Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: THE GREAT GATSBY at Orpheum Theatre Minneapolis

This production runs now through June 7, 2026

By:
Review: THE GREAT GATSBY at Orpheum Theatre Minneapolis

I attended opening night of The Great Gatsby at the Orpheum Theatre on June 2, and it was a fun and visually impressive evening of theater.

The first thing that stood out to me was the costumes. They were absolutely beautiful and really helped bring the glamour of the 1920s to life. Every time the curtain opened on one of Gatsby's parties, there was something new to look at. The set, lighting, and costumes worked together to create the lavish world that fans of the novel expect.

The music was another highlight. My favorite song of the night was "New Money." It was energetic, entertaining, and one of the numbers that really got the audience engaged. Several songs showcased the cast's strong vocals, but "New Money" was the one that stuck with me after the show.

Review: THE GREAT GATSBY at Orpheum Theatre Minneapolis Image

The cast was excellent from beginning to end. Jake David Smith brought both confidence and vulnerability to Jay Gatsby, making him more than just a mysterious millionaire. Senzel Ahmady gave a strong performance as Daisy Buchanan, and the chemistry between the two leads helped make their complicated relationship believable.

I also really enjoyed Joshua Grosso as Nick Carraway, whose narration helped guide the audience through the story. Lila Coogan stood out as Myrtle Wilson, bringing a lot of energy to the role. Will Branner made Tom Buchanan easy to dislike, which is exactly what the role calls for, and Tally Sessions brought real emotion to George Wilson.

Review: THE GREAT GATSBY at Orpheum Theatre Minneapolis Image

One thing I appreciated was that the show didn't rely only on spectacle. While the parties, costumes, and big musical numbers were exciting, the production also took time to explore the characters and the choices they make. By the end, the story's themes of love, ambition, and chasing an impossible dream still came through clearly.

Overall, I thought this was a strong production with a talented cast, memorable music, and stunning visuals. Whether you're a fan of the novel or just enjoy large-scale Broadway musicals, The Great Gatsby is worth seeing during its Minneapolis run.

For more ticket and show information, please click the ticket link button below.

All photos are credit to Evan Zimmerman for Murphy Made

Click Here to Get Tickets
More on Orpheum Theatre Minneapolis
Upcoming Shows
Clue
10/9 - 10/11/2026
The Sound of Music
10/20 - 10/25/2026
Recent Articles
Review: MAMMA MIA! at Orpheum Theatre Minneapolis
Review: MAMMA MIA! at Orpheum Theatre Minneapolis
9/16/2026
Review: SENSORY-FRIENDLY PERFORMANCE OF WICKED at Orpheum Theatre Minneapolis
Review: SENSORY-FRIENDLY PERFORMANCE OF WICKED at Orpheum Theatre Minneapolis
7/27/2026

Reader Reviews



BroadwayWorld TV


Hollywood; Lights, Camera Dance in Minneapolis / St. Paul Hollywood; Lights, Camera Dance
Collide Theatrical Dance Company (10/15-10/25)
When Autumn Falls: An Evening of Song with Nichole Carey in Minneapolis / St. Paul When Autumn Falls: An Evening of Song with Nichole Carey
Crooners Supper Club (10/05-10/05)
Buena Vista Social Club™ in Minneapolis / St. Paul Buena Vista Social Club™
Orpheum Theatre (12/29-1/03)
Songbook Series: Up, Up & Away in Minneapolis / St. Paul Songbook Series: Up, Up & Away
Hanifl Performing Arts Center (Lakeshore Players Theatre) (10/18-10/18)
The Four Seasons in Minneapolis / St. Paul The Four Seasons
Ballet Co. Laboratory Studio Theatre (6/12-6/13)
Dolly Parton's Smoky Mountain Christmas Carol in Minneapolis / St. Paul Dolly Parton's Smoky Mountain Christmas Carol
State Theatre (11/24-11/24)
THE LEGEND OF KORRA in Concert in Minneapolis / St. Paul THE LEGEND OF KORRA in Concert
Orhpeum Theatre (2/16-2/16)
The Playwright Festival in Minneapolis / St. Paul The Playwright Festival
Yellow Tree Theatre (5/22-6/06)
Limón Dance Company in Minneapolis / St. Paul Limón Dance Company
Northrop (1/30-1/30)
Haunted Lament in Minneapolis / St. Paul Haunted Lament
Bumbling Fools Meadry (10/17-10/17)