Review: THE SHARK IS BROKEN at The Toledo Repertoire Theatre

Summertime is approaching, and it may not be safe to go back in the water. No, not because of algae blooms or the occasional Lake Erie shark rumor (seriously, look it up), but because “Bruce,” the infamous mechanical shark from Jaws, has resurfaced at The Toledo Repertoire Theatre.

Although Bruce himself never quite makes an appearance, his legacy looms large from the moment that iconic theme begins. In THE SHARK IS BROKEN, we find him once again malfunctioning, leaving stars Robert Shaw, Richard Dreyfuss, and Roy Scheider stranded between takes. What follows is an entertaining and surprisingly introspective look at what might have transpired behind the scenes during the filming of the 1975 blockbuster.

Running April 24 through May 3, this production offers a thoroughly engaging evening of theater. Based on journals kept by Robert Shaw and adapted by his son Ian Shaw alongside Joseph Nixon, the play imagines the downtime between shoots as a crucible for ego clashes, existential musings, and unexpected vulnerability. Even if you haven’t revisited Jaws recently, the story remains easy to follow. For fans, however, the script is packed with rewarding references—plenty of “chum” to savor.
Director Gary Insch maintains a strong pace throughout the 90-minute runtime. Despite the premise centering on waiting around, the production never drags. His guidance of the cast is particularly effective, resulting in performances that feel both natural and finely tuned. Sarah Styers’ set is visually impressive, with a large boat that doubles as an inventive playground for the actors. While the scale is ambitious, a slightly more compact design might have improved some sightline challenges.
The cast rises impressively to the challenge of portraying such iconic figures. Each actor strikes a balance between homage and originality, crafting performances that feel grounded and human.
Ryan Albrecht’s Richard Dreyfuss is energetic and expressive, capturing the actor’s youthful enthusiasm while also revealing quieter, introspective layers. Brian Dario brings a steady, composed presence as Roy Scheider, serving as the grounded center of the trio with a polished and engaging performance.

Jake Spencer, however, delivers a standout turn as Robert Shaw. His performance is magnetic. His every movement and line deliberate, every moment charged with intensity. His rendition of the USS Indianapolis speech is nothing short of extraordinary, creating one of those rare, electrifying moments in theater that lingers long after the curtain call. Spencer skillfully conveys both the bravado and the underlying vulnerability of a man grappling with identity, legacy, and connection.
While Bruce may be absent, The Shark Is Broken more than compensates with sharp writing, strong direction, and three compelling performances. It’s a witty, thoughtful, and thoroughly entertaining production.
Climb aboard, grab a ticket, and spend an evening at the Rep. You’ll be glad you did.

Reader Reviews

To post a comment, you must register and login.

Need more Cleveland Theatre News in your life?
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...