@ bestie: My guess is she was giddy and giggly because she was tipsy on the champagne. Check out towards the end how she goes in the opposite direction of Mamita and Gaston and bumps into him and then giggles some more.
She seemed giggly through the whole thing (one note). Maybe she needed more of a "before" and "after" the champagne. I remember Leslie Caron hiding her champagne (and her tipsiness) from both Gaston and Mamita throughout the number in the film.
I just felt like they were presenting a number here, rather than acting a scene from a story.
It didn't feel in context that much at all.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22
Is this the time I must confess I never saw High School Musical and had no idea who this Vanessa is, but that is one of the most exciting production numbers ever? She just oozes charm and energy. Love it. Can't wait to see this.
Oh, by the way, when I go to see Gigi on Broadway, I suspect I'll be looking for charming and exciting musical numbers and not stressing out over a girl's believably hiding her "bubbly drunkenness" from the adults who actually wouldn't be bothered by it in the least in this scene. Or were you expecting Anna Karenina instead of Gigi, best12bars?
Good, you keep your kick lines and leaps, and I"ll keep my stories as the most important thing in musical theatre.
You clearly have no clue about the story of Gigi or what is going on in this scene (or should be going on) or who these characters are. But as long as they smile big and ooze and kick high, you're cool.
Glad to hear you're so easily entertained. Enjoy the show!
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22
They were on a TV show. Their job is to make it look as fun as possible. I can't say for sure, but it is possible that the number will progress more when actually in the theatre.
I personally thought the performance was adorable, and all three leads sounded great. I've always found Vanessa charming, and I think this is a perfect role for her.