| Contribution to the Theater Award | The Drama Book Shop | |
| Distinguished Achievement in Musical Theatre | Andre De Shields | |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Lorna Courtney, Betsy Wolfe | & Juliet |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Will Swenson | A Beautiful Noise |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Jefferson Mays | A Christmas Carol |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Arian Moayed, Jessica Chastain | A Doll's House |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Jordan E. Cooper | Ain't No Mo' |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Stephen McKinley Henderson | Between Riverside and Crazy |
|
| Distinguished Performance Award | Phillipa Soo | Camelot |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Katy Sullivan, David Zayas | Cost of Living |
|
| Distinguished Performance Award | Ryan J. Haddad | Dark Disabled Stories |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Sharon D. Clarke | Death of a Salesman |
| Distinguished Performance Award | K. Todd Freeman | Downstate |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Somi Kakoma | Dreaming Zenzile |
| Distinguished Performance Award | John Douglas Thompson | Endgame |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Marylouise Burke | Epiphany |
|
|
| Distinguished Performance Award | Marcel Spears | Fat Ham |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Sean Hayes | Good Night, Oscar |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Sara Bareilles, Patina Miller | Into the Woods |
| Distinguished Performance Award | David Krumholtz | Leopoldstadt |
|
| Distinguished Performance Award | Hiran Abeysekera | Life of Pi |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Anna Uzele, Colton Ryan | New York, New York |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Micaela Diamond | Parade |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Jodie Comer | Prima Facie |
|
| Distinguished Performance Award | Gargi Mukherjee | Public Obscenities |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Alex Newell | Shucked |
| Distinguished Performance Award | J. Harrison Ghee | Some Like It Hot |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Laura Linney | Summer, 1976 |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Annaleigh Ashford | Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Josh Groban | Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street |
|
| Distinguished Performance Award | Stephanie Berry | the bandaged place |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Jeremy Pope | The Collaboration |
|
|
| Distinguished Performance Award | John David Washington, Danielle Brooks | The Piano Lesson |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Oscar Isaac, Rachel Brosnahan | The Sign in Sidney Brustein's Window |
| Distinguished Performance Award | D'Arcy Carden | The Thanksgving Play |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Marla Mindelle | Titanique |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Corey Hawkins, Yahya Abdul-Mateeh II | Topdog/Underdog |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Brittany Bradford | Wedding Band |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Tarra Conner Jones | White Girl in Danger |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Esco Jouley | Wolf Play |
|
|
| Distinguished Performance Award | Linda Lavin | You Will Get Sick |
| Founders Award for Excellence in Directing | Lear deBessonet | |
| Gratitude Award | Darin Oduyoye, Darin Oduyoye | |
| Outstanding Direction of a Musical | Bartlett Sher | Camelot |
| Outstanding Direction of a Musical | Lileana Blain-Cruz | Dreaming Zenzile |
| Outstanding Direction of a Musical | Lear DeBessonet | Into the Woods |
| Outstanding Direction of a Musical | Susan Stroman | New York, New York |
| Outstanding Direction of a Musical | Jack O'Brien | Shucked |
|
|
| Outstanding Direction of a Musical | Casey Nicholaw | Some Like It Hot |
| Outstanding Direction of a Musical | Thomas Kail | Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street |
|
| Outstanding Direction of a Musical | Lileana Blain-Cruz | White Girl in Danger |
| Outstanding Direction of a Play | Jamie Lloyd | A Doll's House |
| Outstanding Direction of a Play | Jo Bonney | Cost of Living |
| Outstanding Direction of a Play | Awoye Timpo | Elyria |
| Outstanding Direction of a Play | Sayok Misha Chowdhury | Public Obscenities |
| Outstanding Direction of a Play | David Mendizábal | the bandaged place |
|
| Outstanding Direction of a Play | Anne Kauffman | The Sign in Sidney Brustein's Window |
| Outstanding Direction of a Play | Kenny Leon | Topdog/Underdog |
| Outstanding Direction of a Play | Awoye Timpo | Wedding Band |
| Outstanding Direction of a Play | Dustin Wills | Wolf Play |
|
| Outstanding Production of a Musical | Some Like It Hot | |
| Outstanding Production of a Musical | A Beautiful Noise, & Juliet, New York, New York, Shucked, Titanique, White Girl in Danger, Wise Children's Wuthering Heights, Dreaming Zenzile | |
| Outstanding Production of a Play | Leopoldstadt | |
| Outstanding Production of a Play | the bandaged place, Fat Ham, Cost of Living, Dark Disabled Stories, Downstate, Elyria, Good Night, Oscar, Life of Pi, Peter Pan Goes Wrong, Prima Facie, Public Obscenities, Summer, 1976 | |
|
|
| Outstanding Revival of a Musical | Into the Woods | |
| Outstanding Revival of a Musical | 1776, Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street, Parade, A Man of No Importance, Camelot, Bob Fosse's Dancin', Camelot, Bob Fosse's Dancin' | |
| Outstanding Revival of a Play | A Doll's House | |
| Outstanding Revival of a Play | Hamlet/Oresteia, Ohio State Murders, The Piano Lesson, A Raisin in the Sun, The Sign in Sidney Brustein's Window, The Thanksgiving Play, Topdog/Underdog, Wedding Band, Wolf Play | |
