Haunted Encounters - Magic Show at Theatre Three
Dates: 12/31/2025
Theatre Three
412 Main Street
Port Jefferson, NY 11777
Phone: 6319289100
Tickets: Various
Is This Your Show?
Submit Updates & Sell More Tickets
Get ready to laugh in the New Year!
Featuring top comedians from Long Island, NYC, around the country, and beyond! Enjoy an evening of outrageous laughter and hilarious fun! LAUGHTER is GOOD for you! Join Us!
6pm Early Bird Show:
On the Mainstage
Jordan Lauterbach: Long Island Comedy Scene; HA HA HAmptons Comedy Tour; headliner
Ellen Karis: The Greek goddess of Comedy; NYC Comedy Scene; Sirius XM; headliner
Scott Baker: AC; Vegas; Catskills; Quickest Thinkers in Comedy
Vinnie Mark: Mohegan Sun; Late Night; Quickest Thinkers in Comedy; National headliner
Hosted by Paul Anthony: 50+ Comedy Tours; Long Island Comedy Festival; Berkshire Comedy Festival
Join us for our New Year’s LAUGHIN’ Eve Early Bird Show, featuring a hilarious lineup of top comedians! This performance will also feature the outrageous comedy duo of the Quickest Thinkers in Comedy, bringing their outrageous comedy antics to THEATRE THREE’s stage. With the Quickest Thinkers in Comedy, the audience becomes part of the show!
8pm Prime Time Show:
On the Mainstage
Jordan Lauterbach: Long Island Comedy Scene; HA HA HAmptons Comedy Tour; headliner
Ellen Karis: The Greek goddess of Comedy; NYC Comedy Scene; Sirius XM; headliner
Vinnie Mark: Mohegan Sun; Late Night; Quickest Thinkers in Comedy; National headliner
Hosted by Paul Anthony: 50+ Comedy Tours; Long Island Comedy Festival; Berkshire Comedy Festival
Join us for our New Year’s LAUGHIN’ Eve Prime Time Show, featuring a hilarious lineup of top comedians! This performance will feature national headliner Vinnie Mark! Vinnie Mark will be headlining our Prime Time Show with his incredible comedy & magic show!
NEW!
10pm Late Night Show:
On Second Stage, Seating LIMITED!!
Jordan Lauterbach: Long Island Comedy Scene; HA HA HAmptons Comedy Tour; headliner
Ellen Karis: The Greek goddess of Comedy; NYC Comedy Scene; Sirius XM; headliner
Scott Baker: AC; Vegas; Catskills; Quickest Thinkers in Comedy
Vinnie Mark: Mohegan Sun; Late Night; Quickest Thinkers in Comedy; National headliner
Hosted by Paul Anthony: 50+ Comedy Tours; Long Island Comedy Festival; Berkshire Comedy Festival
Join us for our NEW New Year’s LAUGHIN’ Eve Late Night Show, featuring a hilarious lineup of top comedians! We’ve added a hilarious 3rd performance to our New Year’s Eve offerings to help kick off the 20th Anniversary of the Long Island Comedy Festival in 2026! This special performance will feature National headliner Vinnie Mark performing his outrageous comedy and magic! To make things even more fun, Vinnie will be joined on stage by comedian Scott Baker of the Quickest Thinkers in Comedy, bringing their outrageous comedy duo antics to THEATRE THREE’s second stage to close out this year in comedic style! Don’t miss it!
Ticket Information
6:00pm Performance: $70
(Pre-sale Price: $60)
8:00pm Performance: $80
(Pre-sale Price: $70)
10:00pm Performance: $100
(Pre-sale Price: $90)
News About Haunted Encounters - Magic Show at Theatre Three
We have no news on this show at the current time.
About the Theatre
🌙 Make a Night of It
Restaurant and parking information is not available for this location.
Theatre Three illuminates the human experience with exemplary, intimate theatre by nurturing authors, artists and audiences. As a recognized pillar of the North Texas arts community, T3 enriches lives by bringing engaging, provocative, and professionally produced theatrical experiences. Outside of performances, we nurture artistic skills by fostering local playwrights, training adult actors, and engaging young artists with internship opportunities and summer youth programming.
Theatre Three Frequently Asked QuestionsFAQ
Parlor of Mystery (2/26/26-2/26/26)
Theatre Three is at 412 Main Street, Port Jefferson, NY.
Amber Ferrari (2/14/26-2/14/26)
Barnaby Saves Christmas (11/22/25-12/27/25)
Haunted Encounters - Magic Show (10/31/25-10/31/25)
James & The Giant Peach (9/27/25-10/18/25)
Theatre Three illuminates the human experience with exemplary, intimate theatre by nurturing authors, artists and audiences. As a recognized pillar of the North Texas arts community, T3 enriches lives by bringing engaging, provocative, and professionally produced theatrical experiences. Outside of performances, we nurture artistic skills by fostering local playwrights, training adult actors, and engaging young artists with internship opportunities and summer youth programming.
More Long Island Coverage
Videos