| Outstanding Actor - Musical | James Naughton | City of Angels |
| Outstanding Actor - Musical | Scott Wise | Jerome Robbins' Broadway |
| Outstanding Actor - Musical | Richard Muenz | The Pajama Game |
| Outstanding Actor - Musical | David Carroll | Grand Hotel |
| Outstanding Actor - Musical | Jason Alexander | Jerome Robbins' Broadwa |
| Outstanding Actor - Musical | Bob Gunton | Sweeney Todd |
| Outstanding Actor - Play | Stephen McHattie | Ghetto |
| Outstanding Actor - Play | Paul Provenza | Only Kidding |
|
| Outstanding Actor - Play | Peter Friedman | The Heidi Chronicles |
| Outstanding Actor - Play | Nathan Lane | The Lisbon Traviata |
|
| Outstanding Actor - Play | Niall Buggy | Aristocrats |
| Outstanding Actor - Play | Philip Bosco | Lend Me a Tenor |
| Outstanding Actor - Play | Mikhail Baryshnikov | Metamorphosis |
| Outstanding Actress - Musical | Debbie Shapiro, Faith Prince | Jerome Robbins' Broadway |
| Outstanding Actress - Musical | Beth Fowler | Sweeney Todd |
| Outstanding Actress - Musical | Toni DiBuono | The Forbidden City |
|
|
| Outstanding Actress - Musical | Roxie Lucas | The Forbidden City City |
| Outstanding Actress - Musical | Geraldine James | The Merchant of Venice |
| Outstanding Actress - Musical | Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio | Twelfth Night |
| Outstanding Actress - Play | Joanna Allen | The Heidi Chronicles |
|
| Outstanding Actress - Play | Geraldine James | The Merchant of Venice |
| Outstanding Actress - Play | Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio | Twelfth Night |
| Outstanding Actress - Play | Pauline Collins | Shirley Valentine |
| Outstanding Actress - Play | Gloria Foster | The Forbidden City |
|
| Outstanding Book of a Musical | Larry Gelbart | City of Angels |
| Outstanding Choreography | Tommy Tune | Grand Hotel |
| Outstanding Costume Design | Florence Klotz | City of Angels |
| Outstanding Costume Design | Santo Loquasto | Grand Hotel |
| Outstanding Costume Design | William Levy Long | Lend Me a Tenor |
| Outstanding Costume Design | Jennifer Arnold | The Lady in Question |
|
| Outstanding Costume Design | Robert Locke | The Lady in Question |
| Outstanding Director - Musical | Michael Blakemore | City of Angels |
|
|
| Outstanding Director - Musical | Tommy Tune | Grand Hotel |
| Outstanding Director - Play | Robin Lefevre | Aristocrats |
| Outstanding Director - Play | Jerry Zaks | Lend Me a Tenor |
| Outstanding Director - Play | Simon Callow | Shirley Valentine |
| Outstanding Director - Play | Adrian Nobel | The Art of Success |
| Outstanding Director - Play | Dan Sullivan | The Heidi Chronicles |
| Outstanding Featured Actor - Musical | Rene Auberjonois | City of Angels |
| Outstanding Featured Actor - Musical | Jonathan Hadary | Gypsy |
|
|
| Outstanding Featured Actor - Musical | Michael Jeter | Grand Hotel |
| Outstanding Featured Actor - Play | Fyvush Finkel | Cafe Crown |
| Outstanding Featured Actor - Play | Matt McGrath | Dalton's Back |
| Outstanding Featured Actor - Play | Peter Frechette | Eastern Standard |
| Outstanding Featured Actor - Play | Gordon Joseph Weiss | Ghetto |
| Outstanding Featured Actor - Play | Edmund Lewis | Without Apologies |
| Outstanding Featured Actor - Play | Simon Jones | Privates on Parade |
| Outstanding Featured Actor - Play | Dustin Hoffman | The Merchant of Venice |
|
|
