Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: THE COMEDY OF ERRORS at The Australian Shakespeare Company

The Comedy of Errors is playing as part of this year’s Shakespeare Under the Stars season until February 19th, 2022.

Review: THE COMEDY OF ERRORS at The Australian Shakespeare Company
Photography by Ben Fon

One of my favourite summer theatre experiences is back... Shakespeare Under the Stars! This annual Melbourne event presented by The Australian Shakespeare Company returns to the Royal Botanic Gardens Melbourne with one of 'The Bard of Avon's' earliest comedies, The Comedy of Errors.

This farce is centred around the mistaken identity of two sets of identical twins, resulting in a hurlyburly of chaos over a 24-hour period. Does this plot sound familiar to you? If you have seen Rodgers and Hart's musical The Boys from Syracuse or the 1988 film Big Business, starring Bette Midler and Lily Tomlin, then that maybe why, as both are based on The Comedy of Errors. Shakespeare himself in turn based The Comedy of Errors on the Roman playwright Plautus' play Menaechmi, increasing plot complexity and depth with the addition of a second pair of identical twins as well as introducing new characters, detailed backstory, and additional themes.

While at times the plot can be difficult to follow, given that there are two sets of identical twins weaving in and out of the various scenes, this state of confusion drives the central narrative of the play. If, like the plays characters, you find yourself bamboozled by what is going on, be rest assured as the play draws to an end Shakespeare will provide you with an answer to all your who, what, why, when and how questions.

The current Australian Shakespeare Company's commedia dell'arte stylised production of The Comedy of Errors fits the play like a glove, with slick direction by Glenn Elston OAM. Elston states that The Comedy of Errors "... is what we all need right now, some unabashed silliness and wonderfully crazy characters...", and I could not agree more!

Greg Carroll's black and white sketch book like set design sets the scene and tone for the play perfectly and Karla Erenbot's boldly colourful costumes bring the archetype of each character vividly to life. The actors all excel in their deliverance of the slapstick 'Punch and Judy' humour, never missing a beat and ensuring the audience has a plethora of 'laugh out loud' moments throughout the performance.

While the entire cast was excellent, a performance that was particularly hilarious and highly memorable was Maverick Newman as the Abbess, Emelia. Newman's character interpretation of Emelia is best described as a mixture of Lady Bracknell from The Importance of Being Earnest and Violet Crawley, Dowager Countess of Grantham, from Downton Abbey. In other words, hilarious stiff upper lip comedy at its best. Madeleine Somers as Luciana also delivered a particularly comical stage exit on roller blades.

Of course the outdoor setting at Southern Cross Lawn at the Royal Botanic Gardens Melbourne is, as always, a highlight of Shakespeare Under the Stars that will continue to please both new and returning theatre goers. There is something about watching a Shakespearean play outside amidst nature, while the sun sets on a hot summer day and the sky transitions to night, that will always seem magical.

The Comedy of Errors is playing as part of this year's Shakespeare Under the Stars season until February 19th, 2022. For more information and to buy tickets please visit

Review: THE COMEDY OF ERRORS at The Australian Shakespeare Company
Photography by Ben Fon

Melbourne Opera Presents The Ring Cycle Cultural Festival Photo
Made possible by Melbourne's most distinguished and committed arts patrons led by Patron in Chief Lady Primrose Potter, Melbourne Opera will present The Ring Cycle Cultural Festival, a regional Australian first coming to Bendigo in March-April.

Carly Rae Jepsen Brings Memphis LK as Guest on Australian Tour Photo
Carly Rae Jepsen’s hotly anticipated The So Nice Tour lands in Australia next month, taking in two nights at Sydney’s Enmore Theatre and Melbourne’s Forum, plus a stop at Brisbane’s The Tivoli. Local pop act Memphis LK has been announced as the national support, set to join Jepsen on all upcoming Australian dates.

New Queer Musical BEARDED Comes to Frankston Arts Centre in March Photo
The brainchild of session musician Sean Donehue and writer Nick Waxman, Bearded is set to hit Frankston Arts Centre’s Cube 37 stage on March 1st for an extremely limited run.

NEWRETRO Comes to Australian Centre for Contemporary Art in March Photo
Melbourne’s award-winning dance company Lucy Guerin Inc (LGI) presents NEWRETRO, an epic new performance installation by leading Australian choreographer Lucy Guerin celebrating the company’s 21st anniversary—part of the inaugural FRAME: A biennial of dance.

From This Author - Josh Stent

Josh has had a passion and love for the Arts ever since seeing his first musical The Secret Garden at age 5. Originally from New Zealand, Josh graduated from The McDonald College of Perfor... (read more about this author)

November 18, 2022

What did our critic think of JOSEPH AND THE AMAZING TECHNICOLOR DREAMCOAT at Regent Theatre?

October 23, 2022

What an absolute honour it was to watch The United Ukrainian Ballet’s production of Swan Lake. The experience truly felt like a moment in history. This production of Swan Lake not only allows audiences to reconnect with a beloved ballet favourite, but to also see the story’s themes through the lens of the current situation in Ukraine.

Review: YOU'RE A CATCH! WHY ARE YOU SINGLE? at Theatre WorksReview: YOU'RE A CATCH! WHY ARE YOU SINGLE? at Theatre Works
October 16, 2022

You're A Catch! Why Are You Single? Like me, you may have been asking yourself this question for quite some time. However, in this instance, I am not referring to my own disastrous love life, or even perhaps potential narcissistic personality traits. What I am referring to is a new 60-minute, one-act, song cycle written by Sarah Wynen, called You're A Catch! Why Are You Single? This laugh-out-loud show recently played at Theatre Works, as part of this year's Melbourne Fringe Festival.

Review: HAIRSPRAY at Melbourne's Regent TheatreReview: HAIRSPRAY at Melbourne's Regent Theatre
August 18, 2022

Hey Melbourne, welcome to the 60's! It's time to put on your most colourful and crazily patterned outfit, tease your hair big, bold, and beautiful, and head on down to the Regent Theatre. Hairspray is back and this time it's the original Broadway version of the musical! Having grown up listening to the original Broadway cast album, it was a sheer delight for a theatre nerd like me to see the original version of Hairspray here in Australia. Seeing this production's opening night performance which coincided exactly 20 years from Hairspray's Broadway premiere was also a big fat cherry on the top! While some elements of the original version do now feel slightly dated and some of this production's casting choices don't always allow Hairspray's vibrant characters to shine as brightly as one would like, you can't deny that this show is just so much fun. From the moment the show opens with 'Good Morning Baltimore' to the standing ovation worthy finale of 'You Can't Stop The Beat', Hairspray will put a smile on your face and have you dancing in your seat.

Review: SIX THE MUSICAL at Comedy TheatreReview: SIX THE MUSICAL at Comedy Theatre
June 26, 2022

SIX the Musical is a must see this winter in Melbourne. Short and sweet at only 75-minutes long, SIX will have you jamming in your seat, while listening to the six wives of Henry VIII tell their side of the story, as a reimagined pop girl group!