Perfect review for Saving Aimee. I agree with many of your thoughts. The music and book fell flat. I didn't care about the story at all. I could have left in the middle of the show and not cared one bit. I actually wanted to, but I stayed to show respect to the cast. A few people actually did leave.
Everyone that I have talked to has a similar feeling about the show. No one would go see it again. A lot has to be fixed before it goes to Broadway or even if they decide to just tour.