Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: VANYA AND SONIA AND MASHA AND SPIKE IS DARK NEUROTIC COMEDY at West Coast Players

Under the direction of Donna Donnelly at West Coast Players, VANYA AND SONIA AND MASHA AND SPIKE takes place in the family's estate and introduces us to whiny, middle-aged siblings, adopted daughter, Sonia (Janice Creneti) and biological son, Vanya (Thom Jay) who were left to take care of their ailing and now deceased parents.

At first I thought they were husband and bipolar wife on the verge of divorce, but it was revealed they were the caretakers of academic parents who named their children after characters in Anton Chekhov plays and were peculiarly devoted to community theatre. The parents became victims of Alzheimer's and the two siblings never moved on to leave their estate when their parents died.

The stagnant pair have been existed drinking their morning coffee and afternoon tea, eating twinkies, reading the paper, watching the blue herons on the lake and basically bickering over nothing to fill the emptiness that is their lives. In a nod to Chekhov, Sonia argues with her brother whether 9 or 10 cherry trees on the property constitutes a cherry orchard. The acting was good, but I didn't find myself endeared to either of Christopher Durang's flawed characters.

In contrast, their sister Masha (SuzAnne Delaney) has been traipsing across the world as a sexy horror movie queen, bankrolling the estate and her siblings' lives or lack thereof, giving them no reason to change or better themselves. When she comes home for an unexpected visit with her boy-toy in tow with plans to sell the family home, Masha wreaks havoc.

Suzanne is delightful as the overdramatic, narcissistic actress who cannot tolerate being out of the spotlight, whose fame came from a horror movie series "The Sexy Killer." At one point, Masha makes a joke at her own expense, revealing insecurities, suggesting she is like Norma Desmond, the delusional self-absorbed has-been actress in "Sunset Boulevard."

Drew Smith is thoroughly entertaining as the gorgeous millennial character Spike who could have maybe be cast in "Entourage 2," who only cares about being adored, working out, texting, being adored, stripping to his underwear, and- well- being adored. His reverse striptease made me literally laugh out loud.

Yet it is two smaller roles that completely blew me away.

A standout performance by Cherie B. Albury as Cassandra, the voodoo psychic housekeeper, harbinger of assorted doom and gloom, drives the action and adds a dimension that the other characters lacked. Cherie reminded of Carole Burnett if she were a cleaning lady and a soothsayer. I absolutely adored this character and looked forward to every time she took to the stage - whether peeking through a window or stabbing a voodoo doll.

Newcomer to West Coast Players, Rebecca Hamburg plays an aspiring actress and visiting neighbor, Nina. She is a breath of fresh air in the stagnant house who catches Spike's eye and causes Masha's jealousy. Nina's bubbliness and enthusiasm are contagious and she is the perfect high-energy, kinetic anthesis needed to the other title-named characters.

The first act is good, but it is the second act that is superb.

It is Vanya that has most of the best lines, including a monologue when Spike is rudely only half-listening to his play and texting. It is a social commentary that almost feels part of a different show, noticeably had both the actresses on stage and audience tearing up as he rails against change, technology, separate lives and disconnection caused by no shared memories anymore- "We licked postage stamps."
This scene was both mine and the cast's favorite.

Sonia's portrayal of the Snow White's Evil Queen, imagined with a fake accent as Dame Maggie Smith on her way to the Oscars was brilliant. Her conversation on the telephone, hesitant to use her normal voice made me actually see a different side of her character and I liked this softened then empowered version of her.

In contrast to millions who love his writing, I've decided that I'm not a fan of Durang's style of dialogue in this play. I don't like watching a play and feel like I'm watching a play. His wordsmithing at times felt stilted and disconnected, much like Chekhov's works. That being said, it has nothing to do with the acting. The cast in this 2013 Tony winner for best play were utterly fantastic in their roles and if you have a chance, you should definitely go see the show running through May 7.



Previews: SANTAS ZOMBIE APOCALYPSE at Straz Teco Theatre Photo
Twenty-two Patel Conservatory students, ages 10 to 18, perform in this action-packed holiday play, assisted by eight apprentices. The student apprentices design most of the show, from full costumes to the colorful video-game-influenced set.

Review: Kander & Ebbs Brilliant, Terrifically Terrifying CABARET at the Asolo Rep Photo
It's a technical marvel from all aspects, with an outstanding cast beautifully directed by Josh Rhodes.

West Coast Players Presents HOW TO SURVIVE YOUR FAMILY AT CHRISTMAS Photo
West Coast Players will present William Missouri Downs' How to Survive Your Family at Christmas, directed by Jimmy Chang, from December 2-11, 2022.

Hillsborough County Students Come to Tampa Theatre for American Stage Bilangual Kids  Photo
For many of the students coming to the Tampa Theatre for a field trip this December 5 and 6, Cinderella Eats Rice and Beans will be the first time they will experience live theatre. Not to mention, live theatre with an all-Latin cast speaking both English and Spanish. 


From This Author - Deborah Bostock-Kelley

A twice-published author, multi-time award-winning playwright, magazine writer, theatre reviewer, and newspaper journalist with 30+ years in journalism and business copywriting, Deb was a 2019 Reci... (read more about this author)


Previews: SANTA'S ZOMBIE APOCALYPSE at Straz' Teco TheatrePreviews: SANTA'S ZOMBIE APOCALYPSE at Straz' Teco Theatre
November 29, 2022

Twenty-two Patel Conservatory students, ages 10 to 18, perform in this action-packed holiday play, assisted by eight apprentices. The student apprentices design most of the show, from full costumes to the colorful video-game-influenced set.

Previews: PLAID TIDINGS at Straz CenterPreviews: PLAID TIDINGS at Straz Center
November 21, 2022

In this sequel, a heavenly phone call from Rosemary Clooney inspires The Plaids to return for a posthumous Christmas performance to bring a little harmony to a discordant world. With music from the 50s and 60s combined with traditional holiday standards, this “heaven-sent” holiday confection promises to fill the audience with nostalgia for a bygone era.

Previews: THE NIGHT BEFORE at FreeFall Theatre CompanyPreviews: THE NIGHT BEFORE at FreeFall Theatre Company
November 21, 2022

The Night Before imagines four friends snowed in Florida on December 23. They make the best of an odd weather situation, gathering around the piano for a night of fun, music, and games, accompanied by a surly house cat named Stephen Sondheim.

Previews: A NUMBER at Off-Central PlayersPreviews: A NUMBER at Off-Central Players
November 11, 2022

'Most every script you pick up begins with some sort of description, by the author, about the setting, time, place, etc. With A Number, Ms. Churchill gave us three words: ‘Where Salter Lives’ - that throws the door open to virtually any possibility,' said junior director Alan Mohney.

Previews: A DOLL'S HOUSE, PART 2 at Tampa Repertory TheatrePreviews: A DOLL'S HOUSE, PART 2 at Tampa Repertory Theatre
November 8, 2022

Under the direction of Stephanie Gularte, this award-winning comedy features a recognized cast of L. Peter Callender (Torvald), Emilia Sargent (Nora), Karla Hartley (Anne Marie), and Bria Matthews (Emmy.)