| Outstanding Featured Actress - Musical | Danielle Du Clos | Aspects of Love |
| Outstanding Featured Actress - Musical | Randy Graff | City of Angels |
|
| Outstanding Featured Actress - Musical | Jane Krakowski | Grand Hotel |
| Outstanding Featured Actress - Musical | Crista Moore | Gypsy |
| Outstanding Featured Actress - Play | Margaret Colin | Aristocrats |
| Outstanding Featured Actress - Play | Jayne Atkinson | The Art of Success |
| Outstanding Featured Actress - Play | Joanne Camp | The Heidi Chronicles |
| Outstanding Featured Actress - Play | Frances Conroy | The Secret Rapture |
|
| Outstanding Featured Actress - Play | Stephanie Roth | Artist Descending a Staircase |
| Outstanding Featured Actress - Play | Tovah Feldshuh | Lend Me a Tenor |
| Outstanding Lighting Design | Tharon Musser | Artist Descending a Staircase |
| Outstanding Lighting Design | Jane Reisman, Neil Peter Jampolis | Black and Blue |
|
| Outstanding Lighting Design | Paul Gallo | City of Angels |
| Outstanding Lighting Design | Jules Fisher | Grand Hotel |
| Outstanding Lighting Design | Paul Gallo | Lend Me a Tenor / Micacolo D'Amore |
| Outstanding Lighting Design | Mary Jo Dondlinger | Sweeney Todd |
|
|
| Outstanding Lyrics | David Zippel | City of Angels |
| Outstanding Lyrics | Maury Yeston, George Forrest, Robert Wright | Grand Hotel |
| Outstanding Lyrics | Richard Maltby Jr. | Closer Than Ever |
| Outstanding Music | Cy Coleman | City of Angels |
| Outstanding Music | David Shire | Closer Than Ever |
| Outstanding Music | Astor Piazzolla | Dangerous Games |
|
| Outstanding Music | George Forrest, Robert Wright, Maury Yeston | Grand Hotel |
| Outstanding Musical | Black and Blue | Black and Blue |
|
| Outstanding Musical | City of Angels | City of Angels |
| Outstanding Musical | Jerome Robbins' Broadway | Jerome Robbins' Broadway |
| Outstanding New Play | Jim Geoghan | Only Kidding |
| Outstanding New Play | Willy Russell | Shirley Valentine |
| Outstanding New Play | Wendy Wasserstein | The Heidi Chronicles |
| Outstanding New Play | David Hare | The Secret Rapture |
| Outstanding New Play | Terence McNally, Terence McNally | The Lisbon Traviata |
| Outstanding One Person Show | Mandy Patinkin | Dress Casual |
|
|
|
| Outstanding One Person Show | Robert Morse | Tru |
| Outstanding Orchestration | Billy Byers | City of Angels |
| Outstanding Orchestration | Rodolfo Alchourron, James Kowal | Dangerous Games |
| Outstanding Orchestration | Peter Matz | Grand Hotel |
| Outstanding Revival | Sweeney Todd | Sweeney Todd |
| Outstanding Revival of a Musical | Gypsy | Gypsy |
| Outstanding Set Design | John Lee Beatty | Aristocrats |
| Outstanding Set Design | Santo Loquasto | Cafe Crown / Italian American Reconciliation |
|
| Outstanding Set Design | Tony Walton | Grand Hotel |
| Outstanding Set Design | Tony Walton | Lend Me a Tenor |
|
| Outstanding Set Design | James Morgan | Sweeney Todd |
| Outstanding Set Design | Thomas Lynch | The Heidi Chronicles |
| Outstanding Set Design | Edward Gianfrancesco | The Widow's Blind Date |
| Outstanding Set Design | Robin Wagner | City of Angels |
| Special Awards | Bernard Gersten, Gregory Mosher, John McGlinn, Manhattan Theatre Club, Paul Gemignani | |
| Special Awards | Jerome Robbins | Jerome Robbins |
|
|
| Unique Theatrical Experience | Barry McGovern | I'll Go On |
| Unique Theatrical Experience | Bill Irwin | Largely New York |
