Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: From Farcical to Sombre in PERFECT ARRANGEMENT at Fells Point Corner Theatre

Review: From Farcical to Sombre in PERFECT ARRANGEMENT at Fells Point Corner Theatre

Being the age I am, I might well be the only person in the audience of the production of Topher Payne's Perfect Arrangement, now gracing the stage at Fells Point Corner Theatre, who can personally recall one of the historical events that inform the play. Though the play's focus is on the "Lavender Scare," which resulted in the purging of hundreds of State Department employees on suspicion of homosexuality, that scare was a companion to the "Red Scare," which led to the purging of hundreds of State Department employees on suspicions of "disloyalty." And indeed the play depicts the same people as implementing both scares, Lavender and Red. In 1953, my father, a senior diplomat administering the Marshall Plan, whose loyalty would in any rational world have been unquestionable, was let go in the Red Scare. And so the play resonated some for me. I can recall that as I came to understand what had become of our family, the thing that most struck me was the due process-deprived irrationality of it all. And for the characters in the play caught up in the toils of the Lavender Scare, that is the nub as well, the irrationality.

It's no wonder the topic appealed to Payne, a prolific Atlanta-based playwright whose work largely focuses on gay themes. Dramatists have always put irrationality to good use. It can for instance serve as the mainspring of farce, as it certainly does here, particularly in the first act. The title Perfect Arrangement refers to the compact of a male gay couple and a lesbian couple to hide in plain view from the disapproval of the world in 1950 by posing as two straight couples living in adjoining halves of a Georgetown duplex. The two halves are secretly connected through the residences' respective front closets, a passage that enables each real couple to reunite at night, unnoticed by the world outside. Such a setup is custom-made for farce. So there is plenty of dashing into and out of the closet or hiding under furniture, of excuses ginned up on the fly to explain when one or other of the "neighbors" is in the "wrong" house while the people expected to be there are elsewhere. To add to the comic as well as the ideological tension, one of the "husbands" and one of the "wives" are together placed in charge of implementing the State Department's purges, paradoxically opening themselves up to retaliatory revelations by their victims. Farce (of a grim sort).

In most farces, though, at the end, after the audience's tension has been ratcheted up by the accumulating lies and cascading improbabilities, all the impostures must come tumbling down. Shams will be unmasked, and the world will readjust. And that convention, the unmasking, is observed in Perfect Arrangement as well. Except that there's nothing funny or farcical about what happened to "unmasked" employees of the State Department in 1950. (The first U.S. diplomat to have exited the closet and kept his career seems to have come out in 1975.) As a result, both history and the dynamics of farce compel a shift in tone between the first and the second acts of the play.

To be candid, I could not entirely follow what does and doesn't happen after the unmasking moment in the play, but it is clear that one of the central characters decides to burrow deeper into the (metaphorical, not the literal) closet while the others make a choice to be truer to themselves and resolve to agitate publicly for change.

I don't think the majority choice was actually available in 1950. Dudley Clendinen and Adam Nagourney, in Out for Good, their authoritative history of "the struggle to build a gay rights movement in America," begin in 1969 with Stonewall, although they note in passing that there had been demonstrations throughout the 60s, which had been "small, rare, respectful, even timid, with the men wearing ties and jackets and the women in skirts." But the events of the play take place at the dawn of the 50s, not even the 60s.

A choice to exit the closet in official Washington of the 50s or 60s would likewise have been career suicide; the actual suicide of Senator Lester Hunt in 1954 when Hunt was threatened with being outed (which inspired the fictional suicide of a senator in the sensational book Advise and Consent (1959) and movie made of it (1962)) gives a more accurate picture of the unendurable fearfulness of the condemnation characters would have had to expect had they come out.

But whatever the historical accuracy of depicting people of that place and time choosing to be publicly and unapologetically explicit about who they were, it works dramatically - as does the related exploration of complicity and self-hatred of gay public servants who participated in gay witch-hunts. The change in tone of the play's second act makes this thoughtful and dramatically challenging exploration possible. That said, one can be grateful to have had the laughs of Act One first.

