Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

The Unbelievers Off-Broadway Reviews

About the Show

A teenager disappears. Time fractures. His mother will never give up hope. The Unbelievers is a new play about the moments that shatter our world, and the ones that help us... (more info)

Theatre City Center Stage 1
Previews Oct 13, 2026
Opened Nov 5, 2026
Critics' Rating
7.00 Mixed
3 Positive
4 Mixed
0 Negative
Readers' Rating
No ratings yet
Rate This Show
Select a score 1–10
Write a Review

Critics' Reviews

The play’s almost clinical approach to the investigation and its impact on the family has an admirable forensic authenticity, but Miriam’s anguish is left so little explored that her plight never becomes particularly affecting or illuminating.

The real genius of the piece is the way it always keeps things shifting — you never quite know where you stand, what timeline we are in, how to feel, or whom to align with. The clever writing, expert direction, and outstanding performances work in ...

5
Thumbs Sideways

The Unbelievers: Drama Sometimes Tests Credulity

From: New York Stage Review  |  By: David Finkle  |  Date: 11/5/2026

And director’s wants to bring out all the inflammatory potential. Knud Adams is the director and steers a strong cast throughout. But it’s the Ambrose-Adams team that gives The Unbelievers double A marks.

9
Thumbs Up

Review: An Unmissable Lauren Ambrose in The Unbelievers

From: TheaterMania  |  By: Rachel Graham  |  Date: 11/5/2026

The Unbelievers is a deeply affecting piece about a woman slowly unwinding and a family desperately trying to keep her, and themselves, together. And with Ambrose as the lead, it’s unmissable.

Director Knud Adams strikes a nice balance between moments of levity and weightier conflict, including a climactic scene where Miriam is confronted by her loved ones about her decision to skip the memorial to chase a dubious lead abroad. It’s a sho...

Nick Payne’s The Unbelievers asks how long a family can hold its breath for a missing child, and Lauren Ambrose answers with a performance so ferocious that the waiting itself becomes the drama.

5
Thumbs Sideways

The Unbelievers

From: Time Out New York  |  By: Billy McEntee  |  Date: 11/6/2026

Looking at the living room onstage in The Unbelievers, you may sense that it feels off. The fireplace, wooden table and upright piano of Paul Steinberg’s set evoke a home, but there are no photographs or knickknacks, no centerpiece on the table: So...

Audience Reviews

No audience reviews yet.

Add Your Review

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $60
Hot Show
Tickets From $71