| Edith Oliver Award for Sustained Excellence | Ruby Dee | |
| Outstanding Body of Work | Second Stage Theatre | |
| Outstanding Choreographer | Tony Parise | Pirates of Penzance |
| Outstanding Choreographer | Tony Stevens | The Complete Works of William Shakespeare (Abridged) |
| Outstanding Choreographer | John Carrafa | Urinetown |
| Outstanding Costume Design | Elizabeth Caitlin Ward | Cymbeline |
| Outstanding Costume Design | Bob Miller, Steven Howard | Dragapella! |
| Outstanding Costume Design | Susan Hilferty, Linda Ross | Franny’s Way |
|
| Outstanding Costume Design | Mara Blumenfeld | Metamorphoses |
| Outstanding Costume Design | Jonathan Bixby, Gregory Gale | Urinetown |
|
| Outstanding Director | Mark Wing-Davey | 36 Views |
| Outstanding Director | Bartlett Sher | Cymbeline |
| Outstanding Director | Mary Zimmerman | Metamorphoses |
| Outstanding Director | John Rando | Urinetown |
| Outstanding Featured Actor | Andrew Weems | Cymbeline |
| Outstanding Featured Actor | Keith Nobbs | Four |
|
|
| Outstanding Featured Actor | Isiah Whitlock, Jr. | Four |
| Outstanding Featured Actor | David Aaron Baker | Hobson’s Choice |
| Outstanding Featured Actor | Frederick Weller | The Shape of Things |
| Outstanding Featured Actress | Kathleen Widdoes | Franny’s Way |
|
| Outstanding Featured Actress | Robin Weigert | Madame Melville |
| Outstanding Featured Actress | Gretchen Mol | The Shape of Things |
| Outstanding Featured Actress | Spencer Kayden | Urinetown |
| Outstanding Featured Actress | Amy Sedaris | Wonder of the World |
|
| Outstanding Lead Actor | Reg Rogers | The Dazzle |
| Outstanding Lead Actor | Peter Frechette | The Dazzle |
| Outstanding Lead Actor | Norbert Leo Butz | The Last 5 Years |
| Outstanding Lead Actor | Jeffrey Wright | Topdog/Underdog |
| Outstanding Lead Actor | Hunter Foster | Urinetown |
| Outstanding Lead Actress | Phylicia Rashad | Blue |
|
| Outstanding Lead Actress | Elaine Stritch | Elaine Stritch At Liberty |
| Outstanding Lead Actress | Martha Plimpton | Hobson’s Choice |
|
|
| Outstanding Lead Actress | Linda Emond | Homebody/Kabul |
| Outstanding Lead Actress | Ruby Dee | Saint Lucy’s Eyes |
| Outstanding Lifetime Achievement | Edward Albee | |
| Outstanding Lighting Design | David Weiner | 36 Views |
| Outstanding Lighting Design | Traci Klainer | Four |
| Outstanding Lighting Design | TJ Gerckens | Metamorphoses |
| Outstanding Lighting Design | Brian MacDevitt | Urinetown |
| Outstanding Musical | Executive Producer, Irwin Keller, Maurice Kelly, Chris Dilley, Maria DiDia, Ben Schatz | Dragapella! |
|
|
| Outstanding Musical | Arielle Tepper, Marty Bell, Libby Adler Mages, Mari Glick, Rose, Land Productions | The Last 5 Years |
| Outstanding Musical | Victoria Leacock, Robyn Goodman, Dede Harris, Lorie Cowen Levy, Beth Smith | tick, tick…BOOM! |
| Outstanding Musical | The Araca Group, Dodger Theatricals, TheaterDreams Inc., Lauren Mitchell | Urinetown |
| Outstanding Play | New York Theatre Workshop | Homebody/Kabul |
| Outstanding Play | Second Stage Theatre | Metamorphoses |
| Outstanding Play | Lincoln Center Theater | The Carpetbagger’s Children |
| Outstanding Play | Roundabout Theatre Company | The Dazzle |
| Outstanding Play | Terry Allen Kramer | The Play About the Baby |
|
|
| Outstanding Play | Ben Sprecher, Susan Quint Gallin, Sandy Gallin, Stuart Thompson, USA/OSTAR Theatricals | The Shape of Things |
| Outstanding Revival | Second Stage Theatre | Crimes of the Heart |
|
| Outstanding Revival | Theatre for a New Audience | Cymbeline |
| Outstanding Revival | Atlantic Theatre Company | Hobson’s Choice |
| Outstanding Revival | On Deck Entertainment, Diane Krausz, Brett Singer | Pirates of Penzance |
| Outstanding Scenic Design | Douglas Stein | 36 Views |
| Outstanding Scenic Design | Daniel Ostling | Metamorphoses |
| Outstanding Scenic Design | Allen Moyer | The Dazzle |
|
| Outstanding Scenic Design | Scott Pask | Urinetown |
| Outstanding Scenic Design | David Gallo | Wonder of the World |
| Outstanding Sound Design | David A. Gilman, Brett Jarvis | Brutal Imagination |
| Outstanding Sound Design | Scott Lehrer | Franny’s Way |
|
| Outstanding Sound Design | Dan Moses Schreier | Homebody/Kabul |
| Outstanding Sound Design | Andre Pluess, Ben Sussman | Metamorphoses |
| Playwrights’ Sidewalk Inductee(s) | Romulus Linney | |
| Unique Theatrical Experience | The Joseph Papp Public Theatre/New York Shakespeare Festival, George C. Wolfe, Producer | Elaine Stritch At Liberty |
|
|
