My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

EDINBURGH 2023: Review: CAROLINE RHEA: I IDENTIFY AS A WITCH, Gilded Balloon

Caroline Rhea: I Identify As a Witch runs until 18 August

By:
EDINBURGH 2023: Review: CAROLINE RHEA: I IDENTIFY AS A WITCH, Gilded Balloon

EDINBURGH 2023: Review: CAROLINE RHEA: I IDENTIFY AS A WITCH, Gilded Balloon Image

It’s been nine years since Caroline Rhea’s last appearance at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe and she’s back for four nights only with I Identify As A Witch.

One quick look at the demographic of her audience and Rhea decides to scale back on the menopause chat, declaring us to be a definite “Sabrina crowd”. Having performed at the festival a few times and having spent childhood summers with family in Islay, she’s got the Scottish accent nailed and does some excellent reenactments of interactions she’s had here. 

It’s quite a casual hour that covers her dating life, parenting a teenager and a lot of audience chitchat. Rhea is undeniably charming and nobody seems to mind, even when she’s poking fun. At this particular performance, she set her sights on a gentleman that she sees as marriage material. This could have gone horribly wrong for someone else but it was taken in good humour. 

Rhea remarks that often when fans stop her for a photo, they then have to excuse themselves as she engages them in conversation for just a little too long. The show doesn’t seem to follow a set structure and is more like anecdotes that pop into her head and she needs a reminder about running over time. 

It’s ever so slightly chaotic but I Identify As A Witch is a brilliant and consistently hilarious hour in the company of a very charismatic host.



Reader Reviews

To post a comment, you must register and login.

Theater Fans' Choice Awards
2026 Theater Fans' Choice Awards - Live Stats
Best New Play - Top 3
1. Liberation
30.5% of votes
2. Giant
16.2% of votes
3. Dog Day Afternoon
15.3% of votes

Need more Scotland Theatre News in your life?
Sign up for all the news on the Spring season, discounts & more...


Videos


Sapphire McIntosh: Squeaky Bum Time in Scotland Sapphire McIntosh: Squeaky Bum Time
Unerbelly Bristo Square - Daisy Room (8/05-8/30)
Concerts of the Future in Scotland Concerts of the Future
Summerhall (Lobby) (8/06-8/30)
Shamilton! The Improvised Hip Hop Musical  in Scotland Shamilton! The Improvised Hip Hop Musical
Assembly George Square Studios - One (8/05-8/30)
Disney''s Muppet Christmas Carol in Concert in Scotland Disney''s Muppet Christmas Carol in Concert
Usher Hall (12/03-12/03)
Dracula: Lucy's Dream in Scotland Dracula: Lucy's Dream
Pleasance at EICC (Lennox) (8/06-8/29)
Glass Child in Scotland Glass Child
Summerhall (Old Lab) (8/06-8/16)
Friendliest in Scotland Friendliest
Gilded Balloon (The Nook) (8/08-8/31)
Furniture Boys in Scotland Furniture Boys
Underbelly (Jersey) (8/05-8/30)
Glob in Scotland Glob
Underbelly (McEwan Hall) (8/05-8/30)
Heated Rivalry: The Musical Parody! in Scotland Heated Rivalry: The Musical Parody!
Gilded Balloon Patter House - Other Yin (8/05-8/30)