FPCT gives the resulting show, both funny and thoughtful, a rousing production. As the two queer characters in charge of purging queer characters, Nate Krimmel and Holly Gibbs are portraits in dismay, and between them they credibly explore the range of emotional development likely for people in their situation. And Ari Eckley and Gabe Fremuth, as their spouses, are good with the comedy and, particularly in Eckley's case, good at the more sensitive stuff, for instance conveying the emotional groundwork on which a character in those circumstances might build the decision to come out. Ebony N. Jackson and Shamire Casselle portray two very different intruders on the seclusion crucial to the Perfect Arrangement. Jackson's character, deep into the kind of housewifery promoted by the postwar media, is anxious to drag the other women along into a life focused on maternity and consumption, her form of sisterhood obliviously threatening the women's lesbian lives. Jackson imparts just the right kind of insistent cluelessness into the role. Casselle's character is more complicated; of uncertain sexual orientation but apparently prodigious sexual appetite, and unburdened by shame, she turns out to be both prey and predator to the witch-hunters and their mates. Casselle wrings a lot of laughs out of a part which remains in large measure mysterious and unknown. While, for reasons I've already given and others, I'm not convinced that this is truly a story of the middle of the last century, any suspension of disbelief I managed was largely due to David Forrer's turn as a senior State Department official in charge of wrangling the witch hunters. He effortlessly evoked the WASPy and patrician State Department I remember around my parents. And the rest of the suspension of disbelief would be owing to Bruce Kapplin's set, a terrific evocation of Mad Men era decorative values.

To paraphrase John Lennon, an amusing and thought-provoking time is guaranteed for all.

Perfect Arrangement, by Topher Payne, directed by Patrick Gorirossi, through September 22, at Fells Point Corner Theatre, 251 S. Ann Street, Baltimore, MD, 21231. Tickets $20 at . Adult language, sexual situations, smoking.

Photo credit: Shaelynn Jae Photography

Cumberland Theatre Stars Of Tomorrow to Present THE SPONGEBOB MUSICAL in April Photo
The Cumberland Theatre Stars of Tomorrow will present The SpongeBob Musical at the theatre April 13th - 16th.

Review: Brava, Bravo! Fall In Love With HUBBA HUBBA at Theatre Project Photo
Brava, Bravo! For HUBBA HUBBA At Theatre Project: Don't miss the World Premiere! This new show by Alex & Olmsted, internationally acclaimed winners of multiple Jim Henson Award grants, is a pastiche of comedic scenes starring humans, puppets and an invisible fruit fly. Each carries a unique message spotlighting different facets of romantic love.

A NICE INDIAN BOY Extends at Olney Theatre Center Photo
Olney Theatre Center is extending the run of A Nice Indian Boy by Madhuri Shekar and directed by Zi Alikhan, for one week. The new closing date is Sunday, April 16, 2023.

VANYA, SONIA, MASHA & SPIKE Opens April 14th At Spotlighters Photo
Spotlighters Theatre presents Vanya & Sonia & Masha & Spike - three crazy siblings and one hot mess, by Christopher Durang and directed by Erin Klarner. Running April 14 - April 30, 2023

From This Author - Jack L. B. Gohn

Review: THE SOUND INSIDE Thrills and Bemuses at Everyman TheatreReview: THE SOUND INSIDE Thrills and Bemuses at Everyman Theatre
March 12, 2023

The Sound Inside, by Adam Rapp, now gracing the boards at Baltimore's Everyman Theatre, is one of those all-too-rare plays that just bowls you over, even if, afterwards, you’re not quite sure where you’ve been during its bemusing 90 minutes.

Review: FPCT's DEAD MAN'S CELL PHONE Only Rings SoftlyReview: FPCT's DEAD MAN'S CELL PHONE Only Rings Softly
February 21, 2023

The play doesn’t do either superficiality or depth well. And so a decent production like this (which Fells Point Corner Theatre provided) can still only go so far with it.

Review: Strange But Relatable JUMP at Everyman TheatreReview: Strange But Relatable JUMP at Everyman Theatre
January 30, 2023

Families, sisterly conflicts, alienation from parents, suicidal tendencies, dissociation, nostalgia for childhood mingled with mature reevaluation of it: all these themes and tropes are universal. And audiences of all backgrounds should find this show about them quite relatable, not to mention intriguing.

Review: RIDE THE CYCLONE At Arena StageReview: RIDE THE CYCLONE At Arena Stage
January 23, 2023

Go See It! Join the enthralled cult! It’s for anyone who was ever a theater or choir kid. It’s for anyone who ever had a sexuality of any flavor whatsoever, or just even an inner life. It’s for the frustrated amateur metaphysician in each of us. And it is certainly for the amateur detective in each of us; the creators, Jacob Richmond and Brooke Maxwell, have sprinkled clues and non sequiturs everywhere for us to ponder.

Incredible Songs and Ingenious Book Propel Audience Bliss With JAGGED LITTLE PILL at HippodromeIncredible Songs and Ingenious Book Propel Audience Bliss With JAGGED LITTLE PILL at Hippodrome
December 15, 2022

We do get a sort of happy ending, but not with a gratifying round of absolution for everyone. In the complicated interplay of transgression and victimization, and in the face of the realities of life in a patriarchal and heterosexist society, almost everyone ends up wishing they’d deserved and received greater absolution. There reemerges what Morissette calls “common ground,” but everyone remains a work in progress. And it is still enough to send the audience out with eyes shining. It’s earned.