News on your favorite shows, specials & more!
The One-Hit Wonderers show poster

The One-Hit Wonderers at Theatre Three

Dates: (8/10/2024 )


Theatre Three

Theatre Three illuminates the human experience with exemplary, intimate theatre by nurturing authors (read more...)

Theatre Three

412 Main Street
Port Jefferson,NY 11777

Phone: 631-928-9100

  1. View All Long Island Shows
  2.  > 
  3. The One-Hit Wonderers

This concert is sure to be the biggest hit of the summer concert series.
Each and every song you will hear was, you guessed it…A NUMBER 1 HIT!


Sugar, Sugar – The Archies 1969

Vehicle – The Ides Of March 1970

Brandy (You’re A Fine Girl) – Looking Glass 1

I Love You More Today Than Yesterday – Spiral Staircase 1969

Bend Me, Shape Me – The American Breed

Get Together – The Youngbloods 1967

Spirit In The Sky – Norman Greenbaum 1970

Hang On Sloopy – The McCoys 1965

Green Eyed Lady – Sugarloaf 1970



   The One Hit Wonderers, the band that’ll play the hits of the poor souls that went through all the rigors of putting a band together, have one hit only to vaporize. They left us with a catalog of great songs that we proudly keep alive, along with our dedicated fans.

When an accomplished group of musicians gets together with a singular vision it can be something special. The members of “The One Hit Wonderers”, are a review of One Hitters and have played with a Who’s Who of rock royalty from Chuck Berry to The Who’s Roger Daltry; from Loggins and Messina to the First Lady of Soul, Aretha Franklin; from jazz legends Wynton Marsalis, Larry Coryell and Victor Wooten, as well as classical virtuoso Leonard Bernstein among others. Today, the members of “The One Hit Wonderers”, the very same musicians who have shared the stage with legends, will perform the music of a lifetime. They will fill your heart with joy and your soul with smiles. This is the music you bop to, the music you sing in your car, the songs you know and love. You will dance all day and say, “I love that song!”. Sonoma Beach Productions is proud to introduce the accomplished musician and composer Gary Oleyar of Sonoma Beach Productions, LLC and is proud to present “I Love That Song” an original musical theater production. “The One Hit Wonderers”, has an impressive lineup of outstanding musicians and vocal artists bringing your favorite hits of the ’60s, ’70s, and ’80s to life! This show will bring you the songs you know and love, from a collection of many decades. Feel the warm nostalgia…feel the thrilling excitement of “I Love that Song”, Meet the Band: Gary Oleyar (Guitar, Violin, vocals), Kevin Brennan (Lead Vocals), Andy Huenerberg (Bass), John Colaiacovo (Keyboards), Lou Petto (Drums), and more that will be joining.

Theatre Three Frequently Asked Questions FAQ

Raggedy Ann & Andy (7/5/24-7/27/24)
Long Island Comedy Festival (7/5/24-7/5/24)
Ted Vigil - John Denver Tribute (7/6/24-7/6/24)
Beatlemania (7/12/24-7/12/24)
Bennie & The Jets (7/13/24-7/13/24)
Bad Animals - Heart Tribute (7/19/24-7/19/24)
The Brooklyn Bridge (7/20/24-7/20/24)
The Fast Lane (7/26/24-7/26/24)
Dancing Dream- ABBA Tribute (7/27/24-7/27/24)
Absolute Adele (8/2/24-8/2/24)
Pinocchio (8/2/24-8/10/24)
Walking The Line - The Johnny Cash Tribute (8/3/24-8/3/24)
British Invasion (8/9/24-8/9/24)
Woodstockmania (8/16/24-8/17/24)
Long Island Comedy Festival (8/23/24-8/24/24)
Matilda (9/14/24-10/20/24)
A Kooky Spooky Halloween (10/5/24-10/19/24)
A Christmas Carol (11/9/24-12/28/24)
Barnaby Saves Christmas (11/23/24-12/28/24)
Crossing Delancey (1/18/25-2/9/25)
Hansel & Gretel (1/24/25-2/8/25)
Dorothy's Adventures In Oz (2/19/25-3/29/25)
Ring Of Fire - Johnny Cash Musical (3/1/25-3/30/25)
The Adventures of Peter Rabbit (4/16/25-5/10/25)
Wait Until Dark (4/18/25-5/11/25)
Half Time (5/24/25-6/22/25)
Snow White & the Seven Dwarfs (5/29/25-6/21/25)

Theatre Three is at 412 Main Street, Port Jefferson, NY.

Theatre Three illuminates the human experience with exemplary, intimate theatre by nurturing authors, artists and audiences. As a recognized pillar of the North Texas arts community, T3 enriches lives by bringing engaging, provocative, and professionally produced theatrical experiences. Outside of performances, we nurture artistic skills by fostering local playwrights, training adult actors, and engaging young artists with internship opportunities and summer youth programming.


A Bronx Tale in Long Island A Bronx Tale
The Argyle Theatre (4/25 - 6/16) Tracker
Harvey in Long Island Harvey
BACCA Arts Center (8/10 - 8/25)
The Fast Lane in Long Island The Fast Lane
Theatre Three (7/26 - 7/26)
Fifth of July in Long Island Fifth of July
South Shore Theatre (6/21 - 6/21)
Beatlemania in Long Island Beatlemania
Theatre Three (7/12 - 7/12)
Hansel & Gretel in Long Island Hansel & Gretel
Theatre Three (1/24 - 2/8)
Fifth of July in Long Island Fifth of July
South Shore Theatre (6/29 - 6/29)
Peridance Contemporary Dance Company in Long Island Peridance Contemporary Dance Company
Staller Center for the Arts (11/16 - 11/16)

Recommended For You