My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Theatre444

160 Carter Road
Geneva, NY

Upcoming Shows

Dogfight

Dogfight

Aug 21 – Aug 29, 2026

Set on the eve of the Vietnam War, Dogfight is a hauntingly beautiful story of unexpected loveand the power of compassion. On November 21, 1963,...


Auditions


Review: The Addams Family at The Mac-Haydn Theatre Conjures a Ghoulishly Good Time


by Steven Favreau - June 15, 2026

With the recent Rocky Horror revival reminding everyone how much fun the macabre can be, how lucky is Columbia County to have its own creepy, kooky, mysterious and spooky night out right there at the Mac-Haydn? The production runs through 6/21....

Review: WATER FOR ELEPHANTS at Proctors


by Peyton VanDerheyden - April 09, 2026

WATER FOR ELEPHANTS is dazzling audiences with extraordinary theatrics, creative visual concepts, and emotional moments. Adapted from the New York Times bestselling novel, WATER FOR ELEPHANTS has a book written by Rick Elice, and features a score by PigPen Theatre Co. ...

Review: KINKY BOOTS at Proctors


by Peyton VanDerheyden - March 16, 2026

KINKY BOOTS brought the fun to Proctors. This touring production is filled with many high points that captivate the audience. The story follows Charlie Price, who inherits his father’s shoe factory, which is on the brink of financial ruin. ...

Past Shows

Amelie

FeaturedAmelie

Jun 5 – Jun 13, 2026

Amélie is a whimsical and magical journey through the streets of Montmartre, Paris

Big Fish

FeaturedBig Fish

Aug 22 – Aug 30, 2025

Theatre444 is proud to present the beloved Broadway Musical, Big Fish with music and lyrics by Andrew Lippa; book by John August. Based on the...

In Pieces

FeaturedIn Pieces

May 29 – Jun 1, 2025

Theatre444 announces the Regional Premiere of a new contemporary musical; In Pieces, written and composed by Fred Ebb Award Finalist and Jonathan Larson Grant Finalist,...

The Story of My Life

FeaturedThe Story of My Life

Feb 20 – Feb 23, 2025

The Story Of My Life follows the friendship of Alvin and Thomas, two men from a small town. These lifelong friends are reunited after Alvin's

The Absolute Brightness of Leonard Pelkey

Sep 10 – Sep 21, 2024

The Absolute Brightness of Leonard Pelkey is a poignant one-man show that explores the life and disappearance of a teenage boy through the eyes of...

Sweeney Todd

Sweeney Todd

Aug 23 – Sep 1, 2024

Theatre444 is proud to bring you a new vision of cultural favorite, Sweeney Todd which has become a bloody, worldwide success since being awarded eight...

How I Learned to Drive

How I Learned to Drive

May 16 – May 19, 2024

Theatre444 is proud to announce performance dates  for the rarely produced play, How I Learned to Drive.  Compassionate, heartbreaking, and sometimes even funny, Paula Vogel's...

Alice by Heart

Alice by Heart

Sep 12 – Sep 23, 2023

Theatre444 is excited to perform five performances of a New Musical at the 2023 Rochester Fringe Festival.  All performances will take place at the JCC...

Tick, Tick...BOOM!

Tick, Tick...BOOM!

Jan 26 – Jan 29, 2023

Before RENT, there was Tick, Tick... Boom!  After a sold out run of RENT this past summer, Theatre444 is proud to bring you a new...

RENT

RENT

Aug 11 – Aug 14, 2022

RENT, with book and music by Johnathan Larsen,has become a pop cultural phenomenon with songs that rock and a story that resonates with audiences of...

All Together Now

All Together Now

Nov 12 – Nov 14, 2021

Theatre444, is proud to bring you the Finger Lakes Premiere of All Together Now! Both Live stream and in person!! Join us as we make...

The Tempest

The Tempest

Mar 26 – Mar 28, 2021

The Tempest; A Brave New Theatre ExperienceTheatre444, is proud to bring you actors from all over the country to create our local version of William...

The Vagina Monologues

The Vagina Monologues

Feb 27 – Feb 29, 2020

Join us as we present a benefit production of The Vagina Monologues with proceeds to go to Safe Harbors of the Finger Lakes. Help us...

The Last Five Years

The Last Five Years

Jan 23 – Jan 26, 2020

Theatre444 is excited and proud to be producing Jason Robert Brown's Drama Desk winner, The Last Five Years.An emotionally powerful and intimate musical about two...

Videos


BOOP! The Musical in Central New York BOOP! The Musical
Proctors Theatre (10/13-10/18)
Mystic Pizza in Central New York Mystic Pizza
Capital Repertory Theatre (7/10-8/09)
Wicked in Central New York Wicked
Proctor's Theatre (11/05-11/05)
Simple Little Things: A Spring Cabaret With Olivia Hernandez in Central New York Simple Little Things: A Spring Cabaret With Olivia Hernandez
Geva Theatre (6/25-6/27)
Just in Time in Central New York Just in Time
Proctors Theatre (6/01-6/06)
Clyde's in Central New York Clyde's
Capital Repertory Theatre (4/23-5/16)
Get Happy: Angela Ingersoll sings Judy Garland in Central New York Get Happy: Angela Ingersoll sings Judy Garland
Geva Theatre (7/23-8/02)
Hell's Kitchen in Central New York Hell's Kitchen
Proctors Theatre (12/29-1/03)
Aladdin at New Amsterdam Theatre in Central New York Aladdin at New Amsterdam Theatre
New Amsterdam Theatre (12/02-6/28)
Golden Girls The Laughs Continue in Central New York Golden Girls The Laughs Continue
Proctors (10/06-10/06)