Skip to main content Skip to footer site map
Review: MISS HOLMES at David S. & Anne V. Howard Studio Theatre

Review: MISS HOLMES at David S. & Anne V. Howard Studio Theatre

The game is indeed afoot in this compelling mystery that does Sherlock proud.

Written by Christopher M. Walsh in 2016 and inspired by the works of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, Miss Holmes is a gender-bending theatrical fan fiction that adds a fascinating re-imagining of the main characters in this Victorian-day mystery. Enter Miss Sherlock Holmes (Helen Sanford) and Dr. Dorothy Watson (Victoria Flounders) What? Women doctors? Women detectives? How absurd!

The game is indeed afoot! We are placed in London, England 1881. Foreboding, anonymous letters are delivered to the newlywed wife Lizzy Chapman (Starr Mandell) of a corrupt Scotland Yard investigator Thomas Chapman (William Ashburn) leading Lizzy to seek help in solving the mystery of who is behind such writings. Miss Sherlock Holmes and her new companion Dr. Dorothy Watson come together as two forward-thinking intelligent women to uncover the conspiracy surrounding Lizzy's husband whose past wives have died of mysterious consequences. Ah, but like any good mystery, there are mysteries surrounding the mystery that also need to be solved!

Sherlock needs a good mystery to solve with a keen mind such as hers, especially after just being released from an asylum, placed there by her older brother Mycroft (Martin Nicholas). He can't keep up with her cunning mind and doesn't have the time or patience to "manage" her. Sherlock's new friend Dr. Watson has her own issues working for the only hospital in London that employs female doctors. Their combined brilliant minds make for great sleuths. Even Sherlock's stoic brother Mycroft sees worth in Dr. Watson noting she tempers Sherlock's shenanigans with an intellectual calm. He offers her a room in the Holmes house with himself and Sherlock at no cost, if she agrees to "spy" and report back to him on his sister's doings. Although she agrees, the good doctor stays loyal to Sherlock and joins her on adventures breaking into people's homes - searching for evidence, shooting poor Edwin Greener (Thomas Finn) and various other mischievous notions.

There are several surprises in this script, as usual with mysteries, more murder, more mayhem, that keep the production moving along. The cast does a wonderful job with the well-designed interchangeable set, cast doublings, and furniture rearrangements. Under the direction of India Marie Paul each actor added their own touch to create the personality traits of the character(s) they portrayed. House management/production team Amanda Schlachter, Craig Smith, and Timothy Bourn are incredibly talented at juggling many roles and tasks at once. Kudos to the entire cast and production staff for pulling together this fine production, particularly following the aftermath of Hurricane Ian. You did Sherlock proud.

State College of Florida, Manatee-Sarasota is accredited by the Commission on Colleges of the Southern Association of Colleges and Schools to award associate and baccalaureate degrees. SCF THEATRE presents four or five shows annually. These comedies, dramas, and mysteries are presented in the David S. & Anne V. Howard Studio Theatre, which is located in the SW corner of the Neel Performing Arts Center. Theatre productions are staged by professional directors who also serve as adjunct and full-time faculty. Auditions are open to SCF students and community members. For more information on the theatre program and upcoming shows visit

Westcoast Black Theatre Troupe Continues 2022-2023 Theatre Season With DREAMGIRLS Photo
Westcoast Black Theatre Troupe will continue its 2022-2023 “American Dreams” theatre season with the highly-anticipated production, “Dreamgirls.” The show runs from February 22 through April 9, 2023.

Art Center Sarasota Welcomes Javi Suárez As Board Member Photo
Philip C. Baker, whose position as chairman of Art Center Sarasota's board of directors commenced with the start of the fiscal year, recently announced that the organization has welcomed the celebrated architect and artist Javi Suárez to its board of directors. 

Hermitage Announces Benefit Concert With Andy Sandberg And Broadway Guest Stars In March Photo
The Hermitage Artist Retreat (Sarasota County, Florida) has announced a one-night-only benefit concert to celebrate the 20th Anniversary Season of the Hermitage and to raise funds for ongoing repairs to the Hermitage following the impact of Hurricane Ian earlier this season.

Florida Studio Theatre Presents The Regional Premiere Of Fast-Paced Drama, THE LAST MATCH Photo
Florida Studio Theatre (FST) presents the Regional Premiere of The Last Match by Anna Ziegler, a fast-paced play diving into the intense world of professional sports.

From This Author - Carolan Trbovich

      Carolan Trbovich is an innovator who used both corporate savvy and her considerable creativity to blaze new trails in entertainment industry operations for two powerhouse music... (read more about this author)

December 18, 2022

What did our critic think of CIRQUE MUSICA HOLIDAY WONDERLAND at Van Wezel?

Review: HOLLYWOOD HOLIDAYS at Riveview Performing Arts CenterReview: HOLLYWOOD HOLIDAYS at Riveview Performing Arts Center
December 12, 2022

What did our critic think of HOLLYWOOD HOLIDAYS at Riveview Performing Arts Center? The Pops Orchestra celebrates the holiday season with the Hollywood Holidays concert led by its imaginative and ever-entertaining music director, Dr. Robyn Bell. The long list of amazing holiday films is only surpassed by their wonderful soundtracks. With new videos from SCF film students, it's holiday cinemagic on the Pops Orchestra's concert stage.

Review: MISS HOLMES at David S. & Anne V. Howard Studio TheatreReview: MISS HOLMES at David S. & Anne V. Howard Studio Theatre
November 21, 2022

What did our critic think of MISS HOLMES at David S. & Anne V. Howard Studio Theatre?

Review: CABARET at Asolo Repertory TheatreReview: CABARET at Asolo Repertory Theatre
November 21, 2022

What did our critic think of CABARET at Asolo Repertory Theatre?

Review: Westcoast Black Theatre Troupe's GUYS AND DOLLSReview: Westcoast Black Theatre Troupe's GUYS AND DOLLS
October 17, 2022

Guys and Dolls is a musical featuring lyrics and music by Frank Loesser and book by Abe Burrow and Jo Swerling. The production follows the lives of New York’s underworld of guys who are cheats, gamblers and gangsters, and the dolls they love that make their lives even more complicated. It premiered on the Broadway stage in 1950. Many will remember the 1955 film version starring the all-star cast of Frank Sinatra, Marlon Brando, Jean Simmons and Vivian Blaine. So many memorable songs came from this production.