My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Bizarre But True UNDYING LOVE To Debut In Key West On Valentine's Day

By:

Bizarre But True UNDYING LOVE To Debut In Key West On Valentine's Day Image

In 1930s Key West, a man who called himself "Count von Cosel" fell in love with a terminally ill girl named Elena Hoyos. Her death was the start of a bizarre but true love story that unfolds for theater fans in "Undying Love: A Key West Musical," debuting on Valentine's Day at The Studios of Key West, 533 Eaton St.

Both macabre and darkly humorous, the stranger-than-fiction musical saga was written by Key West author and musician Ben Harrison. Harrison previously penned a nonfiction book, also called "Undying Love," that chronicled von Cosel's beyond-the-grave obsession with Elena.

When the shocking result of that obsession was discovered in Depression-era Key West, it sparked national news reports. The show features projections and historical photos that evoke the island city's isolation and the atmosphere surrounding the discovery and its aftermath.

The full-scale theatrical production stars a cast of 10 actors led by Amber Good as Elena and Jamie Callahan as the demented von Cosel.

The show includes more than a dozen original songs ranging from a risqué recap of the count's actions to the eerie "La Boda Negra (Black Wedding)," which the delusional lover claimed Elena sang to him from her crypt. Penned by Harrison, the tunes are brought to life by a five-member orchestra.

Following its Feb. 14 debut, "Undying Love" runs for a limited engagement of nine more performances, all beginning at 8 p.m., through March 3. Ticket prices for the haunting, not-to-be-missed production range from $30 to $55 per person.

Event information and ticketing: tskw.org or 305-296-0458

Key West visitor information: fla-keys.com/keywest or 1-800-LAST-KEY

Social: FacebookTwitterInstagramYoutubeKeys Voices blog

Theater Fans' Choice Awards
2026 Theater Fans' Choice Awards - Live Stats
Best Featured Performer in a Musical - Top 3
1. Ali Louis Bourzgui - The Lost Boys, A New Musical
18.9% of votes
2. Bryce Pinkham - Chess
9.6% of votes
3. Ben Levi Ross - Ragtime
6.3% of votes

Don't Miss a Miami Metro News Story
Sign up for all the news on the Spring season, discounts & more...


Videos


Alice By Heart in Miami Metro Alice By Heart
Inside Out Theatre (5/30-5/31)
Slow Burn Theatre Co: Dear Evan Hansen - Smart Stage Matinee Series in Miami Metro Slow Burn Theatre Co: Dear Evan Hansen - Smart Stage Matinee Series
Amaturo Theater at Broward Center (4/15-4/15)
The Best of Broadway in Miami Metro The Best of Broadway
Century Village - Deerfield Beach (5/31-5/31)
South Florida Symphony Orchestra’s Summer Chamber Music Series – Farrenc & Pejačević in Miami Metro South Florida Symphony Orchestra’s Summer Chamber Music Series – Farrenc & Pejačević
The Center of Spiritual Living (6/26-6/26)
Dial M for Murder in Miami Metro Dial M for Murder
Actors’ Playhouse at the Miracle Theatre (5/13-6/07)
ALICIA KEYS’ HELL’S KITCHEN in Miami Metro ALICIA KEYS’ HELL’S KITCHEN
Kravis Center for the Performing Arts (4/20-4/25)
The Wizard of Oz in Miami Metro The Wizard of Oz
Actors’ Playhouse at the Miracle Theatre (7/02-7/25)
Beetlejuice - Recommended for 13+. Parental discretion advised. in Miami Metro Beetlejuice - Recommended for 13+. Parental discretion advised.
Kravis Center - Dreyfoos Hall (6/02-6/06)
Shrek Jr.: A Summer Theater Camp Production in Miami Metro Shrek Jr.: A Summer Theater Camp Production
Amaturo Theater at Broward Center (7/02-7/11)
Lca Conservatory Presents: Disney''s The Little Mermaid, Jr. in Miami Metro Lca Conservatory Presents: Disney''s The Little Mermaid, Jr.
Aventura Arts & Cultural Center (6/07-6/07)