Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: Megan Hilty Sparkles in DIAMOND SERIES: MEGAN HILTY at Feinstein's/54 Below

The stunning show runs through Sunday, Nov. 7

Review: Megan Hilty Sparkles in DIAMOND SERIES: MEGAN HILTY at Feinstein's/54 Below

Megan Hilty, the third performer in Feinstein's/54 Below's 2021 Diamond Series, sparkled as vibrantly as a diamond herself on Tuesday night. I mean that metaphorically, as a compliment to her performance and stage presence, but also literally, as a complement to the incredible silver-sparkly sheath dress Hilty wore during the performance. Every small movement of hers, a sequin on her dress caught the light and cast sparkles across the room, adding an aliveness to the show.

Review: Megan Hilty Sparkles in DIAMOND SERIES: MEGAN HILTY at Feinstein's/54 Below Hilty is a Tony-award nominated Broadway singing actress and TV actor who is performing through Sunday night at Feinstein's/54 Below as part of their Diamond series. The night consists of a three-course dinner (along with canapes and complimentary prosecco) followed by an hour and a half of Hilty being an absolute delight on stage. Her show was the epitome of what great cabaret is and should be: she shared intimate stories about the arts and the life of a performer, wowed us with her incredible vocals, all while the club provided us with excellent food, drink, and service. It's a night to remember, a night to cherish - and I'll be doing both for the rest of my life.

The beauty of 54 Below is that you're often sharing a table with strangers. Last night, before the show, the room was filled with the sound of gentle music and chattering, as guests talked to members of their own parties and made new friends.

All of that faded away at 8:30 p.m. on the dot as a disembodied voice announced Megan Hilty's presence. She made a show of struggling to get up the steps, which elicited laughs and, frankly, was terribly relatable. In a dress like that and high heels, I'd also be hard-pressed to get up those stairs. But if I hadn't written that fact down in my notebook (and if Hilty hadn't joked about it later in the show) I absolutely would have forgotten that moment as I later became completely enraptured by her performance.

Review: Megan Hilty Sparkles in DIAMOND SERIES: MEGAN HILTY at Feinstein's/54 Below Accompanied by a four-person band - music director Matt Cusson on piano, Brian Gallagher on guitar, Dennis Michael Keefe on bass, and Jack DeBoe on drums - Hilty enthralled the club with her stunning vocals, impeccable acting, and delightful stories between songs. When she sang "Popular" from Wicked (Hilty played Glinda on Broadway for several years) she put on a silly voice to evoke the spirit of the character whose point of view the song is from. She still sounded incredible, just...funny, as well. When Hilty later dove into a Dolly Parton medley comprised of "Backwoods Barbie" and "9 to 5," I couldn't help but notice she sounds just like a country star. She's a vocal chameleon, able to take on many a character and accent, all while retaining things like perfect pitch and ability to hit the right notes, which is I'm sure harder than us non-singers might think.

One of my favorite numbers from the night was "Alto's Lament," which, despite its name, is actually a rollickingly hilarious time that left me in stitches. But the absolute showstopper, for me at least, was "Second Hand White Baby Grand," from the show Smash on which Hilty played Ivy Lynn. The song was the perfect showcase for Hilty's beautiful voice, which shone out clear and loud like a crystal, and I found myself nearly tearing up at her execution of the heartrending lyrics.

Another time I almost cried? When Hilty spoke about her husband, Brian Gallagher (yes, the Brian Gallagher who was on guitar) and then he sang "Suddenly Seymore" with her. In that moment, I almost felt like I was witnessing a solitary moment between the couple. They made eye contact and smiled at each other throughout the song, and oh my word, love is beautiful, isn't it?

Megan Hilty is a star. She's got a brilliant stage presence, she can sing like an angel, she's straight-up hilarious. If you've got a free evening this weekend, you absolutely will want to head over to buy tickets. This can't-miss show runs through Sunday night at Feinstein's/54 Below. It is, and I'm not exaggerating even a little, a life-changing, magical experience.

