Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

BWW Reviews: HAMILTON Lives Up to the Hype and Then Some

BWW Reviews: HAMILTON Lives Up to the Hype and Then Some

Once in every decade or so, a musical is created that redefines the genre. Lin-Manuel Miranda's HAMILTON joins that elite Parthenon of THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA, LES MISERABLE and RENT. The two-act musical rolled into the Ohio Theatre (39 East State Street in downtown Columbus) on Jan. 29 pulling a 400-boxcar train of hype it couldn't possibly live up to.

And yet, it did. With tickets ranging from $117 to $423 on StubHub, HAMILTON proves to be that "gotta see it" musical. Even arctic blasts of -23 degrees didn't keep the show from selling out on Jan. 30.

On paper, HAMILTON shouldn't work. It is an unlikely fusion of hip-hop, rap, ballads and traditional Broadway fare. It is a historical musical of what would seem to be a very dry subject, an adaptation of Ron Chernow's 2004 biography Alexander Hamilton. Yet, HAMILTON, which chronicles the rise and fall of the founder of the U.S. Treasury Department, won 11 of the 16 Tonys it was nominated for in 2016 including best musical.

On this tour, Edred Utomia puts his own stamp on the title role, originated by Miranda himself. Portraying a brash, bordering on arrogant, statesman, Utomia masters the subtilties of the role while delivering the goods on "My Shot" and "I Can't Say No To This."

Hannah Cruz is dazzling in her heartfelt performance as Eliza Hamilton. In songs like "Burn," Cruz uses dark colors to paint her character's agony as she is betrayed by her husband and then loses her son and her husband to duels.

Although he is "the villain in your history books," Aaron Burr (Alexander Ferguson) comes across as a narrator the audience disagrees with but ultimately has sympathy for, even after he has killed the main character. Ferguson captures the humor, the passion and the jealousy that drives Burr.

Jennie Harney-Fleming handles the complex role of Angelica Schuyler, who is torn between her loyalty and love for her sister and her desire for Hamilton. Her spotlight song, "Satisfied," is elaborately acted out on a rotating stage. When she talks about rewinding time, the actors and the stage rotate counter-clockwise as she retells the story of meeting Hamilton and setting him up with her sister.

As he did with IN THE HEIGHTS, Miranda penciled himself in the lead role of the musical he wrote. But his works succeed because he lets the other roles shine. Peter Matthew Smith, a CATCO alum, is a scene stealer as snooty King George in "You'll Be Back" and its reprisals. Paul Oakley Stovall creates a large shadow as General Washington, who is the only one able to curb Hamilton's ambitions. Stovall displays a wonderful vocal range in "One Last Time." It only lasts a second, but Stovall showcases his craft in his reaction when Hamilton elbows his way in front of the president to meet Thomas Jefferson.

Perhaps it is the little touches that Miranda included in the musical that makes HAMILTON so extraordinary. HAMILTON is one of the few musicals that truly rewards attendees for paying attention.

Miranda has five actors play two or more parts, but he does it so cleverly that one hardly notices the crossover. For example, in the song, "A Winter's Ball," Burr says to Hamilton, "...the Schuyler sisters are the envy of all. Yo, if you can marry a sister, you're rich, son." Hamilton coyly responds, "Is it a question of if, Burr, or which one?" It's not an idle boast. By the end of the play, Hamilton not only marries Eliza and carries on an emotional affair with Angelica, but beds Maria Reynolds (Isa Briones, who also plays Peggy Schuyler in the first act).

Also, Bryson Bruce plays both Lafayette and Thomas Jefferson, but he does it with such a flourish that it seems like it is two different actors. Miranda, however, winks at the audience when he has Jefferson deliver the line to Hamilton, "Have you forgotten Lafayette?"

Similarly, Jon Viktor Corpuz plays Hamilton's friend Jon Laurens, who defeats Charles Lee in a duel in the first act. Corpuz seamlessly transitions into becoming Hamilton's son, Philip, who loses a duel in the second act.

