Get theatre news and discounts for Orlando
Bright Star show poster

Bright Star at Bay Street Players

Dates: 8/29/2025 - 9/14/2025

Theatre:

Bay Street Players


109 North Bay Street
Eustis,FL 32726

Phone: 3523577777

Tickets: 17.50-30


  1. View All Orlando Shows
  2.  > 
  3. Bright Star


Bright Star is the story of one woman at two different points in her life: the first, when she is a wild young thing growing up barefoot and carefree in the Blue Ridge Mountains of North Carolina; the second, when she is a well-to-do magazine editor in Asheville, 22 years later. Her story is inevitably woven with that of an idealistic young man named Billy, with whom she shares a mysterious connection. As a young teen in Zebulon, North Carolina, Alice Murphy is hopelessly in love with small town heartthrob Jimmy Ray, the mayor’s son. Although their love was pure, it falls victim to the interference of ambitious parents, and their infant son is whisked away before their happy ending could ever begin. More than two decades later, Alice is the successful editor of The Asheville Southern Journal, and meets a promising young writer named Billy. Eventually they realize that they share a hometown, and when Alice sees the handmade sweater she knitted for her baby 20 years before in his personal belongings, she realizes that he is the son she lost so long ago. Their happiness is compounded at the end of the story with a Shakespeare-esque double wedding. Bright Star opened to generally positive reviews and closed after 139 performances. The cast recording was nominated for the 2017 Grammy Award for Best Musical Theater Album.

Cast and Creative team for Bright Star at Bay Street Players

Cast

Noah Clark

Jimmy Ray


Cori Menzies

Mama


Nico Querino

Billy


Avry Aviles

Alice


Jeremy Kleckner

Daryl


Victoria Rivera

Margo


Savanna Dacosta

Lucy


Wendall Walls

Max


Joe Holtzer

Mayor Dobbs


Bailey Freye

Dr. Norquist


Aine Graham

Edna


Gregg Bleam

Daddy Murphy


Grace Godette

Florence


Emma Chippindale

Ensemble


Anna Klostermann

Ensemble


Katie O'Neill

Ensemble


Nicole Taylor

Ensemble


Abbe Piccolo

Ensemble


Kayla Kunz

Ensemble


Olivia Mitterando

Ensemble


Mary Anne Revell

Clerk


Creative Team

John Corneilson

Director


Ashley Peters

Director/Music Director


Molly Schoolmeester

Intimacy Director


David DiMassino

Scenic Design


Nicole Taylor

Choreographer




Bay Street Players Frequently Asked Questions FAQ

Videos


Tiara’s Hat Parade in Orlando Tiara’s Hat Parade
Orlando Family Stage (2/7 - 2/22)

NEW PLAY Tracker
From My Hometown in Orlando From My Hometown
The Winter Park Playhouse (1/23 - 2/21) Tracker
Yo, Ho, Ho! Let’s Go! in Orlando Yo, Ho, Ho! Let’s Go!
Orlando Family Stage (1/24 - 2/22) Tracker
Lilly and the Pirates the Musical in Orlando Lilly and the Pirates the Musical
Orlando Family Stage (2/21 - 3/15)

NEW MUSICAL Tracker
Cirque Ma'Ceo LIVE in Lutz - Feb 27 - Mar 8, 2026 in Orlando Cirque Ma'Ceo LIVE in Lutz - Feb 27 - Mar 8, 2026
Avalon Stables (2/27 - 3/8)
The Notebook in Orlando The Notebook
Dr. Phillips Center for the Performing Arts (5/12 - 5/17)
Meredith Willson’s THE MUSIC MAN in Orlando Meredith Willson’s THE MUSIC MAN
King Center (4/12 - 4/13)
Theatre People or The Angel Next Door in Orlando Theatre People or The Angel Next Door
Sonnentag Theatre at the IceHouse (5/15 - 6/7)
The Cottage in Orlando The Cottage
Sonnentag Theatre at the IceHouse (1/16 - 2/8)
VIEW SHOWS  ADD A SHOW