Skip to main content Skip to footer site map


An excellent rewrite of Ibsen's AN ENEMY OF THE PEOPLE


A LIE AGREED UPON is an excellent rewrite of Henrik Ibsen's 1882 play, AN ENEMY OF THE PEOPLE, and the performances are more than equal to the bold material.

Tony Estrella, the writer and director of this production, did not deviate far from the source material, in his reworking of An Enemy of the People, and as the story unfolds it becomes all too clear that the show's late 19th century themes remain relevant as ever. That the definition of truth and media impartiality are under threat, and the meddling of powerful economic interests threaten the well-being of well, everything and everyone. A Lie Agreed Upon follows the story of Dr. Thomas Stockman (Sean McConaghy), a medical examiner charged with inspecting the public hot springs that he helped to promote...and on which the prosperity of his hometown depends. When Stockman finds the water to be contaminated, his attempts to speak the truth are shut down by a growing mob that includes the mayor, Peter Stockman (Jonathan Higginbotham), who is also his brother. While the rewrite doesn't define the decade being portrayed, that hardly matters when so many of the characters' situations and declarations could be ripped from today's headlines and news articles.

From the leads to the actors embodying the townspeople, there is not a weak link in the cast. Sean McConaghy brings the right amount of pathos to the role of the doctor who just wants to do the right thing for the town he loves based on the scientific evidence he's discovered. As his counterpart, Jonathan Higginbotham is perfect as the mayor who is frustratingly skeptical about the seriousness of the doctor's claims, and moreso of his proposed, very expensive solutions that might be difficult for the town to weather. The newspaper crew who find themselves torn between the interests of both camps are played by Nora Eschenheimer (as Thea Hovstad), Jeff Ararat (as Billings), and Fred Sullivan, Jr. (as Mr. Aslaksen). The issues they face illustrate the challenges faced by journalists to this day - the constant battle between wanting to present the truth while also being beholden to advertisers and those in power. And although she speaks but once, Aniko Moscarelli's physical performance as Greta Stockman leaves a big impact (note: the role is portrayed by Lola Darling during some shows). Kudos also to the several cast members making their Gamm Theatre debuts in this production, including the three 2021-2022 Gamm Fellows, Maria Noriko Cabral, Dan Garcia, and Erik Robles.

The scenery is sparse, largely consisting of chairs and a table, but are still able to transport the audience to a variety of settings. The show's lighting design is also used to good effect throughout the play, such as when its use enhances the broken fourth wall during the show's second half.

A Lie Agreed Upon could not be a more appropriate show for current times and makes for a perfect return to thought-provoking live theatre. Don't miss it.

A Lie Agreed Upon runs September 30th-October 24th at The Gamm Theatre, 1245 Jefferson Blvd., Warwick, RI. Tickets are $49-$69. Discounts for seniors, students, groups, and more are available. Details at For tickets, call 401-723-4266 or visit

For the safety and comfort of Gamm audiences, all patrons must present either proof of vaccination or a negative COVID-19 test in order to enter the theatre. All patrons, regardless of vaccination status, must wear masks.

Pictured: Sean McConaghy (Dr. Thomas Stockman) Background L to R: Donnla Hughes (Katherine Stockman), Aniko Moscarelli (Greta Stockman), Maria Noriko Cabral (Townsperson), Erik Robles (Townsperson), Sarah Sinclair (Townsperson). Photo by Peter Goldberg.

THE HUMANS At Wilbury Theatre Group Extends Photo
Wilbury Theatre Group has announced the extension of the Rhode Island premiere of Tony-Award winner for Best Play (2016) The Humans by Stephen Karam, directed by Josh Short. Now running through December 18, the production features Jim O'Brien, Jeanine Kane, Rachel Dulude, Jessie March, Dave Rabinow, & Carol Varden.

Voting Now Open For The 2022 BroadwayWorld Rhode Island Awards Photo
Voting is now open for the 2022 BroadwayWorld Rhode Island Awards! Nominations were reader-submitted and now our readers get to vote for their favorites.

Photos: Burbage Theatre Co Presents Kate Hamills SENSE & SENSIBILITY Photo
See photos from Burbage Theatre Co's playful adaptation of Jane Austen’s timeless classic Sense & Sensibility.

The Festival Ballet Providence to Present THE NUTCRACKER This Holiday Season Photo
The Festival Ballet Providence, well known for their curated ballet and dance series, educational programs and community outreach returns to the Veterans Memorial Auditorium December 16-24 with their fresh, new The Nutcracker.

From This Author - Erica Cataldi-Roberts

A life-long Rhode Islander, Erica has been an avid theatre-goer since being taken to children's shows at the Warwick Musical Theatre. She is also an academic librarian in Boston, an occasional ... (read more about this author)

Review: THE HUMANS at Wilbury Theatre GroupReview: THE HUMANS at Wilbury Theatre Group
November 20, 2022

What did our critic think of THE HUMANS at Wilbury Theatre Group?

November 10, 2022

What did our critic think of SWEAT at THE GAMM THEATRE? For the better part of the last 40 years, things have been a nightmare for the American working class, especially across the so called 'rust belt' where factories once thrived and have now fallen silent and abandoned. In SWEAT, Lynn Nottage's Pulitzer prize winning play, the playwright takes us directly into that world with a piercing look at small town America and the destruction wrought in those communities by de-industrialization, racism, violence, and addiction.

BWW Review: Radiant NATASHA, PIERRE, & THE GREAT COMET OF 1812 At Wilbury Theatre GroupBWW Review: Radiant NATASHA, PIERRE, & THE GREAT COMET OF 1812 At Wilbury Theatre Group
May 31, 2022

When Dave Malloy’s NATASHA, PIERRE, & THE GREAT COMET OF 1812 closed on Broadway in late 2017, fans of the show (myself included) lamented when, or if, it would be possible to see any iteration of this show again. Thanks to the Wilbury Theatre Group, our hopes have been answered! Known for its eclectic score, ranging through music styles from electronic dance music to folk, GREAT COMET featured a 360 degree, interactive experience no matter where one sat in the theatre. And, with a cast who could act, sing, and play instruments, it seemed unlikely that the show would ever have legs in a regional setting. Fortunately, the Wilbury Theatre Group is more than up to the challenge.

BWW Review: Brilliant OKLAHOMA! at the Providence Performing Arts CenterBWW Review: Brilliant OKLAHOMA! at the Providence Performing Arts Center
March 24, 2022

Warning: this is not your traditional version of OKLAHOMA!, and good riddance. Without changing a word of the book or lyrics, director Daniel Fish has created a revival of the 1943 musical that highlights different aspects of the material simply by changing the tone in which scenes are presented. The story has always been one of a community banding together against an outsider, but that aspect of the show is usually buried in favor of the sunnier, romantic elements of the plot. Not so this time. While the show loses some of its oomph by no longer being presented in the round, as it was during its run on Broadway at the Circle in the Square Theatre, there is still plenty to like even when presented in a traditional space like the Providence Performing Arts Center’s.

BWW Review: Festival Ballet Providence's UP CLOSE ON HOPE ReturnsBWW Review: Festival Ballet Providence's UP CLOSE ON HOPE Returns
February 19, 2022

Festival Ballet Providence’s popular UP CLOSE ON HOPE series returns to their black box theatre. This innovative program is comprised of four unrelated pieces – two contemporary, one neoclassical, and one romantic, two of which are world-premieres. These shows are the perfect way for audiences to experience different styles of dance, and that is certainly true with this specific line-up.