Skip to main content Skip to footer site map



If a spouse transitions from one sex to another in a state where gay marriage is illegal, is the marriage still valid? There are many possible reactions to that question, including heated discussion, juvenile giggling, or reactionary distaste. Composer Laura Kaminsky chose empathy for those most directly affected. The result was her first opera, a striking statement at a time when empathy for anyone different is in short supply. As one, a chamber work for two singers and string quartet, does a compelling job of describing a transgender's struggle with sexual identity. It is the latest offering in the San Diego Opera's detour series, which features smaller-scale works outside the usual operatic repertoire.

Laura Kaminsky

Kaminsky's choice of artistic partners was as fortunate as her timing. Kimberly Reed, a transgender woman, and Mark Campbell, one of today's most successful librettists, collaborated to produce a story that feels real and has emotional impact.

Hannah grows up wanting to be the best boy there is--the fastest, smartest, and strongest--but can't hide from herself the guilty thrill of wearing a blouse under her jacket or letting a feminine side appear in flamboyant penmanship. When she accidently comes across the word "transgender," she begins to realize she is not the only person who is troubled by the difference between her physical and psychological characteristics. Thus begins the arduous process of accepting herself for who she is. An inspired decision places the singers, a baritone and a mezzo soprano, on stage at the same time to represent the warring aspects of a transgender's psychological makeup.

The intimacy of the San Diego production was aided by the relatively small size of the Joan B Kroc Theatre. Director Kyle Lang and scenic designer Jonathan Gilmer incorporated optional background films, shot by co-librettist Reed, and minimal sets featuring simple geometric shapes. The Hausmann string quartet, conducted by Bruce Stasyna, was on a riser toward the back of the stage. No props or extras were used. The opera's 80 minutes riveted attention with singers in near perpetual motion and an unbroken stream of music.

Review: SAN DIEGO OPERA'S PRODUCTION OF AS ONE at Joan B Kroc Theatre Baritone Kelly Markgraf has a romantically warm, auditorium-filling voice and an assured stage presence, no doubt in this case enhanced by his familiarity with the opera. He sang the role of "Hannah before" at its 2014 premiere, and has done it several times since. Mezzo-soprano Blythe Gaissert was part of the workshop team before the premiere, and has sung the role of "Hannah after" in multiple subsequent productions. Her voice, strong and rich, blended perfectly with Markgraf's, especially in the closing duet when they become "as one."

In a recent interview composer Kaminsky told me she had memorized and internalized the libretto before beginning to work on the score. She wanted to be sure an audience could readily understand the words, and the visceral energy behind them. Though not long, the roles are difficult and exhausting. The singers are seldom out of the spotlight, and vocal lines are rhythmically challenging. She told me she had been influenced by working with eastern European and African musicians, and tended to "push against" the more often regular meters of Western music, and the "tyranny of the downbeat."

The Hausmann quartet was also challenged. They played without a break for almostReview: SAN DIEGO OPERA'S PRODUCTION OF AS ONE at Joan B Kroc Theatre the entire 80 minutes, entwining beautifully with an equally near-continuous flow of vocal lines.

Kaminsky said she was never an opera buff and had not, at least consciously, been influenced by the famous grand operas. Her style is clearly contemporary with an individualistic mix of influences. As One has no arias to rival Puccini. She seems to believe the music has to reinforce rather than overwhelm the words for the opera to be the effective statement she envisioned.

As one hit a sweet spot for receptiveness, and its success is accelerating. Having been produced by nearly a dozen opera companies since its premiere three years ago, it has already been scheduled by about as many more in 2018 alone. It humanizes one of the world's least understood and most often mistreated minorities at a time when the substantial progress made by minority groups is under attack. It has low production costs in an era of budget retrenchment. And, like it or not, modern audiences raised on "in-depth" 40-second news clips, reality TV, and social media trivia are more likely to be attracted by single-act productions that take a deep-dive into the life of a contemporary real person than four-act operas with implausible plots about misbehaving royals.

There is much more ahead in the San Diego Opera's 2017-18 season. Visit here for details.


Laura Kaminsky provided her photograph, others compliments of San Diego Opera.

Related Stories

From This Author - Ron Bierman

Ron Bierman has performed on saxophone and flute in several college and other orchestras. He graduated from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology where his studies included music theory as taught... (read more about this author)

July 3, 2022

What did our critic think of SAN DIEGO SYMPHONY CONCERT at The Rady Shell?

BWW Review: SAN DIEGO SYMPHONY CONCERT at Rady Shell Amphitheater
May 25, 2022

Musical impressionism ruled the San Diego Symphony’s early-evening Rady Shell concert this past weekend. First came conductor-composer Esa-Pekka Salonen’s reaction to Nyx, a daughter of Chaos, the earliest Greek god. Nyx, rarely mentioned in extant ancient Greek-literature, is goddess of the night, mysterious but powerful. At one point in Homer’s Iliad, even Zeus changes his plans for fear of making her angry, and I get that. She was the mother of Death and Sleep.

BWW Review: San Diego Opera's Production of AGING MAGICIAN at The Balboa Theatre Shows Off Magical Mystery
May 20, 2022

'What the hell was that?' an opera fan asked her friend as we shuffled into a parking-garage elevator. Not an easily answered question after a viewing of AGING MAGICIAN. Ambiguity abounds and reality is mixed with fantasy. The reality side is clear, mostly. Harold is a middle-aged watch repairman who lives alone. Although repairs pay the rent, they've been neglected because he can't stop thinking about the plot of a book he's been writing in which an aging magician worries his marvelous tricks won't outlive him. As he seeks a capable heir for his book of secrets, he collapses and is rushed to a hospital.

BWW Interview: Rafael Payare Music Director and Conductor of THE SAN DIEGO AND MONTREAL SYMPHONY ORCHESTRAS
May 11, 2022

The San Diego Symphony’s Music Director and Conductor Rafael Payare took up the notoriously difficult French horn at the age of 13. During an hour-long Zoom interview while he was in Montreal, I asked how he had managed to become a soloist less than six months later! “I have to admit it was a little bit fast,” he said. Not the haughty egotistical answer I might have gotten from film conductor-stereotypes. His local youth orchestra, a part of Venezuela’s extensive El Sistema program, needed horns, so he joined a few weeks after first picking one up. “For a couple of classes, I could only play one scale, but somehow something clicked, and I just started playing more.” Less than half a year later he passed an audition for the national youth orchestra, and later became Principal Horn with the prestigious Simón Bolívar Youth Orchestra, the one that first brought Gustavo Dudamel to the attention of the conducting world.

BWW Interview: Laura Reynolds of THE SAN DIEGO SYMPHONY at The Rady Shell And Jacobs Music Center
May 1, 2022

Can a symphony orchestra have a role in solving problems like homelessness and global warming? If you don't think so now, you might change your mind after a conversation with Laura Reynolds, the San Diego Symphony's recently appointed Vice President of Impact and Innovation. In 2015, while she was the Seattle Symphony VP of Education and Community Engagement, both the city and the county decided the increasing number of homeless people had reached a state of emergency. CEO Simon Woods asked her, 'What's our role in this? What should we do?''