The Dinner Show Everyone’s Dying To Attend… At Carmine’s in Times Square! Speakeasy, Die Softly is the newest and most elaborate comedic immersive murder mystery ever performed by The Murder Mystery Company. During this killer show, guests will enjoy a three-course, family-style Italian feast in the newly renovated Sinatra Room at the legendary Carmine’s in Times Square. The year is 1927, a time of flappers, mobsters, bootlegging, and countless seedy speakeasies. Come on into Lou Zar’s and shimmy to the live music of the club’s famous songstress, Lucy Morals, and her accompanist, Keys Yacar, or, if you prefer, play some casino games and win big money you can blow on “soda pop.” Unfortunately, the fun can’t last all night– the feds have been sniffing around, so we need your help to flip the speakeasy into a “legitimate Italian restaurant” before the police raid the place. However, even amidst all these games, dames, and dons, someone had murder on their mind! You and your table team must help the detective solve the crime before the culprit escapes! But, beware… the killer could be anyone… even YOU! The Murder Mystery Company created by Scott Cramton is an experiential entertainment company exploding with popularity after being recently featured on ABC’s “Shark Tank.” Come see what all the hype is about at the legendary Carmine’s in Times Square! Menu Caesar Salad Penne a la vodka Chicken Parmigiana Shrimp Scampi Tiramisu and Cannoli Show Schedule Friday Doors @ 7 pm Saturday Afternoon Doors @ 4 pm Saturday Night Doors @ 8 pm Monday Doors @ 7 pm Additional links and information: Murder Mystery Party Experts | The Murder Mystery Co. The Murder Mystery Company (@themurdermysterycompany) • Instagram photos and videos themurdermysteryco (@themurdermysterycompany) | TikTok Murder Mystery Co. (@MurderMysteryCo) / X
Sunday Doors @ 5 pm
The Murder Mystery Co. is at 200 W 44th St, New York City, NY.
Videos
![]() |
Mars
The Chain Theatre (1/27 - 2/1)
DISCOUNT
| |
![]() |
Brody Went Missing
Caveat (2/1 - 2/1) COMEDY | |
![]() |
Steve Budd: Oy, What They Said About Love
Don't Tell Mama (1/17 - 1/17)
PHOTOS
VIDEOS
| |
![]() |
Always Young The Musical
Theater For The New City (1/15 - 2/1) NEW MUSICAL
DISCOUNT
| |
![]() |
Empower State of Mind
City Winery NYC (2/2 - 2/2)
PHOTOS
| |
![]() |
Two Birds And A Bag Of Bones
The LATEA Theater (1/21 - 1/25) OFF-OFF-BROADWAY PREMIERE
PHOTOS
| |
![]() |
Lobby Hero
Manes Studio Theatre of Long Island (1/9 - 1/25)
PHOTOS
| |
![]() |
Broadway Magic Hour
Broadway Comedy Club (1/1 - 6/30)
VIDEOS
| |
|
How to Make a Doll
Brooklyn Art Haus (1/25 - 1/25) | |
|
Just in Time at Circle In The Square Theatre
Circle In The Square Theatre (2/22 - 2/22) | |
|
Selected Shorts: Spring Training with Brian Lehrer
Symphony Space (4/29 - 4/29) | |
|
Most of My Moms Are Gay
Caveat (3/3 - 4/3) | |
|
Oscar Wilde’s The Importance of Being Gay
Producers’ Club Theaters (2/6 - 2/21) | |
| VIEW SHOWS ADD A SHOW | ||