Review: SCROOGE IN LOVE A New Audience Favorite

Only in San Francisco will theatregoers find the Ghosts of Christmas Past, Present, and, yes, even Future dancing together on one stage. The mysterious figure clad in all black bops its head back and forth in just one of many surprising delights awaiting audiences throughout new musical "Scrooge in Love!" 42nd Street Moon gives the "Christmas Carol" sequel a perfect premiere at the intimate Eureka Theatre, now through December 13.

A year after the original haunting, Ebenezer Scrooge boasts to Jacob Marley of his newfound reputation as a beloved benefactor. But Scrooge has one more lesson to learn, Marley states, and he cannot find true happiness without it. The three ghosts of Christmas return to help Ebenezer learn that "You Can't Put a Price on Love."

Elise Youssef eagerly skips down the aisle with bubble guns in hand, perhaps getting some inspiration from the Ghost of Christmas Past in 1988's film "Scrooged." Then comes Will Springhorn, Jr.'s hearty Ghost of Christmas Present with the reminder that the "present" is a gift not to be lost. David Naughton dons the dark garb of the Ghost of Christmas Future.

Scrooge once again visits Fezziwig's holiday party and witnesses his first meeting with the love of his youth, Belle. Here, the script slightly deviates from Charles Dickens' novella. Scrooge and Belle never become engaged, and Belle leaves because of a misunderstanding. The changes serve the story, however, as Scrooge glimpses what has become of Belle and wonders at "The Things You Should Have Done."

Creators Larry Grossman (of "Snoopy!!!" fame), Kellen Blair and Duane Poole give their title character some beautiful moments of contemplation. Guest star Jason Graae's comedic charms are familiar to Sacramento and the Bay Area audiences, but his tender Scrooge showcases a lovely, versatile voice, and provokes a tear or two in songs such as "A Kitchen Built for Twenty" (with a table set for one).

Of course, dancing and singing ghosts and a cheerful ensemble equal plenty of good humor, as well. Youssef breaks glass (off stage) with her striking, operatic voice, during her sensational and extravagant "I Love Love." The Cratchit family, including a now-well Tiny Tim, muses over the qualities of a perfect wife for Scrooge. And Scrooge rejoices at his own future death because it means Belle still loves him. Ryan Drummond also steals much of the show with his tongue-in-cheek speech and morbid mannerisms as the ghost of Jacob Marley.

With eloquent book and captivating song so well balanced and an all-around fantastic cast, "Scrooge in Love" has a bright future ahead. Audiences will love "Love," from the whimsical clockwork scenic design (by Hector Zavala) to the excellent three-person orchestra led by the always-enthusiastic Dave Dobrusky.


42nd Street Moon's Eureka Theatre
Through December 13
Tickets at
Photo Credit: Patrick O'Connor?

Follow all the latest Bay Area Theatre and Arts news on our San Francisco Facebook Page. Click here to visit the page today!

Follow Harmony Wheeler's theatre and opera adventures on Instagram and Twitter @HarmonyWheeler


Cast and Creative Team Revealed For OTHELLO at San Jose Stage Company

San Jose Stage Company has announced the full cast and creative team for The Stage’s upcoming Jazz-Infused Adaptation of William Shakespeare’s OTHELLO.

Review: LET THE RIGHT ONE IN at Berkeley Repertory Theatre

What did our critic think of LET THE RIGHT ONE IN at Berkeley Repertory Theatre?

San Francisco Opera's Italian Roots Celebrated in New Museo Italo Americano Exhibition

The Museo Italo Americano celebrates the 100th anniversary of San Francisco Opera with a new exhibition: BRAVO—Celebrating San Francisco Opera, Its Italian Roots and Legacy. Presented in partnership with San Francisco Opera and Museum of Performance + Design, the exhibition runs through October 22, 2023 at the Museo Italo Americano located at Fort Mason Center in San Francisco.

Merola Opera Program kicks off its 2023 Summer Festival With METAMORPHOSIS

San Francisco’s internationally acclaimed Merola Opera Program kicks off its 2023 Summer Festival with Metamorphosis: Recovery, Renewal, and Rebirth, an uplifting vocal and piano concert featuring a rich array of songs that explore the many facets of transformation.

From This Author - Harmony Wheeler


#repshow# in[i]# Shipwrecked! An Entertainment
Cinnabar Theater (4/12-4/28)
#repshow# in[i]# Axle Surgeons of California, Inc.
Axle Surgeons of California & Northern California - Axle Doctor (5/26-12/31)
#repshow# in[i]# The Road to Mecca
Z Below (6/04-6/30)
#repshow# in[i]# "Best of Enemies" (NT Live)
Hammer Theatre Center (6/14-6/18)
#repshow# in[i]# Killing My Lobster Presents: Toon Out
447 Minna (5/25-6/10)
#repshow# in[i]# Madame Tussauds Singapore Show
Breathing Storytellers (5/08-5/17)
#repshow# in[i]# The Whole Package
Phoenix Theater (6/20-6/20)
#repshow# in[i]# "Adam Strauss Is Not Unhappy"
The Marsh (5/12-6/16)
#repshow# in[i]# Fiesta Cultural
Lesher Center for the Arts (6/20-6/25)

Recommended For You