The only ones that are repeated in my playlist are (including the "I Believe" that you posted):
Sante Fe (Newsies) Sante Fe (RENT)
Without You (My Fair Lady) Without You (RENT)
Ice Cream (She Loves Me) Ice Cream (The Music Man)
I'm Here (The Color Purple) I'm Here (Matilda)
Most of my doubles come from Barbra Streisand singing old show tunes throughout her career, Carole King via Beautiful: The Carole King Musical, and Kelli O'Hara's "Always" album has a lot that are matched up with my cast recordings.
It's always fun to look at the list though! I have some down the line like "Thank you, Madam" from She Loves Me and then "Thank you, Sir" from Brooklyn the Musical, haha.
Suppertime - You're A Good Man Charlie Brown Suppertime - Little Shop of Horrors Suppertime - As Thousands Cheer
If anyone ever tells you that you put too much Parmesan cheese on your pasta, stop talking to them. You don't need that kind of negativity in your life.
I started one of these threads awhile ago wanting to make a CD... here's the final list (Ended up with 2 CDs)
1. I’m Alive Xanadu 2. I'm Alive Next to Normal 3. Better Little Women 4. Better Bring it On 5. Maria The Sound of Music 6. Maria West Side Story 7. Suppertime YAGM, CB 8. Suppertime Little Shop of Horrors 9. Class Chicago 10. Class Saturday Night 11. Home Wonderland 12. Home Beauty and the Beast 13. Home The Wiz 14. One of Us Mamma Mia! 15. One of Us Rocky 16. If Only The Little Mermaid 17. If Only Whistle Down The Wind 18. Every Day a Little Death A Little Night Music 19. Every Day A Little Death The Count of Monte Cristo 20. Without You Rent 21. Without You My Fair Lady 22. Ever After Bare 23. Ever After Into the Woods
1. Santa Fe Newsies 2. Santa Fe Rent 3. What Would You Do If/Then 4. What Would You Do Cabaret 5. Take a Chance on Me Little Women 6. Take A Chance on Me Mamma Mia! 7. All For You Seussical 8. All For You Saturday Night 9. You and I Chess 10. You and I Bare 11. I Believe Spring Awakening 12. I Believe Altar Boyz 13. I Believe The Book of Mormon 14. Oklahoma Oklahoma 15. Oklahoma Dirty Rotten Scoundrels 16. Gold Once 17. Gold Road Show 18. Alive Jekyll & Hyde 19. Alive Death Takes a Holiday 20. It Takes Two Into the Woods 21. It Takes Two Hairspray 22. Let It Go Frozen 23. Let It Go The Full Monty