Even the way the show handles its lottery tickets is clever. Forty tickets are sold for every performance at $10 each via digital lottery two days before each performance. And of course, the face on a $10 spot is "the 10-dollar founding father," Alexander Hamilton.

With the show only running through Feb. 17, don't leave your fate to the lottery. Make sure you grab any possible seat you can get.

The Tony Award winning musical Hamilton will be performed 6:30 p.m. Feb. 3, 10 and 17; 7:30 p.m. on Feb. 5-7 and 12-14,. and 8 p.m. Feb. 1-2, 8-9 and 15-16 at the Ohio Theatre (30 E. State Street in downtown Columbus). The show will also have 1 p.m. matinees on Feb. 3, 10 and 17 and 2 p.m. matinees on Feb. 2, 9 and 16. For more information, call 614-469-0939.

Regional Awards

From This Author - Paul Batterson

Review: REVIEW: DISNEY'S NEWSIES at Southern TheatreReview: REVIEW: DISNEY'S NEWSIES at Southern Theatre
September 26, 2022

What did our critic think of REVIEW: DISNEY’S NEWSIES at Southern Theatre? Aristotle is credited with coming up with the phrase, 'the whole is greater than the sum of its parts.' Had he witnessed the Columbus Children Theatre's production of DISNEY'S NEWSIES, the philosopher may have reversed the quotation to 'the parts are greater than the sum of the whole.' An energetic cast, sharp management by director Joe Deer and choreographer Vincent Sylvester, and tight orchestration by musical director Lara Brooks lifted a cheesy musical to stellar heights.

RENT Comes To Short North Stage October 6thRENT Comes To Short North Stage October 6th
September 21, 2022

No day but today! Rent is the landmark, groundbreaking rock musical that defined a generation and Short North Stage is staging an exciting new production for Columbus audiences. In the East Village of New York City we follow an unlikely group of bohemians as they struggle with gentrification, love, loss and legacies amidst the HIV/AIDS crisis. Winner of the Tony Award® and the Pulitzer Prize, Jonathan Larson's songs like 'Seasons of Love,' 'One Song Glory,' and 'I'll Cover You,' allows the characters and audiences to embrace hope, find strength and survive. You won't want to miss Larson's phenomenon that redefined musical theater and is just as poignant today. Light a candle and join us for the catered Opening Night Reception Friday, October 7th following the performance! Get your tickets at or call 614-469-0939 Monday thru Friday 9am - 5pm.. Single tickets range between $37 and $55, $20 student rush tickets and pay what you can tickets are also available. Showtimes are 7pm Thursdays through Saturdays and 2pm Sundays October 6 - November 6. Learn more at

Review: TICK, TICK … BOOM at Garden TheaterReview: TICK, TICK … BOOM at Garden Theater
September 12, 2022

What did our critic think of TICK, TICK … BOOM at Garden Theater? Rarely can one sum up the message of an entire musical in three words. However, composer and lyricist Jonathan Larson sums up the message of TICK, TICK ... BOOM! in three words found in the middle of the song, 'Johnny Can't Decide:' compromise or persevere.

Review: ERIC CLAPTON at Schottenstein CenterReview: ERIC CLAPTON at Schottenstein Center
September 9, 2022

What did our critic think of ERIC CLAPTON R at Schottenstein Cente? In Rolling Stone's countdown of the top 100 guitarists, the late Eddie Van Halen described Eric Clapton as 'basically the only guitar player who influenced me - even though I don't sound like him. There was a basic simplicity to his playing, his style, his vibe and his sound. His solos were melodic and memorable - and that's what guitar solos should be.'

Feature: TICK, TICK … BOOM at Garden TheaterFeature: TICK, TICK … BOOM at Garden Theater
September 6, 2022

What did our critic think of TICK, TICK … BOOM at Garden Theater? No actors will be waiting in the wings when the curtain goes up on the Short North Stage's production of TICK, TICK ... BOOM Sept. 9, 10, and 11 at the Garden Theater (1187 North High Street in downtown Columbus).