Skip to main content Skip to footer site map
Review: COME FROM AWAY at Rochester Broadway Theatre League

Review: COME FROM AWAY at Rochester Broadway Theatre League

What did our critic think of COME FROM AWAY at Rochester Broadway Theatre League?

Come From Away, the 2015 Tony-winning Broadway hit currently playing at Rochester's Auditorium Theatre, is perhaps the perfect musical for the time we're living in. Political polarization is everywhere, social media has organized society into siloed echo chambers, and we're emerging from a two+ year pandemic in which we were all socially distanced. What better show to highlight humanity and bring us all back together; or at least, show us that it's possible?

Come From Away tells the true story of what happens when, in the hours after the events of September 11th, 2001, 38 planes from all over the world were rerouted to a small rural airport in Gander in the Canadian province of Newfoundland, as American airspace was closed indefinitely. Once home to the largest airport on the continent, Gander had more recently been a quiet tucked-away community of only a couple thousand smiling Canadians. In the days after 9/11, however, their sleepy little town became temporary home to over 7,000 people from all over the world who had no idea why they were suddenly being diverted to this remote tip of North America. Undaunted by culture clashes and language barriers, the townspeople of Gander sprang to life to feed, shelter, clothe, and comfort this army of strangers, showing them that even in the darkest of times we're all capable of kindness and decency.

Come From Away features a small cast of only twelve actors (several of whom were seen on RBTL's stage the last time Come From Away came to town in 2019) who all toggle between multiple characters consisting of Gander townspeople and travelers-most of them based on actual people-including Captain Beverly Bass (Cailin Stadnyk), the first female captain for American Airlines; Kevin Tuerff (Jeremy Woodard) and Kevin Jung (Ali Momen), the couple from LA; and Nick (James Kall) and Diane (Christine Toy Johnson), a Brit and a Texan who met in Gander and eventually married! The nonstop pace of the show (roughly 1 hour 40 minutes with no intermission) combined with the near-constant character changes required of each actor, are a testament to the talent and stamina of both the cast and director Christopher Ashley. It's a superb display of artistry and discipline.

Just as exciting as the actors on stage are the musicians in the wings (and sometimes on the stage too!), whose rip-roaring Celtic-style tunes act as the backdrop for everything from raucous bar sing-alongs ("Screech In") to heartfelt serenades ("Me and the Sky"). Not only can this band really PLAY, but they're clearly having a ton of fun doing it, joining the cast on stage during select musical numbers as well as closing out the show at curtain call.

It can't be overstated just how critically important shows like Come From Away are right now, given the divisiveness that we're all currently engulfed in every day. Rather than turn a cold shoulder and retreat to the safety of their homes, the people of Gander showed compassion and love during a time of terror and darkness despite differences in culture, national origin, religion and lifestyle. Rather than the millionth jukebox musical or movie adaptation, I sincerely hope Broadway producers find more opportunities to bring shows like Come From Away to audiences, because they're so tremendously needed.

Come From Away is playing until December 11th. For tickets and more information, click here.



New York Stage and Film Announces Summer Dates With New Collaboration With Marist College Photo
New York Stage and Film and Marist College have announced multi-year collaboration that will enable NYSAF to expand its year-round services for artists developing new work in theater, film and television in the Hudson Valley and New York City.

Interview: Sam McLellan Of THE BOOK OF MORMON at Proctors Theater Photo
Prior to this week’s arrival of THE BOOK OF MORMON to Proctors, I spoke with Sam McLellan, who is currently playing the role of Elder Price on tour. His career includes some memorable moments, previously appearing as Dmitry in the national tour of ANASTASIA, and in the touring production of FIDDLER ON THE ROOF. Sam is currently on his third tour.

Redhouse Arts Center Announces Interim Leadership Plan Photo
With the departure of the Executive Director, Samara Hannah, the Redhouse Arts Center's board of directors has approved a plan to maintain operations during this interim period. Long time board member and past board chair, William Hider, will serve as interim director, managing finances and building operations.

Fairgame Grants Applications To Open In February For Third Year Photo
The Upstate Theater Coalition for a Fairgame has announced the third year of Fairgame Arts Grants, an invaluable funding opportunity for non-profit arts and cultural organizations in three New York state regions—Capital, Catskills and Southern Tier.


From This Author - Colin Fleming-Stumpf

Colin Fleming-Stumpf is a lover of all things theatre and performing arts. A native of Rochester, Colin has acted on stages across Western New York and is active in the local theatre community as a... (read more about this author)


Review: AIN'T MISBEHAVIN' at Geva TheatreReview: AIN'T MISBEHAVIN' at Geva Theatre
January 25, 2023

What did our critic think of AIN'T MISBEHAVIN' at Geva Theatre? It's curious that 'Ain't Misbehavin'' feels like such a perfect show for a Rochester audience, given that Fats Waller has no apparent Rochester connection; he was born in New York City, died in Kansas City, and spent the bulk of his short life entertaining audiences across the U.S and abroad.

Review: MISS BENNETT: CHRISTMAS AT PEMBERLEY at Blackfriars TheatreReview: MISS BENNETT: CHRISTMAS AT PEMBERLEY at Blackfriars Theatre
December 14, 2022

What did our critic think of MISS BENNETT: CHRISTMAS AT PEMBERLEY at Blackfriars Theatre?

Review: A CHRISTMAS CAROL at Geva TheatreReview: A CHRISTMAS CAROL at Geva Theatre
December 7, 2022

Christmas is a time of traditions. Be it caroling, making sugar cookies, decorating the tree, or hanging lights, folks love this time of year because of the traditions we create and revisit each December with our friends and loved ones. If you're like me, Geva Theatre's annual production of 'A Christmas Carol' is one of your favorite holiday traditions, and for good reason. It's a consistently top-quality production filled with joy and merriment, and featuring many cast members who have been returning to Geva for this special show for years.

Review: COME FROM AWAY at Rochester Broadway Theatre LeagueReview: COME FROM AWAY at Rochester Broadway Theatre League
December 7, 2022

What did our critic think of COME FROM AWAY at Rochester Broadway Theatre League?

Review: SOMEWHERE at Geva TheatreReview: SOMEWHERE at Geva Theatre
October 30, 2022

What did our critic think of SOMEWHERE at Geva Theatre?