Broadway Beyond Louisville Review: Broadway in Cincinnati presents BEETLEJUICE THE MUSICAL at The Aronoff Center

In the past few years in film, television, and onstage, it’s been proven that nostalgia sells…and it sells well. So it only seems natural (or should I say supernatural) that a spooky season favorite film “Beetlejuice” would make its way to the stage in a big flashy Broadway musical. After premiering in Washington, DC in the autumn of 2018, the show premiered on Broadway in the spring of 2019 with decent fanfare and a healthy slew of Tony Nominations. The show would play up until the pandemic shutdowns, but would come back Broadway in 2022. One thing attributed to its success is the show found an audience through TikTok, especially with younger theatre goers. The show is currently on tour and is set to sell out its Cincinnati engagement, thanks in big part to that passion from younger fans.

Much like the movie, the show focuses on a wacky array of characters who all come together in a creepy old house via different circumstances, but the musical makes some new choices that deviate as well. Adam and Barbara Maitland die of an electrical accident and watch a new family move in and take over their home. Beetlejuice, “a creepy demon" (who is the show’s narrator) agrees to help the Maitlands get the family out with an underlying motivation to be visible again, a feat secured by a living person saying his name three times. The family in question is made of Charles and Lydia Deetz who have just suffered the loss of the family’s matriarch, along with Delia, Lydia’s overbearing and ditzy life coach. Put all of this together and as you can imagine, hilarity ensues.

On opening night, the titular role was played by understudy Matthew Michael Janisse who did a phenomenal job. He expertly helmed the show and brought so much energy to the action, he was a joy to watch. Isabella Esler is a vocal powerhouse as Lydia, but she also has many wonderful and heartfelt acting moments as well, especially in her 11 o’clock number “Home”. Adam and Barbara Maitland were played by Ryan Breslin (an understudy for the role) and Megan McGinnis respectively. Both Breslin and McGinnis compliment each other well, and bring so much joy and life to the show in their characters. McGinnis exudes warmth and humor, while Breslin’s Adam shines in a lot of the more comedic moments, especially opposite Janisse’s Beetlejuice. Another standout is Sarah Litzsinger as Delia. Perhaps my favorite performance and character in the show, she brings the crazy and kooky Delia to life, and gives a masterclass in physical comedy and scenery chewing in the best possible way, every moment she was onstage was a delight.

The direction and scenic design by Alex Timbers and David Korins respectively, is grand and appropriately spooky, drawing a lot of direct inspiration from the style Tim Burton is known for. The score by Eddie Perfect is full of fun earworms, and hilarious lyrics. His clever rhymes come quickly. Pay attention, because you don’t wanna miss one hysterical word!

Beetlejuice as a musical isn’t high art, but it’s not trying to be. It’s trying to be FUN and it wholeheartedly succeeds. I walked out of the show on a comedic high filled with the warm fuzzies that only the best musical comedy can provide. This stellar cast sells this hilarious material in a way that had the audience in the palm of the show’s hand. The show is slightly raunchy and crude (it doesn’t shy away from some four letter words), but for older kids, adults, and anyone who likes to laugh, Beetlejuice is a phenomenal night at the theatre.

BEETLEJUICE THE MUSICAL

Now - January 28th

Aronoff Center For The Arts

650 Walnut Street Cincinnati, OH 45202.

Photo Credit: Matthew Murphy

To post a comment, you must register and login.

Test and expand your Broadway knowledge with our new game - The Broadway Match-Up! How well do you know your Broadway casting trivia?	Play the Daily Game, explore current shows, and delve into past decades like the 2000s, 80s, and the Golden Age. Challenge your friends and see where you rank!
How well do you know your Tony Awards history? Take our never-ending quiz of nominations and winner history and challenge your friends.	Can you beat your friends? Play today’s daily Broadway word game, featuring a new theatrically inspired word or phrase every day!