Review: FIDDLER ON THE ROOF at Plaza Theatrical

The classic showstopper, FIDDLER ON THE ROOF at Plaza Theatrical in Elmont is not to be missed! A deeply experienced director, Kevin F. Harrington pulled no punches with this production. From the costumes, scenery, and set pieces to the music, dancing, and acting, the show was polished from start to finish!

The simple yet effective set by Joel Schoenberger consisted of a detailed backdrop of Anatevka village homes. The lighting by Kay Wright gave the stage the depth it demanded, and the few but perfectly thought-out and versatile set pieces (Donovan Molinaro) provided all the verity the show needed.

Conductor Joseph J. Pallotta brought the orchestra to life with precision and unity. Alan Kingsley's vocal direction elevated the cast to give the best possible performances. The solos and ensemble pieces were equally well done.

When Tevye, played by Bruce Rebold, emerged onto the stage dragging his milk cart and regaling us with the parable of the fiddler, we knew right away we were in for something special. We weren’t just watching an actor play Tevye. We were watching Tevye himself with all his humor and charm. Rebold’s warm baritone, personable nature, and impeccable comedic timing made it difficult to imagine anyone else in the role.

The cast joined Tevye and took their part in the famous (pardon the pun) traditional opening number, “Tradition”. Beautiful harmonies, period and culturally accurate costumes (Barbara Kirby), and traditional choreography (Michelle Taplin) brought the village of Anatevka to life right in the heart of Elmont!

Tzeitel (Megan Bayen), Hodel (Emma Catalano), and Chava (Julianna Osburn) were a perfect trio! They swept us away in “Matchmaker”, as the three daughters executed its harmonies and choreography excellently.

Cathy Chimenti as Tevye’s wife, Golde, was the perfect balance of sarcastic and adoring. Her rich character vocals were really on display in Act II’s “Do you love me?” when she reluctantly confessed her feelings to her husband of 25 years.

The audience was overcome with reverence when the congregation processed down the aisles from the back of the theater during “Sabbath Prayer”. Each carrying candles and adorned in traditional dress, they drew us into the ceremony.

There was no question as to the camaraderie and friendship among Tevye, Lazer Wolf (Frank DiSpigno), and the rest of the village men during “To Life”. Not to be overlooked was Sean O’Connor as Fyedka when he brought down the pub with his extended B-flat!

One Dream. Two ghosts. And a lot of dramatic staging. That’s what you can expect from “The Dream”. Barbara Kirby was strong as Grandma Tzeitel while Fruma-Sarah, played by Megan Bayen, loomed over the stage in her extravagant, ghostly garb, frightening Tevye, Golde and a stage full of ghosts. Be on the lookout for the perfectly timed cymbal/pillow crash!

The choreography and energy of “The Wedding” were infectious! It wouldn’t have been much of a surprise if the audience had gotten up and joined in the fun! In contrast, the mood changed dramatically when the Russians broke up the wedding, destroyed the village, and eventually ousted the entire community from their generational homes.

Traditions both old and new. Times both difficult and joyful. Love and family. You’ll experience all of that and more!

Photo credit: Plaza Theatrical

FIDDLER ON THE ROOF. Playing now through 5/31

2026 Theater Fans' Choice Awards - Live Stats

Best Lighting Design - Top 3

1. Jen Schriever, Michael Arden - The Lost Boys

32% of votes

2. Kevin Adams - Chess

11.1% of votes

3. Jack Knowles - Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)

8.8% of votes

Vote Now! View Live Stats