Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: PRIVATE LIVES at The Schoolhouse Theater

Love, Laughter and Lots of Baggage!

By:
Review: PRIVATE  LIVES at The Schoolhouse Theater

Private Lives is Noël Coward’s finest comedy, originally written for himself and his close friend Gertrude Lawrence. After touring the British provinces, the play opened at London’s Phoenix Theatre in 1930, starring Coward, Lawrence, Adrianne Allen, and Laurence Olivier. A Broadway production followed in 1931, and the play has since been revived numerous times in both the West End and on Broadway. It was also made into a film in 1931 and has been adapted several times for television and radio.  

This comedy of manners features a glamorous couple with a turbulent past relationship. They meet by chance at a hotel five years after their divorce. As fate would have it, they are both on honeymoons with new spouses and discover that they still have intense feelings for one another. They run off together to Paris, leaving their confused partners behind. 

What follows is a tempestuous, hilarious ride. 

Director Owen Thompson has assembled a talented cast. Coward’s fiery dialogue is delivered with elegance and skill. Thompson’s direction is brisk and well staged, filled with sharp comic timing and equally well-played moments of pathos.  

Patrick Zeller, returning after his acclaimed performance as Valmont in last season’s Les Liaisons Dangereuses, plays Elyot. He is thoroughly persuasive as the suave, sophisticated Elyot Chase, while also revealing his character’s vulnerability and total befuddlement when circumstances spin out of control. 

Olivia Gilliatt brings elegance and cool haughtiness to Amanda Prynne. She is equally charming and wicked, with a fragility hidden beneath the surface. 

Zeller and Gilliatt have terrific chemistry, whether they are cuddling or Amanda is breaking a record over Elyot’s head. Their clashes are intricately choreographed, with the two actors leaping over furniture in a wonderfully physical sequence. Dan O’Driscoll does an excellent job staging the fights, and the physical comedy is delivered with superb timing. 

Their new and decidedly unsuitable spouses are the insipid Sybil Chase and the pompous but shy Victor Prynne. 
The wonderful Kate Day Magosci, also returning from Les Liaisons Dangereuses, plays Sybil. She is in awe of Elyot and loves him with deep devotion yet has extraordinarily little understanding of the man she married. Her bewilderment at his behavior feels wonderfully genuine, as does her spectacular blubbering.  

Zachary Clark brings just the right combination of pomposity and earnestness to Victor, especially when he takes it upon himself to criticize Amanda or straighten out Elyot. 

Abby Malczon is delightful as Louise, bringing comic energy and physical agility to the harried maid while navigating her fluent French with ease. 

Hayden Bingham designed the Art Deco sets, including adjoining balconies at the seaside hotel and a lavish Paris living room filled with the rich furnishings and trappings of the 1930s. Kudos, too, for the perfectly curated properties throughout the production.  

The show is splendidly lit by Dennis Parichy. Nancy Nichols’ gorgeous period costumes range from bouncy and playful to stylishly elegant. The sound design by Jessica Klee and Owen Thompson includes Noël Coward songs that add just the right hint of the period whenever needed. 

The skilled supporting crew includes Kevin E. Thompson, stage manager; Isabelle Favette and Cass Wolff, scenic artists; Imani Gallimore and Abby Malczon, running crew; Sofia Lavion, Production manager. 

Go see it! You will laugh out loud. It’s funny, fast-paced, and filled with the kind of sparkling dialogue that makes you wish you could be half as clever in an argument. Private Lives is a wonderfully entertaining evening at the theater. 

Following Private Lives, which runs through September 20, the Schoolhouse Theater will present James Goldman’s gripping historical drama The Lion in Winter, running December 4–20.  

All performances are at the North Salem Community Center 

3 Owens Road 
Croton Falls, NY 10519  

Tickets are available at www.theschoolhousetheater.org or by calling (914) 473-7111 

Photo by Doug Abdelnour.

Click Here to Get Tickets
More on The Schoolhouse Theater
Upcoming Shows
Private Lives
Private Lives
9/4 - 9/20/2026

Reader Reviews

Don't Miss a Rockland / Westchester News Story
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...

Local Shows
Private Lives in Rockland / Westchester Private Lives
The Schoolhouse Theater (9/04-9/20)
The Last Five Years in Rockland / Westchester The Last Five Years
Arc Stages (9/25-9/25)
Las Guaracheras in Rockland / Westchester Las Guaracheras
Las Guaracheras (10/16-10/16)
The Real Thing in Rockland / Westchester The Real Thing
Katonah Classic Stage (10/22-11/01)
Bees Deluxe in Rockland / Westchester Bees Deluxe
Bees Deluxe (10/30-10/30)
Conigliaro Consort in Rockland / Westchester Conigliaro Consort
Jazz On Main (9/18-9/18)
CATCH in Rockland / Westchester CATCH
SUNY New Paltz Theater (9/25-10/04)
Pete Rodriguez Quartet in Rockland / Westchester Pete Rodriguez Quartet
Jazz On Main (9/26-9/26)
Sunday Jazz Brunch- Host by Ron Drotos in Rockland / Westchester Sunday Jazz Brunch- Host by Ron Drotos
Jazz On Main (9/27-9/27)
Masque of the Red Death in Rockland / Westchester Masque of the Red Death
Lyndhurst-Theater-36 (10/15-10/30)

BroadwayWorld TV