| Most Promising Book | Diz White, Ron House | El Grande de Coco-Cola1972-73 season |
| Most Promising Composer | Stanley Silverman | Dr. Selavy's Magic Theatre1972-73 season |
| Most Promising Costume Design | Cookie Gluck, Laura Crow | Warp1972-73 season |
| Most Promising Lyricist | National Lampoon Lemmings | Jean Kelly1972-73 season |
| Most Promising Performer | D. Jamin-Bartlett | A Little Night Music1972-73 season |
| Most Promising Performer | Ralph Carter | Dude1972-73 season |
| Most Promising Performer | Bill Cobbs | Freeman1972-73 season |
| Most Promising Performer | Gail Strickland | Status Quo Vadis1972-73 season |
|
| Most Promising Performer | Tom Atkins | The Changing Room1972-73 season |
| Most Promising Performer | Trish Hawkins | The Hot L Baltimore1972-73 season |
|
| Most Promising Performer | Mary Lou Rosato | The School for Scandal1972-73 season |
| Most Promising Performer | Bill Cobbs | What the Wine Cellars Buy1972-73 season |
| Most Promising Playwright | Robert Randall | 6 Rms Riv Vu1972-73 season |
| Most Promising Playwright | Steve Tesich | Baba Goya1972-73 season |
| Most Promising Playwright | James Prideaux | The Last of Mrs. Lincoln1972-73 season |
| Most Promising Playwright | Joseph A. Walker | The River Niger1972-73 season |
|
|
| Most Promising Set Design | Jerry Rojo | Endgame1972-73 season |
| Outstanding Book | Hugh Wheeler | A Little Night Music1972-73 season |
| Outstanding Costume Design | Theoni V. Aldredge | Much Ado About Nothing1972-73 season |
| Outstanding Costume Design | Patricia Zipprodt | Pippin1972-73 season |
|
| Outstanding Director | Harold Prince | A Little Night Music1972-73 season |
| Outstanding Director | Bob Fosse | Pippin1972-73 season |
| Outstanding Director | Michael Rudd | The Changing Room1972-73 season |
| Outstanding Director | Harold Prince | The Great God Brown1972-73 season |
|
| Outstanding Director | Robert Sklar, Joseph Chaikin | The Mutation Show1972-73 season |
| Outstanding Director | Victor Garcia | Yerma1972-73 season |
| Outstanding Music & Lyrics | Stephen Sondheim | A Little Night Music1972-73 season |
| Outstanding Performance | Patricia Elliott, Glynis Johns | A Little Night Music1972-73 season |
| Outstanding Performance | Rosemary Harris | A Streetcar Named Desire1972-73 season |
| Outstanding Performance | Alan Bates | Butley1972-73 season |
|
| Outstanding Performance | Christopher Plummer | Cyrano1972-73 season |
| Outstanding Performance | John McMartin | Don Juan1972-73 season |
|
|
| Outstanding Performance | James Earl Jones, Stacy Keach | Hamlet1972-73 season |
| Outstanding Performance | Jessica Tandy | Happy Days1972-73 season |
| Outstanding Performance | Christopher Lloyd | Kasper1972-73 |
| Outstanding Performance | Pamela Payton-Wright, Colleen Dewhurst | Mourning Becomes Electra1972-73 season |
| Outstanding Performance | Sam Waterston, Douglass Watson | Much Ado About Nothing1972-73 season |
| Outstanding Performance | Jessica Tandy | Not I1972-73 season |
| Outstanding Performance | Ben Vereen | Pippin1972-73 season |
| Outstanding Performance | Michele Lee | Seesaw1972-73 season |
|
|
| Outstanding Performance | John Lithgow | The Changing Room1972-73 season |
| Outstanding Performance | James Earl Jones | The Cherry Orchard1972-73 season |
| Outstanding Performance | John McMartin, John Glover | The Great God Brown1972-73 season |
| Outstanding Performance | Mari Gorman | The Hot L Baltimore1972-73 season |
| Outstanding Performance | Julie Harris | The Last of Mrs. Lincoln1972-73 season |
| Outstanding Performance | Rosemary Harris | The Merchant of Venice1972-73 season |
| Outstanding Performance | Jack Albertson | The Sunshine Boys1972-73 season |
| Outstanding Performance | Ruby De | Wedding Band1972-73 season |
|
|
| Outstanding Set Design | Tony Walton | Pippin1972-73 season |
| Outstanding Set Design | Tony Walton | Shelter1972-73 season |
|
| Outstanding Set Design | David Jenkins | The Changing Room1972-73 season |
| Outstanding Set Design | Fabian Puigserver, Victor Garcia | Yerma1972-73 season |
