Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: DIE MEISTERSINGER VON NÜRNBERG at the Metropolitan Opera

For the first time in almost seven years, the Metropolitan Opera has revived Wagner's DIE MEISTERSINGER VON NURNBERG.

Review: DIE MEISTERSINGER VON NÜRNBERG at the Metropolitan Opera

Considered by many to be Wagner's masterpiece, today's matinee performance gave credence to that opinion. The production is that of Otto Schenk with scenery by Gunther Schneider-Siemssen, and costumes by Rolf Langenfass.

One needs patience to make it through the opera's great length, but the effort is well worth it. The story is that of the knight Walther Von Stolzing who,while staying in the town of Nuremberg, falls in love with Eva Pogner, daughter of one of the town elders.

Her father is holding a song contest, the prize being his daughter's hand in marriage should she love the victor. The winner, however, must be a mastersinger, a status usually achieved only after many years of study. Hans Sachs, a cobbler and mastersinger, helps Walther achieve his goal and in doing so proves to be the hero of the piece, despite his advanced years.

The town clerk, Beckmesser, is the thorn in Walther's side and impedes the young knight's efforts. All of these characters are well-delineated, both musically and dramatically by the composer, in a plethora of gorgeous music.

As stated above, the production, which premiered in the early 1990's, is traditional, to me the only way to stage this work. This is not an opera that cries for updating, as it is set in medieval times and the characters are indeed of that period. Act one takes place in St. Katherine's Church, the second on a street in Nuremberg, and the third, split into two scenes, in Sachs' shop and on a meadow where the song contest take place.

A number of principal performers were singing their roles for the first time at the Met, namely Lise Davidsen as Eva, Klaus Florian Vogt as Walther, and Georg Zeppenfeld as Veit Pogner, Eva's father. Ms. Davidsen is a relatively young soprano, who is making quite a name for herself worldwide. She made her Met debut in PIQUE DAME two years ago and was to sing Fidelio last season but, due to the pandemic, did not. Her voice is beautiful and quite large and it is no exaggeration to say that she dominated all the ensembles in which she participated. She is to return later in the season in ELEKTRA and ARIADNE AUF NAXOS.

Klaus Florian Vogt has sung at the Met prior to this year. He has a strong tenor voice, while not stentorian, and is easily heard over the heavy orchestration. On hearing him in a live setting, I feel his voice is placed higher than the standard tenor voice, and requires some getting used to. He certainly cuts a dashing figure on stage and is well-paired with Ms. Davidsen.

Georg Zeppenfeld has a rich, voluminous bass and should appear at the Met more often. His sonorous voice would certainly be welcome here in much of the Wagner repertory he sings around the world.

Michael Volle, who sang Hans Sachs during the last revival, continues to amaze with his resonant, burnished tone. He seems to live the role to the fullest.

Johannes Martin Kranzle, also a veteran of this production, brought humor and a tinge of sadness to the role of the outwitted Beckmesser. It was entirely believable that he was competing for Eva's hand although we all know from the beginning he was going to lose out.

Paul Appleby and Claudia Mahnke played David and Magdalene with expertise. The master singers who filled out the reminder of the ensemble were all fine.

Maestro Antonio Pappano, absent from the Met for decades, brought a firm hand to the score and paced it well. He was rewarded with a tremendous and well-deserved ovation. The orchestra sounded excited to be back in place after the long hiatus. The chorus, which plays a major part in the proceedings was nothing short of splendid. The complex finales of acts one and two were perfect.

In all, a wonderful way to welcome the Met back to Lincoln Center after the longest hiatus in its history.

Photo: Richard Termine / Met Opera




From This Author - George Weinhouse


Review: October 16 Season Premiere of PETER GRIMES at The MetReview: October 16 Season Premiere of PETER GRIMES at The Met
October 19, 2022

One of the momentous events of the first season at the new Metropolitan Opera at Lincoln Center (and there were many) was the new production of Benjamin Britten's PETER GRIMES in 1967.  Although it had its Met premiere in 1948 at the old house, it was the Tyrone Guthrie production  that cemented its place in the Met repertory.  Starring Jon Vickers as its protagonist, it served to introduce his portrayal to a generation relatively new to the opera.  For approximately the next twenty years Vickers would play Grimes at most revivals.  Since then, there have been others who have played the role-Philip Langridge, Anthony Rolfe Johnson, and Anthony Dean Griffey-and left their mark on this almost mythical role.

BWW Review: AKHNATEN at the Met OperaBWW Review: AKHNATEN at the Met Opera
May 26, 2022

One of the greatest successes of recent Met seasons is Philip Glass's AKHNATEN, first seen in 2019.I saw it three times that year and fell under its spell each time.It is being revived this season.

BWW Review: Odyssey Records Recording of HENRY VIII by Saint-SaensBWW Review: Odyssey Records Recording of HENRY VIII by Saint-Saens
May 20, 2022

A new recording of Saint-Saens's opera HENRY VIII, by Odyssey Opera, has come my way. It is a complete version of the work which is dated 1883. Odyssey Opera is a company dedicated to the performance of operas that are out of the mainstream but are deemed worthy of recognition. 

BWW Review: ST. MATTHEW PASSION at Carnegie HallBWW Review: ST. MATTHEW PASSION at Carnegie Hall
May 17, 2022

Bernard Labadie led a transcendent performance of Bach's ST.MATTHEW PASSION at Carnegie Hall.

BWW Review: EUGENE ONEGIN at the Metropolitan OperaBWW Review: EUGENE ONEGIN at the Metropolitan Opera
March 29, 2022

The 2013 production of Tchaikovsky's Pushkin-inspired opera EUGENE ONEGIN has triumphantly returned to the Met. I attended the final dress rehearsal and can attest to the fact that the story of Tatyana's infatuation with, and later rejection of, the eponymous 'hero' is vocally in superb hands. Both singers and orchestra were splendid.