I saw the first preview and just thought she was wonderful in the role. Her actuary song is absolutley hilarious and she of course was fantastic in Avenue Q. Love love love her!
I saw her in a reading when she was playing opposite Colin Hanlon! She was great then too; although I didn't think the chemistry was there between her and Colin. She's probably better cast now
I thought Stephanie was great but I have to agree that at many times I couldnt help thinking of Kate Monster. At one point I even half expected her to start singing "Fine Fine Line." It was at the first preview though so I'm sure she's gotten even better.
Stephanie and Colin dont really need to have chemistry as they arent a couple in the show