Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: A BEAUTIFUL NOISE at Hershey Theatre

This Diamond tribute is a real jewel

By:
Review: A BEAUTIFUL NOISE at Hershey Theatre

Based on the life and times of singer-songwriter, Neil Diamond, A Beautiful Noise is a good bit more than the typical jukebox musical.  The framing device of the story is that current day Neil Diamond, played expertly by Robert Westenberg, is reluctantly visiting a therapist (Lisa Renee Pitts) to work through some issues.  Westenberg’s Diamond is gruff, surly and weary. He seems miles away from the smiling, glittery star of yesteryear.

The  sessions serve as the narration to connect the dots of the major events of his life and to bring understanding and meaning to his current state of mind. Soon we are introduced to the younger Neil played by Nick Fradiani.  Fradiani, impressively, goes all in in regards to replicating the looks and sound of the singer.  This was a welcomed change compared to the recent Tina Turner musical at Hershey, where the lead actress sounded a lot less like Turner, and a lot more like Beyonce.

Along the way we get all of Diamond’s greatest hits such as, Kentucky Woman, You Don’t Bring Me Flowers, Hello Again, and, of course, Sweet Caroline.  While some tunes were sung as part of a performance, others were used to further the narrative of the story, sometimes sung by other characters.  This includes the showstopping Forever in Blue Jeans performed by the voluptuous, Amber Ardolino as Diamond’s ex-wife.

Speaking of ex-wives, this show does not shy away from the protagonist’s mistakes throughout his life.  His life choices, good and bad are put on display with bravery and sincerity.  The inclusion of personal and professional flaws is what separates this show from many others that tend to whitewash the biographical events of similar musicians.

Sets are sparse, which is appropriate for this show, since events occur in Diamond’s mind , rather than in reality.  The diverse ensemble nicknamed “The Noise” , are a fun, yet surreal contribution to the story.  They pop in and out of scenes with surprising frequency, never overstaying their welcome.

While you don’t need to be a Neil Diamond super-fan, it doesn’t hurt to have a basic familiarity with his catalog.  The opening night audience seemed to be heavily populated by seniors. However, the story, the songs, and the production can be easily enjoyed by a wide range of ages.  This beautiful show plays at Hershey through July 5th.

Click Here to Get Tickets
More on Hershey Theatre
Upcoming Shows
Cinderella
10/18 - 10/18/2026
Clue
10/30 - 11/1/2026
Recent Articles
WILD KRATTS LIVE Stage Show to Return to Hershey Theatre in 2027
WILD KRATTS LIVE Stage Show to Return to Hershey Theatre in 2027
9/21/2026
Hershey Symphony to Perform Free Children's Concert
Hershey Symphony to Perform Free Children's Concert
8/7/2026

Reader Reviews


Local Shows
Star Wars: A New Hope In Concert in Central Pennsylvania Star Wars: A New Hope In Concert
Appell Center (4/03-4/03)
She Kill Monsters in Central Pennsylvania She Kill Monsters
Lebanon Community Theatre (10/15-10/25)
“Clue”  Live on Stage in Central Pennsylvania “Clue” Live on Stage
Eisenhower Auditorium (10/29-10/29)
Murder at Ackerton Manor in Central Pennsylvania Murder at Ackerton Manor
Fulton Theatre (10/16-11/08)
SIX (Boleyn Tour) in Central Pennsylvania SIX (Boleyn Tour)
Hershey Theatre (6/18-6/20)
Beethoven's Triple Concerto in Central Pennsylvania Beethoven's Triple Concerto
Appell Center (4/24-4/24)
The Dinner Detective Murder Mystery Dinner Show in Central Pennsylvania The Dinner Detective Murder Mystery Dinner Show
The Dinner Detective Allentown (10/17-10/17)
Ebenezer Scrooge's Big Lancaster Christmas in Central Pennsylvania Ebenezer Scrooge's Big Lancaster Christmas
Fulton Theatre (12/04-12/27)
THE BIRDS in Central Pennsylvania THE BIRDS
Little Theatre of Mechanicsburg (10/02-10/18)
Jesus Christ Superstar in Central Pennsylvania Jesus Christ Superstar
Openstage (3/19-3/21)

BroadwayWorld TV