Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: Portland Stage's ALMOST, MAINE is Pure Perfection

Review: Portland Stage's ALMOST, MAINE is Pure Perfection

Portland Stage's revival of John Cariani's ALMOST, MAINE, a play which premiered with the company in 2004, represents some of the very best work this theatre can produce. The exquisitely poetic series of vignettes about love and loss framed within the uniqueness of the Maine context, offers an evening of virtually pure perfection and unlimited delight.

Cariani's play is a perfect vehicle for this theatre in that it speaks in a voice that is so completely authentic that it draws the audience in and commands their empathy and identification. The playwright's world is peopled with real Mainers - not L.L. Bean stereotypes. These are simple, plain-spoken folk with quotidian lives that often hide their deeper emotional subtext. Cariani's great skill is probing the inner depths of his characters' hearts and allowing them to shine through each situation with a quiet intensity that is both profoundly moving and warmly funny. And he masterfully weaves together lives and separate vignettes to create a vivid tapestry of rural American life.

This revival is blessed by Sally Wood's direction. Her identification with the piece and its people is evident, and she skillfully, subtly, and fluidly paces the work. She is a master at creating physical comedy to mirror emotional experiences - witness the scene where Randy and Chad discover the true nature of their feelings for each other - just as she is adept at finding the visual metaphors for the text and eliciting from the cast finely etched performances of quiet truth.

The physical production has a minimalist beauty. Anita Stewart's set with its vast expanse of blue that evokes the great starry northern skies and the chill of winter is both sparse and dreamy. Tiny lights in the distance suggest remote houses, while patches of snow punctuate the loneliness of the landscape with their white purity. Bryon Winn's lighting captures the chill of this north country; Kathleen P. Brown's realistic attire in simple neutrals is completely accurate and she has moments when the costumes add to the comedy such as in the seduction scene where the would-be lovers have to strip so many layers of clothing that their romantic ardor dissipates. Chris Fitze provides the appealing sound design, and Stage Manager Shane Van Vliet expertly anchors the production.

The four-person cast meld themselves into a flawless ensemble. Led (at these early performances) by Cariani, himself, they find the humor and poignancy of their characters. Raymond McAnally, Kathy McCafferty, and Samantha Rosentrater, together with Cariani, form a quartet whose perfrct timing and very present performances make the evening meaningful.

Review: Portland Stage's ALMOST, MAINE is Pure Perfection New work has long been an important part of Portland Stage's mission. Though John Cariani's ALMOST, MAINE is now a beloved revival, it owes its very existence to this theatre. This production pays tribute to that history, but also to the enduring power of the playwright's characters and his and the creative team's special understanding of the people and places depicted in this work. ALMOST, MAINE is one of those plays that not only captures perfectly a specific context, but universalizes it memorably.

Photographs courtesy of Portland Stage, Mical Hutson, photographer

ALMOST, MAINE runs from January 15 - February 9, 2020, at Portland Stage, 25 Forest Ave., Portland, ME www.portlandstage.org 207-774-0465. From Feb. 5-7 Cariani is replaced by Dustin Tucker.



SHREK THE MUSICAL Comes To Marshwood High School Photo
A hilarious fairytale is brought to life as Marshwood High School presents Shrek, The Musical.

First Stats Released For The BroadwayWorld Maine Awards; Watervilles TUCK EVERLASTING Lead Photo
The first live standings have been announced for the 2022 BroadwayWorld Maine Awards! Nominations were reader-submitted and now our readers get to vote for their favorites.

Matt Flinner and Low Lily Will Perform Winter Solstice Show at Middlebury Town Hall Theate Photo
Grammy-nominated bluegrass mandolinist Matt Flinner again teams up with award-winning American Roots band Low Lily to celebrate the Winter Solstice!