Review: Megan Hilty Sparkles in DIAMOND SERIES: MEGAN HILTY at Feinstein's/54 Below

Photos by Helane Blumfield



Linda Purl This Could Be The Start... Photo
Linda Purl brings her newest set list of songs to the Birdland Theater in her show 'The Could Be The Start...'. A blend of classic songs, old and new, with an eye towards fresh beginnings in a reinvigorated time. Backed by the musical trio of Tedd Firth (piano), David Finck (bass), and Ray Marchica (drums).

Seth Meyers Slays At City Winery Photo
In all, what can one say about a comedy pro, delivering a hilarious show in a well-conceived, professional way? We can say, try and get tickets to his next sets at City Winery on February 6 & 9th

Mike Stern Band, Uptown Jazz Tentet, and More to Play Birdland Next Week Photo
Birdland Jazz Club and Birdland Theater has announced jazz programming at running January 31 through February 12. Performers appearing at Birdland Jazz Club include Mike Stern Band featuring Dennis Chambers and Randy Brecker, Uptown Jazz Tentet, Bill O'Connell and the Latin Jazz Sextet, Gunhild Carling and Ben Markley Big Band Feat. Ari Hoenig. 

CRYING ON THE CAMINO To Play Ramsey, NJ in February Photo
Stage performer, Celeste Mancinelli has an extremely funny and deeply moving true story to tell on Saturday February 11th 7:30pm at St. Paul's Roman Catholic Church.


From This Author - Karis Rogerson

Karis Rogerson is a writer and blogger with a passion for telling stories about art and those who make it. She writes novels, poems, essays, and articles for various online magazines.

... (read more about this author)

BWW Review: Megan Hilty Sparkles in DIAMOND SERIES: MEGAN HILTY at Feinstein's/54 BelowBWW Review: Megan Hilty Sparkles in DIAMOND SERIES: MEGAN HILTY at Feinstein's/54 Below
November 3, 2021

The stunning show runs through Sunday, Nov. 7

BWW Feature: Jennica McCleary is the Swiss Army Knife of PerformersBWW Feature: Jennica McCleary is the Swiss Army Knife of Performers
October 31, 2021

The Bette Midler tribute artist returns to NYC with Winnie's Rock Cauldron Cabaret

BWW Review: Natalie Douglas Defies Explanation in BEST OF TRIBUTES: THE WOMEN at Birdland TheaterBWW Review: Natalie Douglas Defies Explanation in BEST OF TRIBUTES: THE WOMEN at Birdland Theater
October 5, 2021

Natalie Douglas was excited to be on stage. She was returning to Birdland Theater on Oct. 1, 2021 in 'Best of Tributes: The Women', with a show that sampled songs from tribute shows she had previously created for Dolly Parton, Nina Simone, and Roberta Flack. The award-winning performer was in excellent spirits as she came onto the stage and greeted the audience. Missing a cue at the beginning of the first song, she laughed it off, restarted, and dove into Dolly Parton's '9 to 5,' which was a perfectly exuberant and jaunty song to kick off the evening.

BWW Review: Stacey Kent is Transportive in SONGS FROM OTHER PLACES at Birdland Jazz ClubBWW Review: Stacey Kent is Transportive in SONGS FROM OTHER PLACES at Birdland Jazz Club
October 2, 2021

Staey Kent's voice teleports listeners to a different era

BWW Feature: Will Nolan Returns With LEOLA'S LADY LAND LOUNGE at The Green Room 42BWW Feature: Will Nolan Returns With LEOLA'S LADY LAND LOUNGE at The Green Room 42
September 30, 2021

I could introduce Will as the creator of Leola, a 'senior citizen redneck diva' who wows audiences with her sketch comedies. I could talk about how he dreamed up Leola as the complete opposite of his own great-aunt Leola - his character is a 70-year-old Southern lesbian who just 'wants to save the whole world.'