Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: THE PIRATES OF PENZANCE, Opera Holland Park

The very model of a modern rib-tickling operetta

Review: THE PIRATES OF PENZANCE, Opera Holland Park

Review: THE PIRATES OF PENZANCE, Opera Holland Park Opera Holland Park offers a variety of dishes to hungry audiences throughout the season. After the meatier affair of La Traviata and concept cuisine The Cunning Little Vixen, we move on to the chocolate soufflé of The Pirates of Penzance. However, like any light - but refined - dessert, creating a bowl of light and fluffy nonsense can be more difficult than it appears. Opera Holland Park, with Gilbert and Sullivan specialist Charles Court Opera, manages to serve up a flavoursome evening of silliness that's every bit as accomplished as existential angst or momentous tragedy.

The plot is bonkers, but clever in a Monty Python cheese sketch kind of way. A band of pirates celebrate Frederic's 21st birthday, which sees the end of his apprenticeship to them; years ago, Frederic's nursemaid, Ruth (vividly evoked by Yvonne Howard) apprenticed Frederic (confident tenor Peter Kirk) to them by mistake.

Angry Frederic wants to exterminate the pirates - they're useless at their jobs anyway, with a softness for pardoning orphans. Ruth desires escaping with Frederic and becoming his bride, but he has other ideas when he spots the Major-General's young daughters and proposes to Mabel (a standout performance by coloratura Daisy Brown).

The satirical romp involves the Major-General (Richard Burkhard, energetic as the Duracell Bunny) avoiding death by the pirates and an unsuccessful police rescue. Meanwhile, there's a hint of modern slavery when the pirates tell Frederic he was born in a leap year, so is really only five and a quarter and still an apprentice. All is well once Ruth reveals that the pirates are all of noble birth, so they're subsequently pardoned.

Multi-skilled John Savournin, starring as the Pirate King and also director of the two-act comic opera, immerses us in a Toy Story-like world where a child's birthday gifts - a Playmobil pirate ship, wind-up toy soldier and brightly coloured bricks - are brought to life.

We feast on designer Rachel Szmukler's set of giant toy boxes and bricks, clockwork Major-General Stanley with a key in his back to crank him up, OTT garish frills and bows for the General's daughters (my companion thinks they resemble late-Victorian Spice Girls), and the pirates attired in daft red-and-white stripy tops, pantaloons and stuffed parrots. Think The Nutcracker on speed.

Lighting by Jake Wiltshire is highly effective. In particular, his use of blue and white floods shining from the back of the set admirably signal, in turn, danger, seaside calm and upbeat radiance.

Conductor David Eaton is as sympathetic to the performers as a chef is to his diners, gently keeping the whole production together and maintaining the balance between singers and a reduced City of London Sinfonia. The size of the orchestra is just right for this operetta. You don't always require a hearty a la carte offering of strings; the woodwind ably sets the tone.

Gilbert and Sullivan's beloved signature hits - "I am the very model of a modern Major-General", "A policeman's lot is not a happy one" and "Tarantara" - are happily received. And yet, for a show whose triumph relies on clear quick-witted lyrics, at times it's a struggle to hear everything the cast conveys. It's a shame the audience has to rely so much on subtitles. On the plus side, the Opera Holland Park Chorus is busy throughout, gamely portraying pirates, police officers and the General's daughters.

The Pirates of Penzance is a recipe for fun - both delicious and diverting. A tasting menu with wine pairing par excellence. Tarantara!

The 2021 season continues until 17 August. For more information contact

Photo credit: Ali Wright

From This Author - Cheryl Markosky

Hooked on theatre when a student usher at Theatre Calgary in her native Canada, Cheryl champions not only London's West End, but also regional venues. Splitting her time between Londo... (read more about this author)

Review: HEAR MYSELF THINK Podcast, Series 2Review: HEAR MYSELF THINK Podcast, Series 2
November 18, 2022

During lockdown, Hear Myself Think's mini audio-theatre podcasts exploring mental health offered solace to listeners in more than 25 countries. Coming from diverse perspectives, they're aimed at communities less likely to get support for mental health issues.

Review: DIDO AND AENEAS, Theatre Royal BathReview: DIDO AND AENEAS, Theatre Royal Bath
October 21, 2022

It's a double first at Theatre Royal Bath with Henry Purcell's Dido and Aeneas. Regarded as England's first opera when initially performed around 1688, it's also the first opera to be performed in the intimate Ustinov Studio.

Review: GOOD LUCK, STUDIO, Salisbury PlayhouseReview: GOOD LUCK, STUDIO, Salisbury Playhouse
October 19, 2022

Mischief's new catastrophe comedy, Good Luck, Studio, goes very wrong - but perhaps not in the way the Mischief team intended.

Review: THE WELLSPRING. Salisbury PlayhouseReview: THE WELLSPRING. Salisbury Playhouse
October 13, 2022

The Wellspring is a new father and son two-hander by award-winning playwright Barney Norris (Visitors, Eventide, Nightfall) and novelist (Five Rivers Met on a Wooded Plain, Undercurrent); and his father - pianist, composer and broadcaster David Owen Norris.

Review: SPIKE, Salisbury PlayhouseReview: SPIKE, Salisbury Playhouse
October 5, 2022

In a fabulously fast-paced and funny tribute to Spike Milligan, writers Ian Hislop and Nick Newman affectionately convey how the extraordinary Anglo-Irishman creates The Goon Show.