City Theatre to Present CHRISTMAS MY WAY: A SINATRA HOLIDAY BASH Next Month Photo
City Theatre will present Christmas My Way: A Sinatra Holiday Bash at City Theater in Biddeford. Performances are December 2-18 (no performance Dec 4) Fridays and Saturdays at 7:30 Sundays at 2:00.


From This Author - Carla Maria Verdino-Süllwold

Born and raised in the metropolitan New York area, Carla Maria Verdino-Süllwold took her degrees at Sarah Lawrence College and Fairleigh Dickinson University. She began her career as a teacher... (read more about this author)


Good Theater Celebrates 20th Anniversary with Ambitious and Affecting CAROUSELGood Theater Celebrates 20th Anniversary with Ambitious and Affecting CAROUSEL
November 17, 2022

The current production of Rodgers & Hammerstein’s CAROUSEL at the Good Theater represents the realization of a lifelong dream for Executive/Artistic Director Brian P. Allen, and the show that he has conceived and directed is both ambitious and genuinely affecting. Marshalling all the resources that this small company can command, Allen has created a chamber version of this 1945 masterpiece that preserves the heart of the tale and pays homage to what is arguably Rodgers & Hammerstein finest score.

Review: THE VICTORIAN LADIES DETECTIVE COLLECTIVE Confronts Convention, Gender Bias - and a Serial KillerReview: THE VICTORIAN LADIES DETECTIVE COLLECTIVE Confronts Convention, Gender Bias - and a Serial Killer
November 7, 2022

The Public Theatre’s production of Patricia Milton’s THE VICTORIAN LADIES DETECTIVE COLLECTIVE is a witty, sophisticated, clever examination of late Victorian mores, skillfully embedded with subtle feminist rhetoric, and all encased in the classic mystery thriller format. Add to this recipe a handful of zany, colorful characters and some facile repartee, and the end result is a delightfully period piece with a compelling contemporary twist.

Review: The Ever-Elusive SHERLOCK HOLMES at Portland StageReview: The Ever-Elusive SHERLOCK HOLMES at Portland Stage
October 31, 2022

For its second offering of the season Portland Stage regales its audience with Steven Dietz’s adaptation of William Gillette and Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s original play, Sherlock Holmes: The Final Adventure. The play, a re-imagined period piece, offers a low-key, witty take on the familiar characters and material with enough twists and turns to satisfy Conan Doyle fans.

MSMT Draws Large Crowd for Concert on the MallMSMT Draws Large Crowd for Concert on the Mall
August 25, 2022

What better way to cap what has been billed as MSMT’s Revival Season than with a free, festive outdoor event that, despite intermittent showers, drew a large, enthusiastic crowd? That is exactly what MSMT did on August 24 when it presented its annual MSMT Concert on the Mall as part of the Brunswick Downtown Association’s summer series. In a program designed to thank the community for its loyal support of the theatre, especially during the pandemic, the seventy-five-minute concert featured performers from the company’s current main stage show, KINKY BOOTS, as well as other local artists in a rousing and engaging program of musical theatre selections.

Resilience, Acceptance, and Change: The Healing Lessons in KINKY BOOTSResilience, Acceptance, and Change: The Healing Lessons in KINKY BOOTS
August 20, 2022

“Lola gains her strength from her resilience,” says Stephane Duret, who plays the drag queen star of MSMT’s KINKY BOOTS. “Sometimes she feels like an island, alone in this world she has created. But she survives. She’s got her Angels for support, her chosen family, and even when she gets a little slap in the face from Charlie, she comes back to their partnership. That’s her resilience.” “And Lola challenges others to be accepting and to change their perspective,” continues MSMT Artistic Director Curt Dale Clark. “I consider it important for MSMT to present something that can cause change in a community, and this show with Stephane’s and the entire cast’s unbelievable performances is doing just that!” His remarks draw applause from the capacity audience at MSMT’s final Peek Behind the Curtain panel discussion, moderated by Carla Maria Verdino-Süllwold, BWW’s Maine editor, on August 17 at Curtis Memorial Library in Brunswick.