Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: BRIAN STOKES MITCHELL PLAYS WITH MUSIC (Splendidly) at Feinstein's / 54 Below

Review: BRIAN STOKES MITCHELL PLAYS WITH MUSIC (Splendidly)  at Feinstein's / 54 Below

Musical Theatre Royalty. We've still got a few.

Oh sure, purists may lament the days gone by of megawatt Great White Way personalities like Merman and Martin, Alfred Drake and John Raitt. But we've still got Chita. We've got LuPone and Peters and Audra McDonald (still in her prime).

And when it comes to leading men, we've got Brian Stokes Mitchell.

The elegant and dapper classical baritone who first burst on Broadway over three decades ago with a booming voice and richly realized performances (from tragic to comic) in such diverse offerings as RAGTIME, MAN OF LA MANCHA and a Tony Award winning turn in KISS ME KATE, has proven time and again (and unequivocally) that he is perhaps Broadway's finest singing actor.

Now returning to Feinstein's / 54 Below for a two week engagement to celebrate the release of his new recording, Brian Stokes Music - Plays With Music, Stokes: warm, genuine, and with absolute joy reveals, in close and intimate quarters, just how essential and multi talented he is.

A consummate musician raised on the idiom of jazz, Stokes (accompanied by a fabulous trio, including Joseph Thalken on piano, Gary Haase on Bass and Clint DeGanon on drums) infuses Plays with Music with a refreshing pop-groove spin on such beloved standards as 'There's No Business Like Show Business" and "Hello Young Lovers," at the same time allowing the playful (and infinitely warm hearted) performer the chance to tackle, with detailed nuance, the moment to moment audience connection of a master storyteller.

From the playful infidelity of "If Ever I Would Leave You" (as delivered to an extremely willing group of female audience members) and the regal swoop of "Gesticulate" from KISMET, which Mitchell exudes with handsome and knightly presence, to "I'm Not Getting Married Today" (performed with breathless, rapid fire perfection) in Mitchell's hands, each song is a one act play of boundless vocal and emotional expression.

Tinging the evening, natch with a spattering of Christmas classics, Stokes' cabinet of characters extends to a deliciously nasty Grinch, and in one of the evening's most delightful spins, an original song penned by Mitchell, himself, detailing the Christmas list of the world's most precocious seven year old ("Christmas is All About Me").

Part of Stokes' enormous appeal is the unlikely pairing of his stalwart virility with emotional accessibility. To experience "The Man I Love" (with male gender pronouns retained) or John Bucchino's masterful paen, "Grateful" delivered with soaring vocals and heart swelling vulnerability is, in a way, to see an every man fantasy realized. Is it perhaps only possible in the musical theatre (or in a cabaret such as this) for man's psyche to ever be so beautifully balanced? If so, than Stokes is our ideal effigy.

An expert pianist and orchestrator, the focus and thematic tie for much of Stokes' tastes and musical selection seem to center on the idea of family. At Tuesday evening's premiere performance, the performer's wife, the actress Allyson Tucker and his teenage son, Ellington both were both in attendance and frequent cause for the continual twinkle in Stokes' eye.

Alternating between affection for them and for the sold out room (watching back in equal adoration), Stokes, with his heart on his sleeve and hand ever reaching for personal kinship, is altruistic and generous.

And with "A Wizard Every Day" (by emerging songwriters, Liz Suggs and Nikko Benson) and most especially, "New Words" written by Maury Yeston, Stokes, with alternating childlike exuberance and wonder, provides the evening with its greatest gifts.

Indeed, singing Yeston's lyrics:

Turn your eyes from the skies now

Turn around, and look at me

There's a light in my eyes now

And a word for what you see

We call it love, my son

Say love...

we hit on Brian Stokes Mitchell's most singular skill. For when showmanship is this burnished with ardour and passion, what, in truth, could ever be more royal?

Brian Stokes Mitchell: PLAYS WITH MUSIC - HOLIDAY! November 12-23, 2019 at Feinsthein's / 54 Below. MUSICAL DIRECTOR: Joseph Thalken (Piano) BAND: Gary Haase (Bass), Clint DeGanon (Drums)

For tickets visit the Feinstein's / 54 Below Website

Brian Stokes Mitchell's album: Brian Stokes Mitchell - Plays with Music is released on November 29th and can be ordered on Amazon.

Visit Brian Stokes Mitchell on the web and follow him @bstokesmitchell


Join Team BroadwayWorld

Are you an avid Cabaret fan in NYC? We're looking for people like you to share your thoughts and insights with our readers. Team BroadwayWorld members get access to shows to review, conduct interviews with artists, and the opportunity to meet and network with fellow theatre lovers and arts workers.

Interested? Learn more here.




Michael Anthony Theatricals LOUDER THAN WORDS To Play The Green Room 42 Photo
The Green Room 42 will bring Michael Anthony Theatrical's production of 'Louder Than Words' to New York City for a one night only engagement in The Broadway Rewind series. 'Louder Than Words', is a musical tribute to one of Broadway's most celebrated composers, Jonathan Larson. The performance will play Friday, December 9th at 9:30pm at The Green Room 42.

Quentin Avery Brown to Present WHAT CHRISTMAS MEANS TO ME at The Green Room 42 This Month Photo
Quentin Avery Brown, from Dolly Parton's Christmas on the Square and Tyler Perry's A Jazzman's Blues will make his solo concert debut at Green Room 42 on December 12th at 9:30pm. 

Photos: ​​​​​​Ann Hampton Callaway Parks Her Talents in the Arts Garage Photo
Her show was titled “Let’s Fall In Love” but the audience that filled every seat in the Arts Garage last night was already in love with the incomparable Ann Hampton Callaway before she walked out on stage. 

54 SINGS LADY GAGA And More Taking The Stage Next Week At 54 Below Photo
Next week, 54 BELOW, Broadway's Supper Club & Private Event Destination, presents some of the brightest stars from Broadway, cabaret, jazz, and beyond.


From This Author - Brady Schwind

​BRADY SCHWIND is an award winning writer and director whose work has been seen in Los Angeles, New York and across the United States.

Brady directed a completely re-conceived pro... (read more about this author)


BWW Review: JUDY KUHN Shimmers in LOVE TO ME at The Green Room 42BWW Review: JUDY KUHN Shimmers in LOVE TO ME at The Green Room 42
February 16, 2022

The beloved musical theatre star brings songs of love to The Green Room 42

BWW Review: PHIRO CHANTE PIAF returns to Birdland TheatreBWW Review: PHIRO CHANTE PIAF returns to Birdland Theatre
October 19, 2021

Myriam Phiro revisits her celebrated jazz tribute to Edith Piaf

BWW Review: LOVE, DESIRE & MYSTERY - IL PARLE, ELLE CHANTE faces DESIRE at The French InstituteBWW Review: LOVE, DESIRE & MYSTERY - IL PARLE, ELLE CHANTE faces DESIRE at The French Institute
February 1, 2021

LOVE, DESIRE & MYSTERY - IL PARLE, ELLE CHANTE faces DESIRE at The French Institute

BWW CD Review: THANKFUL: A BENEFIT ALBUM FOR JERAD BORTZ Provides Broadway InspirationBWW CD Review: THANKFUL: A BENEFIT ALBUM FOR JERAD BORTZ Provides Broadway Inspiration
December 13, 2020

BWW Review: THANKFUL: A BENEFIT ALBUM FOR JERAD BORTZ Provides Broadway inspiration on Rock-It Science Records