Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: JERRY ORBACH'S BROADWAY Hits All the Right Notes at 54 Below

An Evening that was truly a “Lullaby of Old Broadway”

By:
Review: JERRY ORBACH'S BROADWAY Hits All the Right Notes at 54 Below

The evening truly was  a “Lullaby of Old Broadway” at Jerry Orbach’S BROADWAY, at 54 Below on January 25, 2024.   Attired in black slacks and  jewel-toned dress shirts, the cast consisted of a trio of renowned Broadway talent themselves - William Michals, Jay Aubrey Jones and Patrick Michael Wickham.  These three talented singers led theatergoers on a toe tapping journey through the sensational musical career of the man who became one of Broadway’s legendary performers, the one and only Jerry Orbach.

Creator and Director Michael Portantiere and Musical Director Matthew Martin Ward wove the fantastic story of Orbach’s life on the musical stage through the decades for all to hear and see.  Beginning with The Threepenny Opera and continuing through The Fantasticks, Carnival!, Promises, Promises, Chicago to 42nd Street, Jerry Orbach’S BROADWAY didn’t disappoint the jammed to capacity audience, consisting of many loyal fans of musical theater.

Standout performances included a rousing rendition of “Luck Be A Lady” from Guys and Dolls with William Michals, Jay Aubrey Jones, and Patrick Michael Wickham, an emotionally charged version of “Promises, Promises” by Patrick Michael Wickham from the same named show with music by the famed song master Burt Bacharach, and last but hardly least, the belting baritone vocals of William Michals, who re-emerged clad in a sequined black dinner jacket while pulling out all the stops as he put on the glitz and glamor for the ol’ ‘“Razzle Dazzle” from Chicago.

Interspersed throughout the evening’s musical showcases, video and written remembrances from Orbach’s esteemed acting colleagues and friends Brenda Vaccaro and Anna Maria Alberghetti were presented.  A very special tribute came in a live appearance  of the Broadway veteran Lee Roy Reams on the 54 Below stage for his performance of “42nd Street” Stories and Songs. This reviewer was thrilled to hear and see one of the original 42nd Street cast members recreating its music live as well as giving insights into the backstage goings on of the famed 1980 Broadway musical hit.   

Additionally, Orbach’s two sons, Tony and Chris made an appearance onstage giving the patrons a unique opportunity to hear Orbach family anecdotes and personal Broadway show stories from their famed father.  

As a final tribute and the pièce de résistance of the night was when the main cast along with Lee Roy Reams, Tony Orbach and Chris Orbach all vocally accompanied a video of Jerry himself singing the song so closely tied to his memory, “Try To Remember” from The Fantasticks. Not a dry eye was left in the packed house that night.  

What an amazing night it was for everyone’s Broadway memories at Jerry Orbach’S BROADWAY. As the old saying goes, there truly is “no business like show business.”

Jerry Orbach’S BROADWAY was created and directed by Michael Portantiere with musical direction by Matthew Martin Ward.  The show featured Jay Aubrey Jones, Chris Orbach, Tony Orbach, William Michals, Lee Roy Reams and Patrick Michael Wickham.

Find great shows to see on 54 Below's website HERE.

More on 54 Below
Upcoming Shows
Jason Graae: It’s a Graae Night for Singing!
Jason Graae: It’s a Graae Night for Singing!
8/9 - 8/9/2026
Citizens of Belleville: A Bad Cinderella Reunion
Citizens of Belleville: A Bad Cinderella Reunion
8/9 - 8/9/2026
Recent Articles
54 DIVA OFF To Be Hosted By 54 Below For One Night Only
54 DIVA OFF To Be Hosted By 54 Below For One Night Only
8/9/2026
Review: Christine Andreas Soars in S'WONDERFUL at 54 Below
Review: Christine Andreas Soars in S'WONDERFUL at 54 Below
8/7/2026

Reader Reviews

Don't Miss a Cabaret News Story
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...


BroadwayWorld TV


Flame: The Songs of Brady & Browne in Cabaret Flame: The Songs of Brady & Browne
54 Below (8/23-8/23) PHOTOS VIDEOS
DiGangi With A “G” in Cabaret DiGangi With A “G”
The Green Room 42 (8/18-8/18) PHOTOS
Murray Hill: A Murray Little Christmas in Cabaret Murray Hill: A Murray Little Christmas
Joe's Pub (12/16-12/16)
54 Sings Queen in Cabaret 54 Sings Queen
54 Below (11/04-11/04)
54 Sings Broadway's Greatest Hits! in Cabaret 54 Sings Broadway's Greatest Hits!
54 Below (8/22-8/22)
54 Sings Together, Together: A Harry Styles Celebration in Cabaret 54 Sings Together, Together: A Harry Styles Celebration
54 Below (9/29-9/29)
Christine Ebersole with Billy Stritch in Cabaret Christine Ebersole with Billy Stritch
54 Below (10/27-10/27)
Lindsay Mendez and Ryan Scott Oliver’s Actor Therapy in Cabaret Lindsay Mendez and Ryan Scott Oliver’s Actor Therapy
54 Below (11/22-11/22)
Justin Vivian Bond: Madame Stanley in Cabaret Justin Vivian Bond: Madame Stanley
Joe's Pub (9/18-9/18)
Oh Em Gee, They Sang This on Glee! in Cabaret Oh Em Gee, They Sang This on Glee!
54 Below (9/27-9/27)