Rupert Holmes, Stephanie J. Block, Robert Creighton, Jessie Mueller and Betsy Wolfe at THE MYSTERY OF EDWIN DROOD Cast Reunites at CAST PARTY! Photo
For the past ten years, Jim Caruso's Cast Party at Birdland has been the ultimate place for Broadway folks to mingle and celebrate each other, as evidenced by Monday night's jammed-to-the-walls open-mic-fest. The cast of The Mystery of Edwin Drood staged a reunion, with Tony nominee Stephanie J. Block,Bobby Creighton, Andy Karl, Jessie Mueller, and Betsy Wolfe all grabbing the mic separately and together with a live performance of their YouTube hit, 'Bustle Fluffah!' Drood composer/writer Rupert Holmes then surprised everyone by singing his #1 hit, 'The Pina Colada Song!' (Lucky audience members won the new Drood cast recording, too.) BroadwayWorld brings you photos from the festivities below!
Date Taken: May 21, 2013
More Photos...

Robert Creighton. Photo credit: Maryann Lopinto
Date: 2026-03-14From: Photos: PETER FILICHIA & FRIENDS Warms 54 Below With Memories

Paul Adam Schaefer and Robert Creighton. Photo credit: Maryann Lopinto
Date: 2026-03-14From: Photos: PETER FILICHIA & FRIENDS Warms 54 Below With Memories

Robert Creighton and Paul Adam Schaefer. Photo credit: Maryann Lopinto
Date: 2026-03-14From: Photos: PETER FILICHIA & FRIENDS Warms 54 Below With Memories
Videos
TICKET CENTRAL






