My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

YOU SAY TOMATO, I SAY SHUT UP! Extends at CLO Cabaret

By:

Due to popular demand, You Say Tomato, I Say Shut Up! has been extended at the CLO Cabaret through May 12. The show was previously scheduled to close on May 5. Tickets for all remaining performances are now on sale.

About the Show
A 21st century love story where "Happily Ever After" meets "It's Complicated"
From seductive young lovers to reluctant Facebook friends, Annabelle and Jeff have 10 years of marriage under their belts when they encounter the question all married couples face - "Where would we be without Pinot Noir?"

In this 75-minute tour de force You Say Tomato, I Say Shut Up! takes a humorous look at a relationship that seemed doomed by opposing personalities from the start. After trials and tribulations they learn to navigate the conflicts that come with romance, money, and children by embracing each other's differences, taking on parenting as a competitive sport, and dropping out of couple's therapy. Their delightfully crazy lifestyle has managed to keep their relationship intact, upending every idea you ever had about living "happily ever after." PG-13, Some adult content.

Performance Schedule

Wednesdays

7:30pm

Thursdays

1:00pm* & 7:30pm

Fridays

7:30pm

Saturdays

2:00pm & 7:30pm

Sundays

2:00pm

*With optional buffet at the CLO Cabaret on April 25

Tickets
Tickets range from $34.75-$44.75 and will be available online at CLOCabaret.com, by calling 412-456-6666 or at the Box Office at Theater Square. Groups of 10 or more can call the Group Sales Hotline at 412-325-1582 to learn more about special discounts, priority seating and corporate discounts. Visit pittsburghCLO.org for more information.

Theater Fans' Choice Awards
2026 Theater Fans' Choice Awards - Live Stats
Best Touring Production - Top 3
1. Hadestown
11.8% of votes
2. Hamilton
8.9% of votes
3. Les Misérables
8.2% of votes

Don't Miss a Pittsburgh News Story
Sign up for all the news on the Spring season, discounts & more...


Videos


Eddie Day and TNT headline Embers Terrace Grand Opening at Mohegan PA! On May 20, 2026 in Pittsburgh Eddie Day and TNT headline Embers Terrace Grand Opening at Mohegan PA! On May 20, 2026
Embers Terrace (5/20-5/20)
Rainbow Kitten Surprise  in Pittsburgh Rainbow Kitten Surprise
Stage AE (9/23-9/23)
MTV Unplugged Tribute Band returns to Jergel's Rhythm Grille On July 16, 2026 in Pittsburgh MTV Unplugged Tribute Band returns to Jergel's Rhythm Grille On July 16, 2026
Jergel's Rhythm Grille (7/16-7/16)
Brad Williams at Byham Theater in Pittsburgh Brad Williams at Byham Theater
Byham Theater (5/29-5/29)
Completely Unchained: The Ultimate Van Halen Tribute-ON SALE NOW! in Pittsburgh Completely Unchained: The Ultimate Van Halen Tribute-ON SALE NOW!
The Lamp Theatre (5/30-5/30)
The Great Gatsby – Theatrical Production at Benedum Center Pittsburgh in Pittsburgh The Great Gatsby – Theatrical Production at Benedum Center Pittsburgh
Benedum Center Pittsburgh (5/26-5/26)
Superunknown: The Premier Tribute to Chris Cornell presents 'The 35 Tour' in Pittsburgh Superunknown: The Premier Tribute to Chris Cornell presents 'The 35 Tour'
The Lamp Theatre (7/10-7/10)
Sixty Nine - Seventy  in Pittsburgh Sixty Nine - Seventy
City Theatre's Campus (5/14-5/24)
MTV Unplugged Tribute Band at Sherman Showcase On July 11, 2026 in Pittsburgh MTV Unplugged Tribute Band at Sherman Showcase On July 11, 2026
Sherman Showcase (7/11-7/11)
ROCK THE LAMP-A Party to Benefit The Lamp Theatre in Pittsburgh ROCK THE LAMP-A Party to Benefit The Lamp Theatre
The Lamp Theatre (5/29-5/29)