Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: Hugh Panaro Does It Again in MAN WITHOUT A MASK at 54 Below

This engagement is, pretty much, the blueprint of what he and his Director, Richard Jay-Alexander created and the recording of MAN WITHOUT A MASK is just fantastic.

By:

Review: Hugh Panaro Does It Again in MAN WITHOUT A MASK at 54 Below Image

Hugh Panaro

Hot on the heels of MASQUERADE, the immersive PHANTOM OF THE OPERA experience on West 57th Street, Hugh Panaro is doing a return engagement at 54 Below.

There is no question that Mr. Panaro is a world-class performer and it mystifies us that when I mention his name to people, I have to explain who he is and what his career accomplishments are. The industry is now littered with singers and actors and debuts by people “I” never heard of, including “influencers”, YouTube stars and "Tik-Tokers." Hugh Panaro is a sure thing, a solid stock investment of time and money and I wholeheartedly recommend you seek him out. This engagement is, pretty much, the blueprint of what he and his Director, Richard Jay-Alexander, created, and the recording of MAN WITHOUT A MASK is just fantastic. You can stream it and hear him for yourself, if you’re reading this and don’t have access to NYC’s 54 Below.

Hugh Panaro’s voice is astonishing and that is no exaggeration. Full, rangey, colorful, delicate, robust, dangerous, soaring and everything in between. He's funny, charming, handsome and has you in a spell song after song after song. There were countless electrifying musical moments throughout the show, and Hugh’s special guest Francesca Mehrotra, added a stunning touch with their (Masquerade) duet on The Music Of The Night.

Joseph Thalken at the piano with his full bodied theatrical arrangements and Brian Holrz on bass supporting Hugh makes this evening an iconic musical 54 Below engagement.

Adding even more buzz to the night was the presence in the audience of Hugh’s “Christine” in Phantom of The Opera on Broadway in the early 2000s, Raissa Katona Bennett and Bill Russell, lyricist/book writer of Side Show.


 For tickets to the rest of the run, continuing April 24, 25, 30 and May 1, visit 54 Below’s website. See photos from the opening night show on April 23 below.Review: Hugh Panaro Does It Again in MAN WITHOUT A MASK at 54 Below Image
Hugh Panaro

Review: Hugh Panaro Does It Again in MAN WITHOUT A MASK at 54 Below Image
Hugh Panro

Review: Hugh Panaro Does It Again in MAN WITHOUT A MASK at 54 Below Image
Hugh Panaro

Review: Hugh Panaro Does It Again in MAN WITHOUT A MASK at 54 Below Image
Hugh Panaro

Review: Hugh Panaro Does It Again in MAN WITHOUT A MASK at 54 Below Image
Hugh Panaro

Review: Hugh Panaro Does It Again in MAN WITHOUT A MASK at 54 Below Image
Francesca Mehrotra

Review: Hugh Panaro Does It Again in MAN WITHOUT A MASK at 54 Below Image
Francesca Mehrotra

Review: Hugh Panaro Does It Again in MAN WITHOUT A MASK at 54 Below Image
Hugh Panaro

Review: Hugh Panaro Does It Again in MAN WITHOUT A MASK at 54 Below Image
Hugh Panaro

Review: Hugh Panaro Does It Again in MAN WITHOUT A MASK at 54 Below Image
Hugh Panaro

Review: Hugh Panaro Does It Again in MAN WITHOUT A MASK at 54 Below Image
Hugh Panaro

Review: Hugh Panaro Does It Again in MAN WITHOUT A MASK at 54 Below Image
Hugh Panaro

Review: Hugh Panaro Does It Again in MAN WITHOUT A MASK at 54 Below Image
Hugh Panaro

Review: Hugh Panaro Does It Again in MAN WITHOUT A MASK at 54 Below Image
Joseph Thalken & Hugh Panaro

Review: Hugh Panaro Does It Again in MAN WITHOUT A MASK at 54 Below Image
Hugh Panaro & Raissa Katona Bennett

Review: Hugh Panaro Does It Again in MAN WITHOUT A MASK at 54 Below Image
Raissa Katona Bennett & Hugh Panaro

Review: Hugh Panaro Does It Again in MAN WITHOUT A MASK at 54 Below Image
Hugh Panaro & Eda Sorokoff

Review: Hugh Panaro Does It Again in MAN WITHOUT A MASK at 54 Below Image
Raissa Katona Bennett

Review: Hugh Panaro Does It Again in MAN WITHOUT A MASK at 54 Below Image
Bill Russell

Review: Hugh Panaro Does It Again in MAN WITHOUT A MASK at 54 Below Image
Raissa Katona Bennett, Joseph Thalken, Eda Sorokoff

Review: Hugh Panaro Does It Again in MAN WITHOUT A MASK at 54 Below Image
Hugh Panaro & Francesca Mehrotra

Review: Hugh Panaro Does It Again in MAN WITHOUT A MASK at 54 Below Image
Francesca Mehrotra

Review: Hugh Panaro Does It Again in MAN WITHOUT A MASK at 54 Below Image
54 Below

Review: Hugh Panaro Does It Again in MAN WITHOUT A MASK at 54 Below Image
54 Below

More on 54 Below
Upcoming Shows
Felipe Rose: Live in Cabaret Disco
Felipe Rose: Live in Cabaret Disco
9/23 - 9/23/2026
Brent Comer
Brent Comer
9/23 - 9/23/2026
Recent Articles
Review: Patrons Pack 54 Below For HALF AN EVENING WITH DAVID RASCHE
Review: Patrons Pack 54 Below For HALF AN EVENING WITH DAVID RASCHE
9/22/2026
Tara Jackson to Bring ALLOW ME TO INTRODUCE MYSELF to 54 Below
Tara Jackson to Bring ALLOW ME TO INTRODUCE MYSELF to 54 Below
9/22/2026

Reader Reviews


Cabaret Shows
Jensen Freeman: Neon Nights in Cabaret Jensen Freeman: Neon Nights
Laurie Beechman Theatre (9/26-9/26) PHOTOS
The Beat Goes On in Cabaret The Beat Goes On
Don't Tell Mama (10/08-10/08)
Timeless: A Tribute to Bernadette Peters in Cabaret Timeless: A Tribute to Bernadette Peters
Don't Tell Mama (10/04-10/04)
Pharaoh's Daughter in Cabaret Pharaoh's Daughter
Joe's Pub at The Public Theater (11/08-11/08)
Murray Hill: A Murray Little Christmas in Cabaret Murray Hill: A Murray Little Christmas
Joe's Pub at The Public Theater (12/19-12/19)
Lindsay Mendez and Ryan Scott Oliver’s Actor Therapy in Cabaret Lindsay Mendez and Ryan Scott Oliver’s Actor Therapy
54 Below (11/22-11/22)
James Tom is...Emotionally Repressed!, curated by Murray Hill in Cabaret James Tom is...Emotionally Repressed!, curated by Murray Hill
Joe's Pub at The Public Theater (11/05-11/05)
A Gay’s Dream: Broadway’s Leading Ladies with a Gender-Bent Twist in Cabaret A Gay’s Dream: Broadway’s Leading Ladies with a Gender-Bent Twist
54 Below (11/30-11/30)
Maria Corsaro: Love Makes the Changes in Cabaret Maria Corsaro: Love Makes the Changes
Pangea (10/23-10/23)
54 Celebrates Hanukkah: A Festival of Writers in Cabaret 54 Celebrates Hanukkah: A Festival of Writers
54 Below (12/06-12/06)

Cabaret venues in New York City


BroadwayWorld TV