Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: A GENTLEMAN'S GUIDE TO LOVE AND MURDER at City Springs Theatre

Review: A GENTLEMAN'S GUIDE TO LOVE AND MURDER at City Springs Theatre
Googie Uterhardt as the D'Ysquith Family
Photo Courtesy of City Springs Theatre

On Friday evening, City Springs Theatre opened a dazzling, well-sung production of the 2012 Tony Award-winning stage farce A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder, securing the theatre's place among the best professional theatres in Atlanta. The production, a pure technical delight, showcases gorgeous scenic design by Alexander Dodge and spot-on costuming by Linda Cho. The most delightful thing, though, is the fantastic turn by Atlanta favorite Googie Uterhardt as ... well ... the whole D'Ysquith family.

The story of Monty Navarro (Haden Rider) begins on the eve of his possible execution as he sits in jail writing his memoirs. We learn that Monty, a social nobody, is hoping to win the love of Sibella Hallward (Leigh Ellen Jones). Unfortunately for Monty, Sibella is a social climber who wouldn't think of marrying a nobody like Monty. Silly, silly fun ensues when Monty finds out that he's ninth in line to inherit the earldom of Highhurst and begins to see a real hope for his future with Sibella, especially if he can jump the line of succession by killing the heirs who stand in his way.

Dodge's scenic design, which presents a gorgeous stage within a stage that frames most of the scenes, practically functions as a principal character as it cleverly moves us to all of the disparate settings for Monty's murders: the top of a tower, a fragrant garden, a skating pond, just to name a few. In one magical scene, paintings on the walls slide away to reveal actors playing the portraits' subjects. In another, the heads of the busts on the intricately detailed stage swing in to allow actors' heads to replace them. It's a whole wonderful spectacle, superbly complemented by the fun video projections that help us to fully appreciate moments like the first victim, Reverend Lord Ezekial D'Ysquith's, fall from a high tower and the ensuing splat on the concrete.

Like Dodge's scenic design, Linda Cho's richly detailed costume design is heavily inspired by the original Broadway production. And that's great because Cho's costumes perfectly depict the pretensions of London high society in 1907. Each costume of each D'Ysquith victim (for instance, a turn-of-the-century bodybuilding suit with a quite exaggerated ... crotch area) perfectly characterizes its owner, a particularly important victory in this show since the entire line of heirs is played by one man.

The company of players is capable and each approaches the operetta-style score with ease, but by far the most skilled at the farce is Googie Uterhardt. He portrays characters ranging from a country squire to Lady Salome (a very bad actress) to a social climbing spinster philanthropist. Each of his characters is hilariously rendered, and his wonderful slapstick exaggerations of his characters' respective (and mostly appalling) character traits are a joy to watch.

You. Dexter. American Psycho. A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder is but one entry in a growing catalogue of dizzyingly popular stories about serial killers. The thing that makes this entry stand out is the fact that the tuner, with super clever lyrics and book by Robert Freedman and Steven Lutvak, renders Monty so likable in the midst of such a heinously premeditated murder spree. At the time of its premiere, The New York Times called the show "entertainment most merry," and that definitely holds true here at City Springs. I guess you could say they've put on a killer comedy.

A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder plays through March 15 at City Springs Theatre.

For tickets and info, visit

Join Team BroadwayWorld

Are you an avid theatre goer in Atlanta? We're looking for people like you to share your thoughts and insights with our readers. Team BroadwayWorld members get access to shows to review, conduct interviews with artists, and the opportunity to meet and network with fellow theatre lovers and arts workers.

Interested? Learn more here.

From This Author - Amy Zipperer

Amy Zipperer is an award-winning playwright whose short plays have been produced across the United States and Canada. She currently teaches creative writing and theatre at Georgia Military College in... (read more about this author)

BWW Review: A Well-Sung Sondheim Favorite Ends the Long Period of Darkness in Sandy Springs
July 12, 2021

Into the Woods is a solid and well-sung outing for City Springs Theatre Company to mark the opening of a newly planned season full of beloved musicals, including The Sound of Music and West Side Story.

June 16, 2021

D&D WITH DEEDEE:  THE ADVANCED DUNGEONS AND DRAGONS TUTORIAL, the Barbed Tales' audio play included in this year’s Fringe Audio, is a funny character-driven piece that takes a clever behind-the-scenes look at the nature of beginning podcast production.

BWW Review: DATA at Alliance Theatre
May 13, 2021

DATA, the winner of this year’s Alliance/Kendeda National Graduate Playwriting Competition is available to stream on demand or to experience as a live virtual event through the Alliance Theatre Anywhere Series at Alliance Theatre this month.

Summer Camp Highlights: City Springs Theatre, Alliance Theatre, GA Ensemble, and Aurora Theatre Offer Theatre Camps for All Ages
April 14, 2021

Summer is looking pretty bright this year.  And we’re not even talking about the reemergence of the reliable Georgia summer sun.  We’re talking about the real patrons in the stadium seats. We’re talking about live summer concerts with our favorite sweaty koozies.  And we’re talking about the highly anticipated return of another fun summer staple:  theatre camp!

BWW Interview: Nichole Palmietto of THE SHIFT at Found Stages
March 16, 2021

When we finally shake this pandemic off for good, we’re going to be left with an extensive new vocabulary that includes all-things-Zoom.  There’s Zoombombing.  We've got the popular Covideo party.  And there’s my favorite:  Zoom fatigue.  This month, Found Stages, one of Atlanta’s most innovative theatre companies, is tapping into our increasingly impressive knowledge of Zoom with a Zoom theatre production called The Shift.  BroadwayWorld caught up with director Nichole Palmietto to talk about the show.