Is This Your Show?
Submit Updates & Sell More Tickets
I Think We're Lost at Theatre Exile
Dates: 4/10/2026 - 4/19/2026
📍 Theatre: Theatre Exile
Pier Players Theatre Company
Philadelphia, PA
Philadelphia, PA 19147
Tickets: $20.00 General Admission, Student and Industry discounted tickets available at the door
Share
Pier Players Theatre Company presents the world premiere of I Think We’re Lost, a darkly comedic reimagining of Peter Pan.
It’s 2026. Wendy is gone, and Peter considers leaving Neverland. To keep her fantasy alive, a scheming Tinker Bell recruits two new arrivals from Philadelphia—a “Lost Boy” and a “Wendy 2.0.” But as the newcomers confront their existential baggage, they uncover unsettling truths buried in Neverland’s past.
I Think We’re Lost is written by Peter Fenton, directed by Madison Caudullo, and produced by Chelsea Cylinder. The world premiere production is scheduled for April 10th-19th at Theatre Exile.
I Think We're Lost at Theatre Exile Schedule
Saturday, April 11th at 8:00pm
Sunday, April 12th at 2:00pm
Thursday, April 16th at 7:30pm
Friday, April 17th at 8:00pm
Saturday, April 18th at 8:00pm
Sunday, April 19th at 2:00pm
Cast and Creative Team for I Think We're Lost at Theatre Exile
Cast
Joshua Gold
Peter Pan
Vanessa Torres
Tinker Bell
Nina Vitek
Connor Forsyth
Chelsea Cylinder
Lindsay Plencner
Julianne Kastner
Maggie Wratten
Kate Brighter
Wendy Darling
Tyler Collins
James Hook
Miguel Ortega
Smee
Joseph Peachey
Flick, Eric, Peter Pan u/s
Audrey Ney
Lindsay Plencner u/s, Wendy Darling u/s
Doriane Feinstein
Tinker Bell u/s, Maggie Wratten u/s
Harrison Rothbaum
Smee u/s, Flick u/s, Eric u/s
Creative Team
Chelsea Cylinder
Producer
Peter Fenton
Playwright
Madison Caudullo
Director
Eleanor Safer
Stage Manager
Finn Warrick
Technical Director
Julianne Kastner
Marketing Director/Sound Designer
Kate Brighter
Props Designer/Fight Captain
Vanessa Torres
Costume Designer
Tyler Reppert
Set Designer
Elliot Konstant
Lighting Designer
Quinton J. Alexander
Fight Director
Dana Liu
Fight Assistant
Ivana R. Thompson
Fight Assistant
Lara Goldwert
Photographer
News About I Think We're Lost at Theatre Exile
We have no news on this show at the current time.
About the Theatre
Similar Shows Nearby
Theatre Exile Frequently Asked QuestionsFAQ
What shows are coming up next at Theatre Exile?
Endgame (09/10/26-09/27/26)
Where is Theatre Exile located?
Theatre Exile is at Philadelphia, PA, Philadelphia, PA.
What shows have played recently at Theatre Exile?
Endgame (09/10/26-09/27/26)
The Great Privation (How to Flip Ten Cents Into a Dollar) (05/28/26-06/14/26)
Long Live the Queen (a her-story of drag) (04/30/26-04/30/26)
Philly GRIT: Camp Cookie (03/26/26-03/26/26)
Philly GRIT: The Dangers of Tobacco (03/19/26-03/29/26)
Philly GRIT: A Vacation (03/18/26-02/28/26)
Philly GRIT (03/18/26-03/29/26)
JOB by Max Wolf Friedlich (10/30/25-11/16/25)
A Puppeteer with The Palsy Performs Scenes from Shakespeare or, the Ghost in the Machine (08/07/25-08/24/25)
Glitter in the Glass by R. Eric Thomas (05/29/25-06/15/25)
The Great Privation (How to Flip Ten Cents Into a Dollar) (05/28/26-06/14/26)
Long Live the Queen (a her-story of drag) (04/30/26-04/30/26)
Philly GRIT: Camp Cookie (03/26/26-03/26/26)
Philly GRIT: The Dangers of Tobacco (03/19/26-03/29/26)
Philly GRIT: A Vacation (03/18/26-02/28/26)
Philly GRIT (03/18/26-03/29/26)
JOB by Max Wolf Friedlich (10/30/25-11/16/25)
A Puppeteer with The Palsy Performs Scenes from Shakespeare or, the Ghost in the Machine (08/07/25-08/24/25)
Glitter in the Glass by R. Eric Thomas (05/29/25-06/15/25)
|
Brian Henson's Puppet Up! Ensemble Arts Philly - Miller Theatre (9/29-9/29) |
|
|
Jim Henson's Labyrinth: In Concert 40th Anniversary The Keswick Theatre (9/25-9/25) |
|
The Vampire Circus Keswick Theatre (10/10-10/10) |
|
Illumination Prima Theatre (11/20-12/23) |
|
Antigone Bristol Riverside Theatre (2/02-2/21) |
|
An American Christmas Songbook Bristol Riverside Theatre (12/15-12/22) |
|
The Lemonade Stand Fringe Hub Plays & Players (9/08-9/27) |
|
Karen Tenderness in... DOPPEL BÄNGER The Magic Gardens Studio (9/09-9/19) |
|
Turn the Beat! A Gloria Estefan Tribute Bristol Riverside Theatre (3/03-3/07) |
|
Bride To Be Plays & Players Theatre (9/12-9/20) |
