Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

CORNED BEEF (AND OTHER ARGUMENTS) Debuts at Theater For The New City This April

Performances run April 23-May 10.

By:
CORNED BEEF (AND OTHER ARGUMENTS) Debuts at Theater For The New City This April

It's 1890-ish, and two immigrants aboard a ship headed to Ellis Island are about to have beef. Major beef. They just don't know it yet.

That's the conflict that ignites CORNED BEEF (AND OTHER ARGUMENTS), a new darkly hilarious, shamelessly silly, and surprisingly heartfelt play written by Robyn Kimmel and Brian Martin, coming to Theater For the New City on April 23.

Directed by Sofia Pastena, the production runs from April 23-May 10, featuring Robyn Kimmel and Brian Martin in leading roles.

The 19th-century romp follows Ruth, a Jewish immigrant from a European shtetl, and Phineas, a down-on-his-luck Irishman, who left everything behind for a chance at the American Dream. But chaos erupts when they discover that they're both coming to New York City with the same mission: To bring corned beef to the New World. Their incessant quarreling and quick banter explores unlikely friendship, belonging, and generational anxiety through biting satirical wit, Katz's Deli sandwich-sized laughs, plus a few surprisingly tender moments thrown in for good measure.

"It's 'The Odd Couple' meets Mel Brooks meets 'Fiddler on the Roof,'" says Kimmel. "A dishonest history with an honest look at the anxiety that exists both within the Jewish and Irish Catholic experience."

Kimmel adds, "The character of Ruth is loosely inspired by my own great-grandparents. She brings a heightened level of anxiety to the stage that I have always felt is deeply and intrinsically Jewish. Despite coming from different countries, cultures, and religions, both the characters and the audience realize they're more similar than different."

The creative team behind Corned Beef (and Other Arguments) includes stage manager Sofia Pastena, set design by Olivia Taylor, and lightning design and board operator Zoe Tevyaw.

Performances will take place at Theater For the New City, located at 155 1st Ave, New York, with shows Thursday through Saturday at 8 PM and Sunday at 3 PM.

Click Here to Get Tickets
More on Theater For the New City
Upcoming Shows
Getting COMPLETE
Getting COMPLETE
1/14 - 1/31/2027
Recent Articles
ONE-ACT PRIDE FESTIVAL NYC to Feature Works by Queer Artists at Theater for the New City
ONE-ACT PRIDE FESTIVAL NYC to Feature Works by Queer Artists at Theater for the New City
6/4/2026
Photos: GOODNIGHT, MRS. CALABASH At Theater For The New City
Photos: GOODNIGHT, MRS. CALABASH At Theater For The New City
6/2/2026
Need more Off-Off-Broadway Theatre News in your life?
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...

Local Shows
Dr Kara Kibara – The Love Guru in Off-Off-Broadway Dr Kara Kibara – The Love Guru
Brooklyn Art Haus (7/16-7/16)
A Tom Lehrer Cabaret in Off-Off-Broadway A Tom Lehrer Cabaret
The Green Room 42 (7/29-7/29)
Broadway Magic Hour in Off-Off-Broadway Broadway Magic Hour
Broadway Magic Hour: Magic Show (7/25-1/02)
My Evil Twin in Off-Off-Broadway My Evil Twin
Marjorie S Deane Little Theater (7/18-7/18)
Oil & Whiskey in Off-Off-Broadway Oil & Whiskey
The Bitter End, Laurie Beechman, Prohibition, The Rat NYC (7/15-8/12) VIDEOS
Rock Never Dies in Off-Off-Broadway Rock Never Dies
Hard Rock Cafe (5/29-8/30) PHOTOS VIDEOS
SAY MY NAME in Off-Off-Broadway SAY MY NAME
AMT Theatre (7/23-7/26)
Shangri-La-La, a comedy musical about Siegfried & Roy in Off-Off-Broadway Shangri-La-La, a comedy musical about Siegfried & Roy
American Theatre of Actors (ATA) (7/25-7/26)
That Math Show in Off-Off-Broadway That Math Show
Theater555 (6/11-8/16)
THE HARM in Off-Off-Broadway THE HARM
American Theatre of Actors (7/16-7/21)

BroadwayWorld TV