you know a lot or very little about Rosemary Clooney's life, I definitely suggest checking out TENDERLY at Florida Rep. There's so much more to this incredible story than just Rosemary Clooney's music career, and I have no doubt audiences will be inspired by the challenges she overcame to find happiness.

TENDERLY is playing in Florida Rep's ArtStage Studio Theatre now through February 24. Performances are Tuesday-Thursday at 7 PM, Friday-Saturday at 8 PM, with 2 PM matinees on Thursday, Saturday, and Sunday. To buy tickets, you can visit, call Florida Rep at 239-332-4488, or stop by the box office at 2268 Bay Street, Fort Myers, FL, 33901.

Photo Credit: Joe Dafeldecker

Related Articles View More Ft. Myers/Naples Stories

From This Author - Emily Yorgey

Emily Yorgey is an avid arts fan from Southwest Florida. She graduated from Florida Gulf Coast University in Spring 2017 with a Bachelor of Arts degree in English and a minor in Creative Writing. Before... (read more about this author)

Review: NEWSIES at The Belle Theatre
June 27, 2022

what did our critic think? NEWSIES at the brand new Belle Theatre in Cape Coral took place June 10-19, and I saw one of the final few performances. NEWSIES is one of my favorites, so I was looking forward to experiencing this production in a new way.

BWW Review: THE BIRDS at The Laboratory Theater Of Florida is A Hoot!
June 13, 2022

The Laboratory Theater's production of THE BIRDS, a parody of the Hitchcock classic, follows Melanie Daniels as she visits a town that is being attacked by birds. 

BWW Review: ROCK OF AGES at Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre is 'Nothin' But a Good Time!'
June 2, 2022

ROCK OF AGES at Broadway Palm, directed by Dean Sobon, is a jukebox musical that tells the rock'n'roll story of a 'small town girl' and a 'city boy' as they fall in love while chasing their dreams. 

BWW Review: SPONGEBOB SQUAREPANTS: THE MUSICAL at Florida Repertory Theatre
May 25, 2022

SPONGEBOB SQUAREPANTS: THE MUSICAL is now playing at Florida Repertory Theatre. The production, directed by Assistant Education Director Christina DeCarlo, is one of Florida Rep Education's Conservatory productions.

BWW Review: MAYTAG VIRGIN at Florida Repertory Theatre
May 3, 2022

MAYTAG VIRGIN by Audrey Cefaly, now playing at Florida Repertory Theatre, is a sweet, southern romantic comedy focused on neighbors Jack and Lizzy. Jack moves into the house next to Lizzy's, she brings him a pie to welcome him, and from there they form a bond.