My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Neil Haven's Puppet Murder Mystery WHO KILLED SANTA? Plays Arcade Theatre, 1/2-12

By:

A Milwaukee favorite in 2008, 2009, 2011, and 2012, Who Killed Santa? by local playwright Neil Haven will be produced again in January of 2014.

Who Killed Santa? will run January 2-12, 2014 at The Arcade Theatre in the Underground Collaborative (Grand Avenue Mall, Lower Level, 161 W. Wisconsin Avenue, Milwaukee, Wisconsin 53203.) The show features actors Bo Johnson, Rick Pendzich, Amy Geyser, Liz Shipe, Nate Press, and Brittany McDonald. Puppets created by Dan Katula, costumes by Amanda Schlicher, written and directed by Neil Haven. Tickets are $20 and can be reserved online at whokilledsanta.com. The website also features a video preview and performance calendar. Who Killed Santa? contains adult language and content and is suitable for audiences sixteen and older.

Synopsis: Who Killed Santa? The Choose-Your-Own-Ending Musical Murder Mystery Holiday Whodunit. In this hilarious and irreverent send-up, Santa is hosting his annual holiday party attended by the usual holiday favorites: Frosty, Tiny Tim, The Little Drummer Boy, and Rudolph, who all have a bone to pick with Santa. After the introduction of the sexy new Little Drummer Girl, tempers flare, and Santa ends up with a candy cane through the heart. No one will confess, no one can leave, and Christmas is in jeopardy. As the tension builds, a couple of incompetent detectives enter the scene, and all the dirty secrets of these iconic holiday characters are revealed. Eventually, with the help of the audience, the murderer is convicted and sentenced. Who Killed Santa? is an alternative adult show featuring parodies of holiday songs, large rod puppets, and four different endings determined by which suspect the audience accuses.

About the Playwright: Neil Haven is a published and regularly produced playwright. He is the author of Pink Champagne, Stuck, Get a Life, and The Playdaters, and has been commissioned for several outreach/educational plays. His work has been seen at In Tandem Theatre, Uprooted Theatre, Pink Banana, The Brumder Mansion, UW-Whitewater, and other theatres around the country. He holds an MFA in playwriting from the University of Las Vegas, Nevada.

For additional information, please see whokilledsanta.com.

Click here for a preview.

Theater Fans' Choice Awards
2026 Theater Fans' Choice Awards - Live Stats
Best Featured Performer in a Play - Top 3
1. Laurie Metcalf - Death of a Salesman
10.1% of votes
2. Danny Burstein - Marjorie Prime
7.7% of votes
3. Alden Ehrenreich - Becky Shaw
7.2% of votes

Don't Miss a Milwaukee, WI News Story
Sign up for all the news on the Spring season, discounts & more...

Local Shows
Into the Woods in Milwaukee, WI Into the Woods
Bombshell Studio Theatre (4/30-5/17)Tracker
Into The Woods in Milwaukee, WI Into The Woods
Lakeland Players Ltd (5/01-5/17)Tracker
Shrek the Musical in Milwaukee, WI Shrek the Musical
Rhode Center for the Arts (5/01-5/17)
Agatha Christie's And Then There Were None in Milwaukee, WI Agatha Christie's And Then There Were None
Milwaukee Repertory Theater (5/26-6/28)
All Shook Up, Jr. in Milwaukee, WI All Shook Up, Jr.
Sunset Playhouse (5/11-5/12)
Pippin in Milwaukee, WI Pippin
Racine Theatre Guild (5/15-5/31)
Weird Al Yankovic at Fiserv Forum in Milwaukee, WI Weird Al Yankovic at Fiserv Forum
Fiserv Forum (10/17-10/17)
Mrs. Christie in Milwaukee, WI Mrs. Christie
Milwaukee Repertory Theater (4/14-5/10)
Monty Python''s Spamalot in Milwaukee, WI Monty Python''s Spamalot
Uihlein Hall Marcus Center (7/14-7/19)
Frida…A Self Portrait in Milwaukee, WI Frida…A Self Portrait
Milwaukee Repertory Theater (4/03-5/17)
VIEW ALL SHOWS  ADD A SHOW  


Videos